"Sherlock Holmes" The Hound of the Baskervilles: Part Two (TV Episode 1968) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Hound of the Baskervilles Part 2
Scarecrow-8810 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
In this second part of the 60's BBC series, Watson runs for the manor after hearing the growl of the hound, understanding exactly what Sir Charles felt when he had a coronary. This time, we see that Stapleton isn't fond of Sir Henry's(Gary Raymond)courtship with his "sister", barking aloud at his "attempted molestation" while they were chatting. Watson discovers that Holmes has been in Dartmoor the entire time, and he informs him of the killer responsible for not only Sir Charles' death, but of the escaped convict, who fell victim of the hound thanks to clothes he wore, given to him by the Barrymores(Christopher Burgess and June Watson). Holmes and Watson, at first, thought the Sir Henry had been attacked, fallen from a hill to his death, but it was the convict, wearing his clothes. This episode establishes Stapleton's true nature, and we see that, in this particular adaptation, that he's a slimy scoundrel, with ulterior motives behind his actions which include Laura Lyons(Penelope Lee), a shunned daughter of Dartmoor's renowned lawyer, Squire Frankland(George Howe). Lyons is the one who wrote the letter, hoping, it seems, to borrow money from Sir Charles wanting a divorce from her lecherous husband..how Lyons and Stapelton are involved is one of many keys to solving the mystery behind why Sir Henry's boot was stole, and why she wasn't present to meet Sir Charles the night he died. We see that Frankland is offended by the mere mention of his daughter's name in his presence. Interesting enough, in this adaptation, the identity of the killer and his motives are clearly defined before the end by Holmes to Watson in a pub, unlike others which allow it to play out at the end as a surprise twist. Holmes plans to set a trap with Sir Henry as bait walking the path by the Moor at night from Stapleton's home..this, to his horror, was a blunder for the fog would be thick risking danger to anyone who makes the mistake of stepping into the dreaded swamp of the Grimpen Mire.

Again, the use of English locations make for great effect, and the only dressed set which didn't really work for me was the cavern for which Holmes was hiding on the Moor, the rocky walling just doesn't cut the mustard. I imagine I'm not the only one who gets a bit antsy with Cushing away, but Hound of the Baskervilles is really a showcase, if you think about it, for Watson, who does a great deal of sleuthing, asking the tough questions that are needed to get to the bottom of things. I think, though, that these released episodes featuring Cushing as Holmes will be a treasure for his fans...even if he's so little featured in the Hound of the Baskervilles parts of the series. Abruptly ends unlike the Rathbone/Bruce movies which usually have the duo recollecting about what they had just accomplished, in this one Holmes and Watson watch as the mastermind behind the plot against Sir Henry gets his just desserts, sinking into the Grimpen Mire. We see the hound make it's entrance in a savage assault on Sir Henry. I thought the other parts were suitably cast, but this may very well be all Nigel Stock's show. The parts one and two might have a rather familiarity and predictability to them because those of us who have watched countless versions of the Hound of the Baskervilles will feel like we have seen this all before. Since I like this story, even if Holmes is treated as almost an afterthought most of the way through, seeing another good version doesn't bother me none. This version has a heated confrontation between the Stapeltons, and the Lyons' character is established to a greater extent than usual.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Quite Good but Abrupt
Hitchcoc10 April 2021
I was quite satisfied with this version of the Hound. It follows the plot better than any of the dramatizations I've seen. It is superior to the Jeremy Brett one (my favorite Holmes portrayer). But I must say there is something missing in the end. It's as if they were rushing to finish it off. I was also a bit disappointed with the hound itself. Can you say "phosphorous"? Glad I saw it, however. I taught this story for several years and wish I had had access to this version.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Part 2 features even less of Peter Cushing
kevinolzak26 December 2022
The conclusion of "The Hound of the Baskervilles" (Oct. 7, 1968) again suffers from a paltry small screen budget and lackluster treatment, but at least it deviates from other adaptations by using the Laura Lyons character usually missing from better known versions. Peter Cushing's Holmes has even less screen time here, his arrival at the halfway point a long time in coming, and his matter of fact reveal of the culprit well before the climax proves underwhelming. Discussing plot points while swilling wine make this an often exasperating affair, its finale resorting to quick cuts to show a barely glimpsed hound as anything but ferocious. Even Peter Cushing's meticulous playing cannot disguise the feel of a filmed stage play, though Nigel Stock acquits himself well when Holmes is absent. The switch between outdoor action shot on film with videotaped studio interiors will continue throughout the remainder of the series, four other episodes surviving the years: "A Study in Scarlet," "The Boscombe Valley Mystery," "The Sign of Four," and "The Blue Carbuncle."
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed