"Stargate Universe" Divided (TV Episode 2010) Poster

(TV Series)

(2010)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Now the show is moving in the right direction
conan3524 December 2014
"SGU Stargate Universe" Episode Space is where the series stops dipping their collective toes in the water and starts swimming in the deep end. After watching Col. Young and Camile Wray butt heads for the power. We see the evil genius of Dr .Rush get physical, the teaming of Camile Wray and the scientists' vs the military.

The battle between the scientists' vs the military. Col. Young has been fighting this issue since before they arrived on the ship. Also this issue has played out in every Stargate show.

Now for my WTF moments; Chloe siding with Rush's team? The HR lady is leading the revolt? Camile Wray is playing both sides. The scientists don't see that Col. Young is looking out for all the people? Dr. Rush does not care about getting back to Earth? Why does it appear as if all the big brain scientists' loose their mind when ever there is trouble?
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"They revolted out of nowhere" says the guy who didn't pay attention to any other episode.
prjct-6408015 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
So the tension that has built up the whole season finally explodes. Rush tries to take over the ship and fails. We all new it was coming. It was fun to see the crew at odds with each other. Not my favorite episode but a needed one.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
S1E12
syntory17 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
By itself, the whole conspiracy story arc in SGU is not a bad one. It makes for a good space drama. I just don't think it fits in the Stargate world. This was another episode that was good overall. The alien encounter could've been better if they gave us a better explanation of where these aliens came from and what exactly they want with The Destiny. This episode was also one example where the communication stones were not simply being used as a writing crutch. This was a prime example of how the stone should be used. Also the interruption of the connection leaving TJ to finish things was a nice touch. Overall good episode. I just think better writing could have been done when it comes to the division among the crew.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Worst Episode Yet
jdwill-6238413 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The ragtag band living with starvation and dehydration. Two pregnant young ladies in desperation for food and water having almost neither. They are always having to face ridiculous dangers, ship is never fully functional and having extremely hostile groups chasing them and attempting to kill them all. The ship (who's name I am unable to remember now) shows the group this planet abundant with food, water, and good health. I have not given a rating less than seves to any episode before. Short story: found Eden, and the military used force to remove their rights of choice and freedom. TYPICAL 😢👎🏽 Shame.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A terrible episode that insults the viewer with unintelligent dialog and unused plots
the_elite8816 April 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This has to be one of the most unintelligent episodes so far an out of the blue mutiny insulting unintelligent dialog and unused plots. The plot is simple Dr Rush and Camille Wrayn stage a mutiny with every civilian crew member on the ship except Eli offcourse. It begins with Colonel Everett Young and Matthew Scott leaving the ship in a shuttle to remove a small ship attached to the hull of destiny, apparently it has been there for centuries and of the same type used by the race in the last episode anyway Dr Rush and Camille using the opportunity try to transfer ships controls to a laboratory in the ship, Eli who is in the control room is visited by Chloe Armstrong obviously to distract Eli (who knew she would let herself be used as a tool) but when Eli cant lock the shuttle in he soon finds that someone is trying to transfer control of the ship and starts locking the system some dialog is then transferred between the conspirators and Young, Scott, Eli and Chloe which ends with Chloe running to see Rush when she is told that the shuttle crew would be killed when the ship jumps in to hyperspace. More dialog is transferred and after a brief standoff Rush pauses the transfer so Eli can lock the shuttle and the remaining systems, Rush then locks down the ship during which Tamara Johansen and a crew member get trapped with the conspirators the crew member draws his pistol when the civilians would not let him pass the only gun in the area and the advantage and he gets a perfect opportunity to kill one of the main conspirators Wrayn but asks Tamara his apparent superior officer what to do and she says put your gun down something no one would do in that situation but he complies and both become hostages. More dialog is transferred and it is soon realised that Eli has control of the ships air supply and could cut it off in the conspirators area but Rush is un moved saying 'they occupied a larger part of the ship and that there is enough oxygen for them to hold out until Young's team dies of dehydration, but here is an unused plot Eli could have just flooded the area with carbon monoxide till every one passed out. More dialog and its decided to trade Eli for food and water but this is just a diversion as Rush wants Eli because of the restricted access and Young needs time to go on a space walk with Scott so they can gain access to the lockdown areas via the ships damaged hull and gain access for his men. Now the aliens from the previous episode turn up and start attacking the ship some more dialog between Rush and Eli revels that Rush has a homer planted in his chest next to his heart but Chloe doesn't as there is no scar by this stage Young has gained access and has let his men in and has made his way to Rush who confidently explains that it was nessicary to take the ship so all power could be transferred to the shields till the ship re-jumps into hyperspace in 2min or so, Rush's secret is reviled and it is decided to remove the homer which occurs later but is successful and the ship jumps into hyperspace and Wrayn says to Young that they need to work together acting like nothing happened and a smug as ever which really annoyed me and all civilian crew members are sent to their quarters (isn't mutiny punishable by death or life in prison) Chloe and Scott make eye contact and Scott is obviously hurt by Chloe's actions Chloe also looks disappointed and upset at hurting Scott but maybe she shouldn't have let herself be used in the first place what did she expect. Overall this is a terrible episode that insults the viewer the only decent part is when it is revealed that the conspirators are little more than cowards when Young's team subdues them one tried to act tough but when he was faced with being shot by Ronald Greer soon backed down another tried to run or attack a furious Vanessa James and simply gets a face full of her M4 butt. The writers should be ashamed!
5 out of 57 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed