Broken Sun (2008) Poster

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
What a gem!!!
maxsappa29 October 2008
'Broken Sun' is an excellent example of independent cinema: Bold, ambitious and intelligent.

I do not want to spoil the story to much for people who would love to see it. I can only say that it is set in 1944 in the Australian outback where an escaped Japanese soldier from a POW camp and an ex Australian soldier meet - needless to say that after that nothing will be the same. By the way, it is based on a true event - just in case you are one of those who love films based on reality.

What I really loved is the complex relationship between the Australian and Japanese characters. They are both tormented individuals though humane. There is no bad person or good person to blame or to praise. You, me, nobody can can judge or understand the real meaning of war unless you were there fighting with glory or scared to death.

Ultimately, the great success of 'Broken Sun' is to show the price paid by human beings when victims of deprivations, indignities and excessive pride. War annihilates people firstly inside and after outside. There is no return when we fight for something with weapons and regardless.

What a gem!!! It is a pity that it was only shown in a bunch of Theatres in Australia.

I am looking forward to watching it again on DVD.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
a complete success.
ptb-823 February 2008
I have seen BROKEN SUN at a preview recently, as it opens in Australia for Anzac Day April 25. It is set in 1944 when a group of Japanese soldiers held in a P.O.W. prison in rural Australia decide to escape. This is a true event and is covered in the George Miller film THE COWRA BREAKOUT. In BROKEN SUN one young Japanese soldier ends up hiding in the remote hilltop farm of a lonely farmer, a man who fought and never recovered from WW1 in 1917. It is a great premise for a drama, a rural dream/nightmare captured in astonishing photography, some of it really un nerving as the Aussie bush can be even in the day when you might be disoriented. This is a small film but one that will translate to the cinema-going population of many generations because it is about being human, being lost, afraid and being lonely. It succeeds on all fronts and is a great quiet almost melancholy piece about young men in and after war. Two 'escapees' / soldiers / men in the forest or on an island or on the run has been done a few times before in US movies, but this Australian film is the most humane and visually breathtaking I have seen of this theme. I hope it does well and if it comes to any film festival near you, run to see it. You will be astonished. There is even one alarming scene that reminded me of the 1931 Frankenstein movie where the 'monster' encounters a little girl... in this film it translates into a farm verandah. In Australia The Cowra Breakout story is regarded with high emotion as in 1944 those Japanese soldiers killed or who took their own lives, were given a full military funeral; there is even a memorial garden in the town of Cowra to this day. They were considered very brave to have attempted what they did and as a result it is honored. This film has that tone. Many soldiers who escaped fell into an emotional void when they realized they could not return to Japan as escapees because it meant such dishonor; as a result they suicided in the Australian bush. BROKEN SUN addresses these dilemmas in a neatly beautiful and emotional way that deserves applause everywhere it screens. A very well made film about a very sad but compelling topic... and an event on the Australian calendar of significant historic importance that reflects our emotional image as a Nation.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed