- Brooke McQueen: [to Mary Cherry] Okay, how do you know this person knows what we did?
- Mary Cherry: [in her over-dramatic way] Because they know what we did after we went our separate ways. He has vengeful proof of my silent shame.
- Nicole Julian: Explain.
- Mary Cherry: [yelling] I can't! Okay, I'm just too ashamed! Okay, fine. This year, for spring break...
- Suzi Klein: [as Mary Cherry whips out poster of movie, a parody of I Know What You Did Last Summer, lunatic voice.heard:] I know!
- Mary Cherry: ...I tried out for a horror movie!
- Nicole Julian: [setting up the trap] Okay now, Brooky, you know the plan. Strike a pose like a damsel in distress. And that will attract the killer. Now, when we scream, backup will run in and catch the perpetrator that knows what we did at spring break.
- [poses on bed]
- Nicole Julian: Try to look vulnerable and kill-worthy.
- Brooke McQueen: George, your heart may be broken, but the rest of you is fine. I know for a fact that Harrison isn't sick and isn't contagious. I know what Harrison really did for spring break.