"American Experience" The Rockefellers: Part 1 (TV Episode 2000) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
An amazingly detailed and balanced look at the Rockefellers
planktonrules3 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This first part of this "American Experience" documentary on the Rockefellers is mostly about John D. and his son, John, Jr. The rest of the Rockefeller clan (including Nelson) are discussed in part two.

The film, not surprisingly, begins with the birth of the family patriarch--John D. Rockefeller. It was interesting learning how his parents were such opposites--his mother pious and sober-living and the father a ne'er-do-well jerk! Despite his dad being a thief and scum-bag, John seemed to take after his mother--and had a very strong sense of religious obligation towards other. But, it was a sober and moralistic obligation--one that oddly allowed him to behave a bit unscrupulously in business BUT allowed him to donate much of his money in secret. This would explain why history generally says he was a miser with his money and never gave away anything but dimes to kids. All in all, he was a man who was hard to hate or embrace as a good guy--which is true of so many of us. The film also had some real surprises for me--the biggest of which is that the dissolution of Standard Oil in an antitrust suit actually made Rockefeller MUCH richer!!

As far as Junior goes, he had a big set of shoes to fill in--with a HUGE family fortune and a seat on the board of directors. What happens next is also confusing--just like his father. On one hand, the horrid 'Ludlow Massacre' occurred on his watch. But, on the other, he tried very hard to atone for this and did much when it came to philanthropy.

All in all, I really liked part one, as it was a 'warts and all' exposee AND it also was NOT a hatchet-job. At times, the film even managed to make me feel a bit sad for John D. I am not saying he was a saint, but there was some goodness within him that is often forgotten by those who paint him as Satan's BFF! As a result of this sense of balance and completeness in talking about the family, I strongly recommend you see it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Intelligent and well made, if cold as the subjects
runamokprods13 November 2013
Well told and intelligent, the saga of the Rockefeller family is one of the great American stories. There was a lot of detail in this thorough documentary I had never known before. I was never bored despite the two parts running three and a half hours.

That said, it was somewhat lacking in emotion, as, apparently the Rockefellers were themselves at times. Unlike the story of the Kennedys or FDR, or others that American Experience have covered, it felt like a great history lesson, but not a powerful film.

That almost certainly is a comment on the subjects, not the film-making, and I'm glad they didn't try to force this cold, distant and strange bunch into artificially likability.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed