Babies (2010) Poster

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
37 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
It's a Small World After All
cheryllynecox-110 May 2010
When "Babies" comes out on DVD, it will be the perfect baby shower present for any parents-to-be. From the opening sequence with its variety of birth preparations, delivery environments, and the way that different cultures welcome new life, the viewer is given rare glimpses of a beginning. From there the filmmaker features the developing personalities of the respective babies.

The Mongolian baby is swaddled and often left alone with the occasional rooster and later toddles along alone among the cattle. His big brother is a bully, but he learns to stand on his own.

In Namibia, the baby is immediately socialized with other babies and children. The community of mothers share nipples, grooming, and other responsibilities, but mostly seem willing to let the babies learn their own lessons in their own ways. Not only do we see babies eating just about anything discovered on the ground, or crawling through the dusty plains, but we also enjoy their wild joy during play or dance.

The temper-tantrum of the Japanese toddler was one of the most delightful segments of "Babies". The little girl's world, carefully observed from her first moments, is nurtured by devoted urban parents whose world view is from a tall apartment building.

Born to earthy San Franciscan parents, the American baby is the center of her parent's universe. Her world is full of books, pets and parks. Some might consider her over-indulged, but her parents seem mellow and mature as they prepare their daughter for a future that she'll share with children from Namimbia, Mongolia, Tokyo, and every other global neighborhood.

I appreciated many moments during the many vignettes that linked developmental milestones of the four babies. The film demonstrated how much more alike we all once were before we learned to abide by this ideology, or that cultural construct. Whether our nourishment comes from a disemboweled goat, a cardboard box, or a farmer's market, we all require a connection with something grander and greater than ourselves.
37 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Babies: A Sociocultural Documentary
hauntedmemories178 May 2010
I just got back from seeing Babies (Bebes) at my local movie theater. It examines the first year of four babies' lives in four diverse nations. There was no narration, which was a blessing, and nothing was translated. Thus, it was a true look at these babies' lives without any apparent biases, mistranslations, etc. I felt like I was back in my sociocultural ethnography class in college learning to view without judging and learn from each group. I would have liked more cohesion or purpose and the film may have been better if it had had a culminating milestone for each child at the end, but what was there was very good.

If you can appreciate other cultures for what they are and go in without judgment, this is a documentary for you. It also has extreme elements of cuteness, so if you want the "aww" factor, this may be a good movie for you. Unfortunately quite a few viewers in my audience were close minded and had a hard time viewing the film without making comments about what they viewed as poor parenting, so that is something to watch for if you go to see it in the theater.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
babies are the window to very subtly contrast cultures
chuck-52615 May 2010
With no narration, virtually no subtitles, dialog mostly either indistinct or in an unknown foreign language, and no music at all, Babies lets you paint a very wide variety of interpretations on it. You can't even shoehorn it into the stereotype of a filmmaker who only tips his hand a couple times over the duration of the film; the filmmaker doesn't show his hand in a completely unambiguous way even once. If this film turns out to not have a lot of mass audience appeal, my guess is it will be because of this almost militant ambiguity, more or less forcing every audience member to do all their own thinking.

Perhaps the most common way to interpret the film is a simply a huge "cute fix". This interpretation isn't necessarily bad, or even definitively overly shallow. What would be wrong-headed though is straight-jacketing the film so the "cute" interpretation is the _only_ legitimate interpretation, something that's definitely not the case.

Another way to look at the film is the real topic is comparative societies, and it happens to use babies as a window to get at the real topic.

Different values around and approaches to sanitation come up quite often; one could even possibly interpret them as the main theme of the film. Some of the babies are shown crawling around in the dirt, so much so their legs are a different color. And some of them are shown crawling around in shallow pools of water. Some mothers are shown cleaning their baby's bottom after a poop by scraping their bare bottom on the mother's knee, then wiping the poop off their knee with an old corn cob. On the other hand some babies are shown pooping in their diapers which we know they'll have to continue wearing for a while. Yes some of the things we see are very different from how we're used to doing it (which to be fully honest isn't always as good as we're used to thinking it is:-). But as far as we can see none of the babies ever gets sick - suggesting that sanitation styles don't matter as much as we think.

Different approaches to discipline are shown only a couple times, contrasting the "spanking" and "not spanking" approaches. In both cases we get the impression the baby can't even figure out what behavior caused the discipline (even though it only happened a few tens of seconds earlier). The message seems to be that trying to discipline really really young kids is just a waste of time. In any case, these few scenes are so sparse and so brief it's obvious they can't form the basis of a valid interpretation of the whole film.

It was clear babies need to see and touch in order to learn; they're very much concrete learners and aren't set up to handle abstract concepts. The baby seeing a slaughtered goat in the dirt or learning to eat bits of fatty meat from a communal pot or even watching flies buzz around some bare bones seemed to be on their way to grasping how life works. On the other hand the baby subjected to a bunch of mothers sitting on a carpeted floor and singing a song about "the earth is our mother" clearly didn't get it; in fact, the baby tried to simply escape from the whole scenario.

To some extent all babies want the same few things, and raising babies is focused on these things: getting enough sleep and enough to eat, fitting in with older siblings, figuring out how to move around and ultimately how to talk - these simple things fully occupy babies. What seemed different to me is where the babies were headed - some were taking their first small steps toward adulthood (although clearly it would take a long time to get all the way there), while others were headed for a separate period of "childhood". While the contrast between babyhood->adulthood and babyhood->childhood->adulthood was present throughout the main part of the film, it was especially obvious watching the somewhat older toddlers in the considerable additional footage beside the closing credits. Those headed directly for eventual adulthood started to play with and mimic the behaviors their elders used to obtain food. On the other hand those headed for childhood never saw an adult doing something they got paid for, and apparently had no concept of earning one's living.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Cute. Perfect for Mother's Day
WHYeat7 May 2010
Warning: Spoilers
They burp. They cry. They poop. But they also make life unbelievably magical. Babies. We all love them.

It's a documentary with cute babies doing cute things. The documentary follows 3 girls and 1 boy in the first year of their lives: Ponijao lives in Opuwo, Namibia with her parents and 8 older siblings. Mari is an only child and is raised in the ultra-modern city of Tokyo, Japan. Bayar (short for Bayarjargal) lives with his parents and older brother Degi (short for Delgerjargal) on a family farm in Bayanchandmani, Mongolia. Last but not least, Hattie is raised in a very "green" family in San Francisco, California. There is absolutely no narration throughout the entire 80 minutes. It is simply a collection of video clips with some music. There's really no need for narration because the babies' actions speak for themselves and completely transcend language barriers.

The movie starts with a short introduction of each city and each baby. After birth, two go home in diapers, one is naked, and the other is bundle tightly into a baby burrito. All are adorable. Being a new born can be tough. Especially if you have older siblings because they can get jealous. Bayar's brother, Degi, is caught on camera repeatedly swinging a sweater at his helpless baby brother. Afterwards, Degi puts Bayar into a baby stroller and rolls him out of the house and onto their family cow pasture - and leaves him there. Hattie is kept under closer guard. As her mother cooks, she is bouncing around in a baby seat with bungee cords attached to a nearby door post. She finds it curious that her view constantly changes as she is rotating on each bounce.

As the babies begin to crawl around, they get more mischievous. Ponijao discovers that another child has an extra appendage between his legs. She gives it a quick tug. Flipping her loin cloth up, she's curious to find no such appendage! She laughs. Babies are so curious and it's amazing how fast they learn. Mari finds that a round wooden peg fits perfectly in the hole of an orange disk. Unfortunately, the peg falls out once she picks up the disk. She breaks into a convulsing cry as she rolls around on the floor and kicks bother of her legs. She sudden stops to try again. Upon failing to fix her toy she continues to cry.

Babies is both heartwarming and enlightening. It sheds light on the vast cultural differences in the way people perceive and handle pregnancy, birth, and raising babies. On the other hand, there are fundamental human qualities that cross national borders and are shared by each child. The cuteness is only interrupted by shocking differences. The thing that stood out the most was the amount of supervision. Ponijao had all sorts of stuff in her mouth, even half a bone she found in the dirt. Bayar is seen popping up from a truck bed stark naked as though he had just woke up from one hell of a night. I was shocked, but they look like they do just fine. In fact, if you stay for the credits, you'll see footage of them in present day.

If your husband is on the fence about having kids, take him to watch Babies. I guarantee you that it will be the end of that conversation. This movie is chock-full of moments that will make you smile without even realizing it. Guys, you don't even have to hide it this time. You might even score a few points with the ladies for being sensitive.

Be filial and take your mother to watch Babies on Mother's Day. Or you can take her to watch Iron Man 2.

Bro-Approved.

Follow my chick flick reviews for men @ RatedChick.com
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A joyous celebration of the first year of life
howard.schumann6 September 2010
Having recently celebrated the birth of Liliana, our first grandchild, I admit I am a little biased toward babies in general and the documentary Babies by Thomas Balmes in particular. The film, however, stands on its own as a joyous celebration of the first year of life for four youngsters in different parts of the world. Filmed without narration, subtitles, or any comprehensible dialogue, Babies is a direct encounter with four babies who stumble their predictable ways to participating in the awesome beauty of life.

Enhanced by the inspiring music by Bruno Coulais, we follow Mari, a little girl in Tokyo Japan; Ponijao, another girl living in Namibia in Africa with their mother and eight brothers and sisters; Bayer (Bayarjargal) a boy who lives in Mongolia; and Hattie, definitely the most privileged of the four who lives with her apparently super aware parents in San Francisco. Watching their development over the first twelve months of life is a direct experience of the enchantment that life has to offer. The babies laugh, they cry, they play, they get frustrated, they poop, and they bask in the loving tenderness of those around them.

Needless to say, their experience of the first year of life is vastly different, yet what stands out is not how much is different but how much is universal as each in their own way attempts to conquer their physical environment. Mari becomes frustrated as she sets about getting the hang of teaching toys by attempting to place a spindle into the hole of a disc. Bayer unravels a role of toilet paper and then takes bites out of it when it is all undone. Hattie crawls towards the door during a parental ecology meeting in San Francisco as if to say, "Get me out of here, I've had enough of this".

Though the language is different as well as the environment, the babies cry the same, laugh the same, and try to learn the frustrating, yet satisfying art of crawling, then walking in the same way. Of course, those in Tokyo and San Francisco have definite physical advantages over their young counterparts in Mongolia and Namibia. Hattie has the advantage of cultured and literate parents who read to her and show her books with the title "No Hitting." Bayer and Ponijao live close to earth, naturally sitting with goats or playing among cows, having their tongue licked by a dog, and even drinking water out of a dirty stream, yet we are confident that life for Bayer and Ponijao, though culturally different than for Hattie and Mari, will survive and prosper by the loving ways of their own parents and the environment in which they live. You will either find Babies entrancing or slow moving depending on your attitude towards babies because frankly that's all there is, yet for all it will be an immediate experience far removed from the world of cell phones and texting, exploring up close and personal the mystery of life as the individual personality of each child begins to emerge. For me, it was difficult to resist.
21 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
baby, oh, babies
jordathan5 May 2010
I just got back from a screening of this documentary that examines (sans narrative, thankfully) the first year of four babies, one from mongolia, one from tokyo, one from namibia, and one from san francisco, more accurately representing the world population than if it were four western babies.

though the film as it stands is worth watching and is an entertaining piece of cinema, it never quite reaches the moment it seems to want to build towards: the humanity of all people. it settles instead for being a cute, fluff piece for the audience to coo over with numerous "oohs" and "awwws."

don't get me wrong, though-the babies themselves are great, and watching their different personalities operating in different cultures is the driving force of the film. it's a very watchable film, just not as poignant as it could (or maybe should) have been.
21 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
There is Beauty in the World
jchory9 May 2010
This movie shows the development of four babies from birth to about one year old. They are from extreme different cultures - Namibia, Mongolia, Japan and the United States. the movie is well-crafted - the photography and musical score is very good. There is no narrative. The movie shows babies as they explore, wonder and learn and I found it easy to create my own narrative as I did the same while watching them.

The diversity among them was part of the narrative. Namibia appeared barely touched by technology; Tokyo utterly transformed its landscape. It was interesting that the Japanese parents sang the birthday song in English and that the simple yurt the Mongolians lived in had an accompanying satellite dish. It is also amazing that each baby's unique personality emerges so early in their lives.

The universality of man was the other part of the narrative. Put a loincloth or a business suit on a man and a man is still a man. I wondered why are all babies so cute, be they humans, puppies or goats? Why does the first word in any language appear to be "mama"? Why were the animals so ambivalent and nonthreatening to the babies? Moms seem to naturally be tender with their little ones. Each baby experienced the struggle and triumph of learning to crawl, stand, walk and run just like the other billions of us.

This world has horrific evil, violence and darkness. But it also has beauty that about takes my breath away. People say "stop and smell the roses". Sometimes I find it good to look at a tree, or the clouds or stars, or people at the mall, just walking by. In the same way, I enjoyed watching the babies. It was a thoroughly entertaining and enriching way to spend 79 minutes.
54 out of 60 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Baby Love
Quietb-128 May 2010
Warning: Spoilers
"Babies" looks at the first year of four babies in four locations around the world. No narration, no dialogue, this visual documentary speaks for itself.

From fancy toys and gadgets to playing with a spoon or a rock, the babies do their thing. From birth to the first step the babies seem on equal footing, but you can't help think at some point varied opportunities will leave a few babies literally in the dust.

Four babies was the perfect number. Well photographed, a fun score and appropriate pace. Take a break from the explosions and in your face 3D movies and let "Babies" put a smile on your face.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Babies - a Tribute to Mother's around the world.
Laurie_Ann_Curtis6 May 2010
Warning: Spoilers
French director Thomas Balmes (The Gospel According to the Papuans and Waiting for Jesus) latest documentaries subject matter is very simply just Babies, but is much more than that it as we watch and learn. His film, entitled "Babies", follows four babies from birth to their first steps. Culturally and environmentally each of these babies are from very different parts of the world. Ponijao, from Opuwo, Namibia; Bayarjargal, from Mongolia; Mari from Toyko, Japan; and Hattie from San Fransisco in the United States. The culture and environments of these babies are very diverse, yet as we learn through the film, and through these four babies, that we as humans have more in common then our perceived differences.

In the opening scene we meet Ponijao she is playing with rocks with another baby and it appears as if they are grinding flour together, so different from our western culture. Or is it? They are mimicking their mothers, just as in our western culture our children play in their plastic Little Tykes playhouses, imitating the world around them. Then Balmes introduces us to the four babies by showing us different aspects of the four births; we see Mari's mom writing in red on her newborns feet, Ponijao's mother covers her belly in a red clay paste, Bayarjargal's birth seems to be a water birth in the local hospital and we see Hattie in the hospital after birth being monitored. Four lives brought into the world.

From there Balmes film is really very different in that it is purely observation of these babies lives. There is not a narrator to guide you through the story. The images are the story. We watch the babies sleep, we see them nursing with their mothers, we watch them grow. We see them crawl and explore there are hilarious scenes like the opening scene of Ponijao playing and then fighting with another baby. A scene of Bayar (Bayarjargal) taking a bath when a goat comes along for a drink of water, there are scenes of a moms group taking a trip to the zoo. Each scene speaking differently to whom is watching. I would imagine that the film would be quite different for me to watch, if I was not a mother, with those early years of child raising behind me.You could watch Babies at different points of your own life and take away something very different.

Babies seems to be intentionally designed in a way that exploits this personal connection aspect. One that provides a very personal connection of the audience with the film. While Babies may speak differently to each viewer it also seems to have a universal message. While culturally we are all different and the environments that we are raised in are different there is something universal to being human. While we watch these four babies grow, we see that these four babies share many more commonalities, than difference that divide them.

A great film for Mother's Day weekend really a tribute to a mother's love, and a film that all ages can watch and enjoy.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Cute and Revealing, if Spacey and Soft-Spoken
drqshadow-reviews30 September 2013
The name pretty much says it all here, as we follow four newborns from vastly different cultures through the first year of their lives. Without a spot of narration or even so much as a subtitle track for the non-English segments, it's a classic case of a film allowing its viewers to take whatever they want from it. As a relatively new parent myself, I was fascinated by the day-to-days of the two rural babies - one from the dust of west Africa, the other the grassy fields of Mongolia - and how completely alien their surroundings and practices seem from my comfortable perch here in the first world. It's tastefully filmed, with a particular emphasis on artistic framing and long, captivating shots of unsupervised children at play, encountering and discovering their world one step at a time. My young boys absolutely loved it, but at this point they'll watch almost anything with a cute face or two. Nice eye candy with a hint of deeper meaning, but not a show-stopper.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A lovely tribute to infancy and parenthood
Honu-866 September 2017
I've watched this film quite a few times now, sometimes as background noise while I play with my own baby. To watch the subtle differences and similarities between these global families makes one realize that, while we all may raise our children differently, the love there is the same. Each baby has his or her own experiences and discoveries which delight the viewer in their innocence. There's Hattie with her headstrong demeanor despite being born so small, Bayar with his curiosity and penchant for getting dirty, Mari's budding independence, and Ponijao's adventurous attitude. The music by itself is heartwarming and sounds almost like a lullaby in its own right. It's calming and, I'll admit, brought a tear to my eye more than once when paired with the sweet images of sleeping babies and their crooning parents. The love in this film is overwhelming and, while no parent is perfect, this film serves to show that children are a blessing and that every loving parent is the same, no matter what part of the world you come from.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Of course they're sweet! They're babies!
MartianOctocretr526 September 2010
Documentary style exposition of the first year or so of the lives and experiences of four tiny tots from four widely divergent cultures. We watch basically from their eager-to-learn perspectives as these debutantes to the world learn to embrace life through the cultural lens of their respective families.

The babies' individual stories are told concurrently, with little vignettes of parallel events shown side-by-side to compare and contrast how the rudimentary experiences common to all people are filtered into the different cultures and life styles, but not essentially different in the end. Learning to crawl, walk, how to interact with others, learning about self, etc. are all shown in the normal development chronology. The children hobble, falter, struggle, cry in anguish and frustration, make pratfalls, experiment, learn, and finally succeed. And then: move on to the next challenge in the crazy and wonderful journey of life.

It's difficult to watch the children when they fail or feel pain. It's also cute and funny as their unique personalities begin to emerge: the San Francisco baby has the most humorous moment with her logical and effective reaction to an irritating PC kiddy song. There's very little dialogue; only a few words by the adults is used, as necessary for a few key events. Usually there's cooing or crying by the little ones. The intent works: the kids are the stars.

A gentle documentary that intentionally paces slow and focuses on the babies and how they react. Sweet, joyous, and upbeat.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
There's a goat in my bathtub
ferguson-69 May 2010
Greetings again from the darkness. About 4 months ago I saw this trailer and knew immediately I wanted to see it. The word "documentary" is usually box office death, with only a few exceptions. Those exceptions usually involve penguins and Morgan Freeman. Sorry, no penguins here. Only babies. And goats. And cats.

Director Thomas Balmes from France had a pretty good idea - show the first year of life for four babies from different parts of the world. The babies are from Namibia, Mongolia, Tokyo and San Francisco. It seems his ideas pretty much stopped there. What we see are interlocking scenes of each of the babies at similar stages of developments. The stark contrast in environment seems to be the driving force of photography.

Developed countries vs. un-developed countries. Is it best to raise your child in the wilderness or in the big city? Does it even matter? We see babies rolling on dirt hut floors and poking at goat's ears. We see other babies going through baby yoga and group therapy sessions. Apparently the big surprise is that all four babies learn to crawl, walk and talk no matter the level of luxury or amount of parental attention.

Roger Ebert says all babies are cute. Any fan of "Seinfeld" will tell you that's just not true. What is true is that babies are curious and observant and creative. No one knows if the over-indulgent and over-protectiveness of high society actually helps or stifles the development of babies. What we do know is that life finds a way and babies keep growing and learning, whether in a hot tub with mom or in a bowl that a wild goat uses as drinking water.

I just wish the director had put more substance into the delivery. We are simply observers in quick snapshots of each baby. We get very little from the parents or other kids. The obvious points are made, but in the end, this feels a bit empty and probably better served on the National Geographic channel than the local cinema.
33 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Playful, unique but light documentary
mdnobles199 May 2010
An enjoyable, charming, heartwarming documentary about babies around the globe and the difference, similarity on their life as a baby. This was a nicely photographed film and a pretty memorable one at that but it kind of bothered me that there wasn't much dialogue or narration and when there was in different countries there wasn't any subtitles which was a bummer because I was really interested on what other cultures talk about on an normal everyday basis and their input on parenting and because of that it made the pacing sometimes sluggish with a series of clips that you could probably find on youtube or home videos but that still doesn't make it lose its charm. Overall there isn't much else I can say about Babies, it wasn't a brilliant documentary but a very adorable one that will lift your spirits high and I recommend it for mothers or parents to be but that's pretty much it. Worthy of a rental. More of a 2.5 out of 5 stars.
11 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
If you have a baby/toddler you need this movie
shadowsofthevoid17 January 2016
This movie makes me laugh every time I watch it.

However we use it to entertain our child. Babies love to watch other babies and this is an hour and a half of baby footage in high quality with no narration. It keeps babies entertained when all other TV won't. I don't think the makers of this movie had this intended audience but I swear if you have a baby/toddler this movie is a god send.

For any parent this is a must have movie for you library. It allows us to have a shower, clean the house, have five minutes peace.

Other than this its a great movie and I enjoy watching it over and over with my daughter. I love seeing how other cultures raise their children and it is a fascinating look at the first year of life.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Who can hate babies?
cricketbat15 August 2018
You can't really dislike this documentary - it's about babies! Who can hate babies? That being said, I probably won't watch it again. The lack of narration or true dialogue was interesting, but it made the movie feel like a ballet. And we all know how I feel about ballet.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
different cultural values equal different childhoods
lee_eisenberg27 April 2020
The documentary "Bébé(s)" (called "Babies" in English) shows the infancy of four different children in different countries. The absence of narration shows how the tykes grow up based on the different cultures. The infants in the US and Japan get all of life's modern conveniences, while the infants in Namibia and Mongolia grow up amid their peoples' traditional ways.

Watching the Namibian and Mongolian families, I wondered if they realized that they would get seen by moviegoers worldwide. Whether or not they did, it's an impressive documentary, letting viewers see the different types of cultures. It's probably worth noting that on the subject of Namibia, this month marked the sixtieth anniversary of the founding of the South West African People's Organization (SWAPO), which fought against apartheid South Africa's occupation of Namibia (and last month was the thirtieth anniversary of Namibia's independence from South Africa).

Anyway, this is a documentary that everyone should see as a look at the different cultures of the world. I recommend it.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Light piece, hard to stay attentive
uffda_775925 February 2011
The images of sibling rivalry and napping children are universally understood and anchor this film. Those glimpses of commonality tie families together across the globe. But the striking differences with handling a nursing baby, or changing a diaper, or establishing boundaries make for the most interesting moments in this film.

First World'ers will cringe to watch the baby from Nambia crawl down to a stream to drink some water. So there are some provocative moments in the film, that inspire the viewer. There are some moments in the film that make the viewer truly thankful to have First World conveniences.

But mostly, the movie meanders through cute images of children, with no sense of story or timeline. Just picture how long your attention is maintained looking through someone else's photo albums with no accompanying storyline or narrative.

It will amuse or interest parents, mostly during the few scenes that will feel quite alien or even alarming, but surprisingly my youngsters were completely unimpressed with the images of these other youngsters.

Plus, unfortunately, the US family is some New World hippy family from San Francisco who worship the Moon Goddess. The only hope is that their child seems to recognize this goofiness and runs for the door during one of their chanting rituals.

Basically, a movie that could have been culled down to 7 or 8 scenes of interest.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not for those with attention-deficit disorders...
MrGKB20 January 2011
Warning: Spoilers
...nor the hard of heart or bereft of intellectual curiosity, "Babies" is a straightforward look at the first year or so of four babies born in disparate parts of the world. Narration is non-existent, the score by Bruno "Coraline" Coulais is whimsical and thankfully non-intrusive, the editing by Craig "The Silence of the Lambs" McKay and Reynald "Rwanda: History of a Genocide" Bertrand is tightly focused, ably abetting the fine direction by documentarian Thomas "How Much Is Your Life Worth?" Balmès. Production-wise, no one can fault "Babies." Beyond that, I'm unsurprised that the gentler sex rates this film more than a full point over the males. Sadly, only a handful of worldwide IMDbers appear to have bothered with the film, and I'm not sure if that's simply a reflection of poor distribution, or an indictment of the nature of IMDbers. Apparently, it's just now beginning to achieve any sort of genuine international distribution, theatrical or otherwise. If it ever does manage to penetrate mass consciousness, I suspect its mediocre rating on this site will rise. If not, well, more's the loss to cinematic hoi polloi.

Documentary buffs will recognize elements of works like "March of the Penguins," "Winged Migration," and the like. Anyone willing to shelve their personal shibboleths and shove their cultural biases to the side will find much to enjoy, despite the lack of much of a dramatic arc beyond the natural progression of babies from helplessness to standing on their own two feet. And no one who deigns to call themself human or civilized can fail to recognize the uncomplicated theme of the commonality of experience and the universality of love from one side of the globe to the other. Highly recommended.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Infantile
JohnDeSando7 May 2010
What were they thinking, those producers of Babies? The documentary about four little ones from their first days to walking time is not imaginative, comical, or engaging. I couldn't wait for this dull doc to be over.

The babies are from Namibia, Mongolia, Japan, and the US. One or two are homely and sedentary; one is a born explorer and fun to watch abuse goats; the fourth is obviously forgettable as I haven't a clue about him or her-the baby swiftly left my memory. Intercutting among the babies doesn't even mitigate the boredom.

Just think about the last time you looked at friends' pictures of their new baby. Can't wait for it to be over? Right? Without narrator or inspiring cinematography, Babies is infantile.
14 out of 79 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A very slanted view of four families.
vdismukes-276445 June 2021
While I really enjoyed the babies and their development, especially since Mongolia was included. However, I would like to learn more about how the types and locations of families was selected. The choice of an Nambian family was interesting but I don't think representative of an African child's growing up. An inexperienced viewer might draw conclusions about which cultural setting was "better" and more enriching. Perhaps a better selection of families would have been to look at the similarities between child rearing instead of the contrast. And maybe there should have been a much broader selection of families and cultures. There was one very notable error in the sequence about the Mongolian family where the caption often indicated that Japanese was being spoken. I seriously doubt that the case---Mongolian should have been listed. And while we are talking about language, what was the language of the Namibian families. What ethnic/tribal group did they represent and what language/dialect did they speak? So much more could have been included to make this film a more enriching endeavor.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Watch it if you have one or want a baby (but don't expect controversies)
drazsika-716-81482014 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
We have a 5 weeks old baby. It was great - and very interesting to see this movie, primarily because
  • you never take a peak into lives of forgotten African (Namibian) or Asian (Mongolian) cultures and from Europe Tokyo, Japan seemed very unusual too
  • there is plenty of cuteness and tranquility in the fact that the 4 babies reach age 1 without any major issues. It calms you down as a parent
  • apart from babies you see beautiful landscapes and animals too


BUT:
  • this movie fails to address the facts that living anywhere as a baby in the world is NOT the same (2 out of 1000 infants die in Japan while 36 do in Namibia, not to mention diseases, pain, etc.)
  • we see the good, the smile, the cute and we see... ...boredom. But many of the other emotions as worries, health issues, etc. seem non-existent
  • you need to think long and hard until practices like circumcision and excision come to your mind


All-in-all: a good movie. Cute. Will make you smile. Will make you laugh. You might get some ideas what to do with your baby. Will make you think everything's all right. In Black Africa too. Don't expect a too much in-depth experience.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A movie about babies which seriously could have been conceived and put together by babies (with a little help)!
Hellmant16 October 2010
'BABIES': Two and a Half Stars (Out of Five)

Veteran documentary filmmaker Thomas Balmes directs and writes (from an idea by Alain Chabat) this film following four babies from their first breath to their first step. The film focuses on Bayar, Hattie, Mari, and Ponijao for the first year of their life as cameras pretty much follow them wherever they go. Each baby is also from a different location from around the world with babies coming from Mongolia, Namibia, San Francisco and Tokyo. The Blu-ray and DVD also features a bonus feature where the director returns to each baby and their family a few years later and shows them the completed film.

The movie is extremely slow paced with very little dialog and no narration. The parents are seen here and there but say very little, the video seen is almost entirely of the babies. There's no real direction or plot and the movie plays out exactly as described; just a year in the life of the four babies. It's kind of more like a nature documentary than anything based on people we've ever seen before. This has driven some viewers mad with boredom and I have to admit I was pretty bored at times and found my mind drifting. The babies are extremely cute though and there is some entertaining video.

I think the point of the film is to show that we are all the same just raised differently in different cultures. This is a pretty simple and obvious message though and although the video is cute and entertaining pretty much any filmmaker with the right equipment could make a movie like this. If you film babies for long enough you're going to get some sweet and amusing video , all you have to do is edit it together nicely. While this film is put together nicely there could have been a little more to it. Like I said of course the video is sweet, uplifting and enjoyable to watch but it's also boring frequently and there was just so much more potential for a better film.

Watch our review show 'MOVIE TALK' at: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBr4LOQxrmg
7 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nothing to go Ga-Ga over....
simmmz30 May 2011
French film maker Thomas Balmès has crafted a sleeper hit in the observational doco Babies, and whilst it is destined to satisfy the clucky, it offers an amusing albeit forgettable 79 minutes for the rest of us.

Tracking the first year of life of four little tackers across the globe, we follow the all-smiles Hattie in San Francisco, placid Mari in Tokyo, inquisitive Ponijao in Namibia and adventurous Bayar in Mongolia. The four babies' lives are interwoven cleverly, linked by key experiences in their development.

The filmmakers take a fly-on-the-wall approach, with no voice-over and no interviews whatsoever. In some ways this is a bold decision that strengthens the film, forcing the audience to view the world through the eyes of the babies. On the other hand, with little insight into their backgrounds, emotional engagement is minimal.

What it does succeed in is providing an interesting juxtaposition of parenting approaches. Gasps and shocked giggles filled the audience as Ponijao plays freely with the open mouth of a dog, and Bayer bathes with a wild ram. Contrasted with Hattie's desperate escape attempt from New Age chanting in a parental clinic, the viewer can infer various meanings. The most potent idea I took from the film however, was that despite location, there is little difference between newborns from one side of the globe to the next.

Unlike most observational docos, Babies is handsomely shot, with the occasionally stunning use of natural lighting, and the soundtrack featuring Sufjan Stevens creates a fun and whimsical mood. There is also a particular resonance to images in the film; Bayar crawling along the barren plains in the Mongolian mountains, and Mari gazing out of a Tokyo apartment window into the expansive city beneath her. Such moments invite contemplation back on those mysterious years.

The film floats along peacefully, providing the audience with some genuinely insightful moments, yet artfully dodges the excessive nappy filling, crying, vomiting and disruptive sleep patterns of babies, opting for a more ebullient insight into early human life that leaves us cynics questioning the documentary's heavily constructed nature.

Despite moments of power and a humbling reflection of baby-hood, the film is almost too passive in its approach. It is buoyant and light for its duration, but for the 23 year old childless cynic, Babies was nothing to go gaga over.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Just Watching Babies Being Babies
japamo4 May 2011
Warning: Spoilers
I am a professed baby junkie. Merely seeing a baby or toddler in person or in a picture elates and uplifts my mood and emotions. Therefore, I predicted that I would appreciate and savor the "Babies" DVD I purchased recently. My prediction satisfyingly came true. "Babies" is a contemplative but absorbing celebration of these remarkable beings.

The movie is essentially a "What if" stylistic experiment. What if we followed the broad outlines of a wildlife documentary, but with the subject being young human children instead of lions or elephants? What if we select a global approach by focusing on four children (one African, two Asian, and one North American) and compare and contrast their babyhood? What if we improved on the wildlife documentary and eliminated the distracting narration and commentary that purports to understand the subjects' motivations? What if we simply sit and watch the babies do their things and draw our own individual conclusions? It's a daring, risky approach and will not appeal to all cinematic tastes.

For example, if you prefer fast-paced, action-oriented documentaries, you probably won't enjoy "Babies". If you prefer deliberate, observant, leisurely paced stories, you will probably be more partial to the story. Of course, if you adore children, you will find paradise. The babies are the Namibian girl Ponijao, the Mongolian boy Bayarjargal, the Tokyo girl Mari, and the San Franciscan girl Hattie. We see all four during the interval from birth to about one year old. We see them interacting with their parents, their siblings, other babies, and their environment. They all exhibit the behaviors we expect from babies: wonderment, curiosity, contentment, frustration, fear, and triumphant satisfaction. We see them grow in experience and independence. Even though they may occasionally face an overzealous sibling, a scary gorilla and tiger, or a boring Native American spirit exhortation, all the babies exhibit spunk, intelligence, perception, and resilience. It's fun, charming, and even emotional to watch them react to something, and sometimes not even react at all as life swirls around them. I simply loved them all, and was relieved and gratified that their parents seemed to do so as well.

Of course, the babies' socioeconomic backgrounds run the gamut from the "primitive" savanna to the ultra-modern city, with Bayarjargal's milieu being an unusual hybrid of Mongolian farming steppe and technologically advanced yurt (including a laptop computer and satellite dish). But as other posters have commented, babies really don't care a whit about wealth and possessions. All that matters is that they receive love, support, and guidance, and they certainly do. Also, each baby is allowed a certain amount of freedom to explore his or her surroundings; no parent, when we occasionally see them, acts as a jailer or micromanager. They step in only when they have to (i.e. the baby is in danger of being hurt - which very seldom happens in the movie).

I think part of a baby's appeal is their ultimate mystery. Sure, we can usually figure out (from coos and cries) whether a baby is happy, sad, or frightened. But when they simply stare at something, what are they thinking? Nobody, not even the baby, really knows. I appreciate that "Babies" keeps silent and non-judgmental about that mystery and does not indulge psychological theories and speculation about the children's' motivations. However, the viewer may come up with some of his or her own.

The movie rotates more or less in sequence among the four children, which all more or less receive equal time. Again, the movie is non-judgmental about the children's' race and circumstances; for example, it does not wring its hands about Ponijao's "poor" upbringing or tout Mari's and Hattie's formative advantages (e.g. baby yoga classes). Babies don't care about those things and the movie gently reminds us that adults shouldn't either. All that matters are the love babies receive and the pleasure they give in return.

"Babies" made me chuckle with the children's unself-conscious antics but even more often made my eyes mist with their mere presence. The movie reminds us that babies are one of nature's (God's) true masterpieces and that their existence is a comforting reminder of humanity's ultimate immortality.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed