Harlan Coben's Shelter (TV Mini Series 2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
146 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
It lost its way
npjy832 September 2023
The first couple of episodes were really good and interesting. Kept you thinking how the mystery is going to unravel itself. Then, it started losing its way. Filler episodes where it's excessive dialogue only and becomes increasingly boring.

The theme starts changing. From horror, thriller, then onto drama and love story.

Characters also change throughout as well. The geeky kid who is funny and witty becomes a serious person half way through.

As well as the theme and characters changing, the storyline changes also.

The profanity level is quite high, with excessive swearing in all episodes.

If the series kept with the same theme, storyline and characters from the beginning, it would have been a great series. Starting to lose interest in the series half way through.
56 out of 71 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Some negatives but two great positives
pacman-812 October 2023
The series on whole for story telling is average and surprisingly enough for Harlan Coban very predictable.

That said though I think the hype around the writer is why other reviews are negative as people expect brilliance from this type of show.

It's a good show and with obvious flaws, it has two fantastic positives in Adrian Greensmith (Spoon) and Abi Corrigan (Ema). I found the pair of them so interesting, funny and lovable. They carried the show from start to finish by pulling on your every emotion during the journey.

Don't be put off by the negativity but instead go into without expectation and just enjoy the show.
26 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A great start so far
jmcauley-118 August 2023
Really enjoying this show. Usually I get lost with Harlen Coben's series but this one I can follow. Maybe because I'm actually watching it and not on my phone. Trust me you DO NOT want to be distracted during this show. Something big happens in every scene, and the series moves very fast. The acting is great, with lots of fun characters. (The nerdy kid with glasses is really funny, and all the main actors are very good.) Can't wait to see what future episodes bring! If you want more, hey, hit pause and Amazon will even sell you the book! I have to write 600 characters so here you go Internet Movie Database.
59 out of 85 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Why Harlan Why?
WeWatchMovies13 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I don't know when I'm going to learn my lesson, I just need to read the book and leave it at that but nooo I have to always ruin it by watching the show or movie which is, as usual, nothing like the book and all characters get a color, rqce, gender or total character change, I assume to check all the correct boxes. Mickey is a nice guy but a boring character, Ema sure lost a lot of weight Arthur is the same thank god, that's it. Mickey and Ashley know each other all of 1/2 a day and he acts like she was his girlfriend. And Shira and Hannah, please. Harlan can you be a little more picky with the screen writes!!
40 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Potential everywhere
StevieBaby0927 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
There is potential all over the place here however it goes in some ridiculous places. The concept is great and there are some brilliance to the show.

The lead is a bit dull, I don't feel connected at all however the rest of the main cast are great especially Spoon (Adrian Greensmith) who is just brilliant!!

The supporting cast don't make much sense to me. The point to the 'adult' characters are wasted in terms of the core storylines.

There's some really poor editing, continuity and quality. In saying this I did enjoy the show but so much potential has been lost that could mean a higher score.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good - but language?
ghobbes3 September 2023
Interesting plot and characters. I always enjoy the mysteries that have a historical element to them. Cold cases, unsolved disappearances, wrongful convictions. I have to say though - the language in the thing is exaggeratedly foul. Gratuitous use of the f-bomb. Coben didn't write that way. He didn't need to throw in excess bad language in order to make his point or create the mood of the scene. To me - not an informed critic - just an avid reader and viewer - it takes a LOT away from the show. The screenwriters make it sound like they can't write a sentence without using the word f--. Pretty disappointing.
18 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Great start to a series!
aemilyl2418 August 2023
Not sure why people are saying there's so much profanity in this series. It's honestly not that much, the first f word wasn't until 19:50 minutes and the first s word was at 17:23 minutes (not like another review said there was so many within the first 15 mins - no clue what show that reviewer was watching...as reading that review I thought it was going to be very liberal with the profanity), as it honestly wasn't that much profanity, only 9-10 instances in the whole first episode, and they were very spread out within the episode and then had 2-3 within two or three sentences of dialogue. Also they're teenagers - maybe spend some time with them, as they curse a lot when not in the company of adults, so yeah...I found that it was actually pretty realistic. The background music has a bit of profanity, but the character's dialogue isn't bad...at least in the first episode.

Also if you've read the novel, yes some characters have been changed a bit, but Harlan Coben was HEAVILY involved in the production. I've only watched one episode so far but this seems to be ramping up to definitive Coben's twists and turns. Can't wait to see what else is in store.
44 out of 69 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Perfect balance of mystery thriller and cheesy high school drama
xwsgnx20 August 2023
Really enjoying this so far-it is hard to find shows that I can watch with my teens. I love all the characters, no matter how cliche they may seem on the surface I feel like the actors are all really great at portraying depth-and not everyone is exactly the cliche that they seem now are they? Spoon is my favorite so far...love to cheer on the nerdy underdog. The only reason I didn't give it a higher score is that I feel some of the bad language is unnecessary and would have loved for a writer/editor to have toned that down to make it a little more family friendly. But overall willing to overlook. It's definitely sucked me in and can't wait for more!
8 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A great show so far.
brett-booker19 August 2023
Not sure why people aren't liking it. It's hard to please the masses these days. They expect far too much too soon, some need to have a break from watching anything if that's how they treat new shows. However the show started off well, the mystery is intriguing especially with episode 3. Hope the momentum carries on. I don't see the issues with the profanity, it goes back to not being able to please the masses and the whiney cancel culture that has been nurtured in the last 15 years. Peoples just need to enjoy tv for what it is and if they don't like it, don't watch it because there are plenty of people out there who do and will like it.
35 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
An enjoyable YA mystery... but why so much swearing?
Tweekums13 January 2024
This series, adapted from the book of the same name, sees teenager Mickey Bolatar moving to New Jersey to live with his aunt after his father is killed in a car crash and his mother is institutionalised due to her drinking. On his first day at his new school be befriends Ashley, a new girl, but shortly afterwards she vanishes, he suspects foul play. Things get stranger when the local 'crazy old woman, known as 'The Bat Lady' addresses him by name and tells him that his father is still alive. With new friends Ema, a goth girl, and the somewhat nerdy Arthur 'Spoon' Spindell he starts trying to find what happened to Ashley. Inevitably several old secrets are exposed as well as dangers being encountered.

I read the book some time in the last year so was interested in seeing how it would transfer to the screen. For the most part it is fairly faithful to the source material. There are some obvious changes. The fact that Mickey now lives with his aunt rather than Uncle Myron this is kind of understandable given that Myron is the protagonist in many of Coben's books so he is unlikely to want him introduced on film/television as a secondary character. The second change is less explicable; Coben's books, even the ones aimed adult readers, don't contain much swearing but the amount in this series is somewhat ridiculous; there would scarcely have been more if Quentin Tarantino had been brought in to work on the script! Mickey is a likeable protagonist although his character seems bland whenever Ema or Spoon are around as these characters are so much more fun. The cast is sold although those playing the high school jocks look too big and too old to still be at school... obviously this is hardly the first show to make such casting decisions. The story provides a decent number of twists and there is a nice sense of danger even if we know certain characters are highly unlikely to be harmed. Overall I enjoyed it but wouldn't recommend it as family viewing due to the excessive swearing.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Why change the characters?
obnursesherri27 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
In the book, there is no Aunt Shira. Mickey stays with his Uncle Myron. There is even a series of books with Myron Bolitar as the protagonist. Why delete his character and create a fake Aunt?

Also, his mom struggled with drug addiction in the books. In the series, she does not. She has depression so severe it requires her to stay in a posh inpatient facility. With addiction being such a real and believable problem in America, why change it?

My guess is because they've also changed the race of the characters as well. Mickey is no longer a white boy who plays pick up games of basketball in the 'bad side of town.' He's mixed race and for some unknown reason his mom appears to be black but only speaks to him in Spanish. I can see why they didn't want to make the black/Spanish speaking mother a drug addict, but his mother IS a drug addict.

Ema is supposed to be obese, yet here she is another scrawny goth. Spoon's character is true to the book- an unrealistic over-the-top nerd who feels more at home in an 80s summer camp movie. Both are annoying. Mickey is chasing this hard after a girl he only met for half a day in the TV series. In the book she is his gf and they have a relationship, so it makes sense that he's trying to find her.

It's a shame. I usually like Harlan Coben, but this isn't one I would have chosen to make into a series. You can LISTEN to the whole audiobook in under 7 hours but it takes 8 episodes.

Also... is it ends like the book, it ends on a cliffhanger. So frustrating after all that time.
71 out of 90 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
So far so great
mykol-hamilton18 August 2023
I'm enjoying the heck out of Harlan Coben's latest series so far, just as I've loved every book and TV series by Coben, since the beginning. I sure don't understand the low ratings by some folks. As with every Coban story, it grabs you from the start, and doesn't let go. Compelling characters, twisty stories, unexpected turns. Fantastic cast (who are these goofballs saying the acting is bad?). All the young characters are well cast, sympathetic, funny and serious, as each is called for it. And there's no beating Tovah Feldshuh, Constance Zimmer, or Kristoffer Polaha. I'm excited to finish the ride.
60 out of 105 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The 6 stars are about right for this one.
joellyn-mumcian24 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I only started watching this (and then subsequently reading the YA Mickey Bolitar books) because I've been reading the Myron Bolitar series, which left me with more questions than answers. Enough said there. And, I'm possibly revealing a spoiler here) all I can say is the Mickey Bolitar books are SO much better than the actual series. Most of the acting is just average, with the exception of the four main leads, the characters of Mickey, Spoon, Ema and Rachel. I like them. The adult actors are pretty awful, with emphasis on Mickey's aunt, an actress that I've always liked in the past, but here she's just sleepwalking through this role. And to make matters worse, because of the licensing conflict between Amazon Prime and Netflix, Mickey's uncle Myron Bolitar has been replaced as Mickey's guardian by his aunt, which really lessens the dramatic effect of the series because of the conflict between Mickey and his uncle. Coben and his co-writers have tried to combine all three of the Mickey Bolitar books into this one series, to the detriment of it as a whole. I still mostly enjoyed watching it, which is why I gave it a 6 out of 10, but if you really want to understand Mickey's whole experience, you should just read the YA novels, which are very good.

Hopefully the Myron Bolitar series that is in the works will be better acted and much more satisfying than this one.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good start...WTF middle?!?
twin-chaos8 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
The series started off great, with an interesting plot. The first few episodes sucked me in with the mystery and background of the characters, then it went off the rails. The original plot become riddled with unnecessary storylines, swiss cheese sized plot holes and some extremely bad acting. Much of the series is unbelievably filled with unnecessary subplots that don't move the story along and just make the viewer think WTF and what's the point?!?

How is it possible that some 15 year old kid can run around town/school as if he's James Bond? Kidnappings, killings, human trafficking and of course throw in a gaggle of lesbians. Also, this kid is risking his life for some girl he knew for 5 minutes...it's just getting ridiculous.

I'm now invested after 6 episodes, so I'll finish the series, hopefully the last 3 episodes are as good as the first 3.
73 out of 93 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Interesting 8-episode series, holds together very well to the end.
TxMike2 October 2023
Warning: Spoilers
One issue with this type of mini-series, running a total of around 6 hours over 8 episodes, is that by the time you can judge if it is worthwhile viewing you have seen most of it. So it requires a lot of trust, that the script and actors will make it worthwhile.

My wife and I watched it streaming on Amazon Prime, usually two back-to-back episodes in a single night, and we both found it worthwhile viewing. Entertaining and meaningful, with a bunch of really interesting characters. The main downside is the profanity level is quite high, with excessive swearing in all episodes by most characters. Not realistic and mostly unnecessary.

It is at its core a story about human trafficking and a covert organization with a mission to stop it and rescue kids. In the first episode there is what appears to be an unfortunate vehicular accident, teen Mickey's dad does not survive. But as the story continues an older lady known locally as the "Bat Lady", living in a spooky older house, whispers that his dad isn't dead. So, much of the middle episodes deal partially with Mickey trying to find out if his dad really is alive.

The old woman is played wonderfully by veteran actress, and one of my favorites over the years, Tovah Feldshuh who, with appropriate makeup, looks older than her actual years.

Yes, there are a number of well-worn teen tropes on display, but the over-arching theme includes students who started out ignoring each other gradually becoming friends and working together to get at the root of the issues.

And yes, it is fiction, from the mind of writers. Not all of it is realistic but when we watch programming like this the main requirement is "Is it entertaining?" And yes, it is.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Did I Read The Same Book??
NicoleG12167 December 2023
As some others have said, there were drastic changes from the book adaption and they weren't good changes! The book doesn't even have an Aunt Shira so that threw me off immediately. Then there's a whole separate storyline of her becoming a lesbian? I guess they felt they needed to diversify the characters, but it felt really unnecessary to me and didn't add anything of value to the story. On a positive note some of the episodes were very suspenseful and there were some good twists. Another thing mentioned by other reviewers was the foul language. The cursing was really excessive which surprises me because it was supposed to be targeting young teens so I thought it would be a bit more family friendly. I have enjoyed the adaptation of other Coben books, but this one was overall a big disappointment. Read or listen to the book instead! Not sure if there's going to be a season two, but if there is, I hope they clean it up! So much potential from the book for the screen adaptation to be good. Such a waste.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Generational Trauma
not_an_octopus19 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I went into Shelter with no expectations or knowledge of the plot and was immediately drawn in by the story. It has an intriguing premise for a mystery and pointedly touches on themes of generational trauma, abuse, grief, and loss. The actors who play the main trio of high school friends (Jaden Michael as Mickey Bolitar, Adrian Greensmith as Arthur "Spoon" Spindell, and Abby Corrigan as Ema Winslow) have great chemistry with one another and an easy rapport. Much of the storytelling is reflective of different people hiding secrets from one another, which makes people behave strangely. I wish the storyline with Mickey's Tennis-Pro mother kitty (Narci Regina) would have played out a bit more, untangling the differences between depression and grief. The sex-trafficing storyline felt a bit muddled and rushed, and I'm not sure why because there was a lot of potential for substance there. The baddies in the series were a little over-the-top, but that seemed to fit with the overall dramatic theme of the series. In all, I felt this was an engaging and entertaining series good for a weekend binge.
1 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pretty good
ylopez-2379418 August 2023
Hmmm just started to watch the first 3 episodes so far I like it. It's interesting. I like all the characters. Again mind you. I have never read the novel so I really didn't know what this was about until recently.

I do like the entire cast my favorite would be the most know. Of all actors which is Constance Zimmer even though. Kristoffer Polaha was in the first episode and I really liked him. Anyhow I am looking forward. To seeing more episodes and seeing how this unfolds. I really like it. I would definitely recommend anyone that wants to spend a couple of hours entertained.

Kind of reminded me of the Goonies the way they stick together....
33 out of 65 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Almost
Headturner1127 August 2023
An 8 but I've only watched the 3 or 4 episodes released so far. I turned it off right away then went back because I looked and had nothing and I usually like Harlen Cobens stuff( well except the last 2 series I saw. I loved Goosebumps growing up and this is like it but more for a bit older target . It's funny because when I was about 10 there was this supposed haunted house near me but it was way inside these trees so we would just sit and look through them at it. Lol. Made me wonder if there was a way if I'd go looking thru the windows? Lol. Tho I'd never just in and be all hello, anybody home? Haha like they always do on TV. If there is a house no one answers almost 100% of the time people are all oh let me walk in. I haven't figured out the witch like lady and it seems like they are time travelers or something? Idk. I'll continiue and update if needed.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Dynamic and creative so far...
Spellbound8819 August 2023
Very new to me, as I've just watched the first episode. I'm a mystery enthusiast, so this is excellent, having a new show to watch. So far, it's such a treat, I'm really enjoying it, however, the cast is always my problem. The forced diversity, the forced racial tensions.....are just so redundant, repetitive and unnecessary. I've started listening to the audiobook as well.....only to find out there is no aunt in the original story, but an uncle. Why was that altered? There's a certain wholesome warmth I noticed throughout the show, and hope it doesn't get bulldozed by alternative, forced narratives.
32 out of 64 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Mystery Thriller that Will Keep You Guessing
Aretheu22 January 2024
Harlan Coben's Shelter is a captivating mystery series that follows Mickey Bolitar, a teenager grappling with the loss of his father and the secrets of his new town.

The series seamlessly blends suspenseful storytelling with relatable character dynamics, keeping viewers engaged from start to finish. Jaden Michael delivers a compelling performance as Mickey, capturing the complexities of a young man navigating grief, friendship, and the thrill of unraveling a hidden truth.

Amidst the mystery surrounding Ashley's disappearance, Mickey and his friends embark on a journey of self-discovery, facing personal challenges that mirror the larger enigma they uncover. The series effectively explores themes of identity, belonging, and the power of resilience in the face of adversity.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
4 stars is being generous
murphygreen848413 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
There are parts that are actually pretty good - but mostly this feels like YA trying to be edgy. In the words of detective Del Spooner "stop cursing, 'cause you're bad at it". I realize I've been out of highschool for a while, but none of the characters feel real.

Speaking of not feeling real, none of the actions events seem real either. "I foiled an attempted kidnapping - so I decided to hide the girl in my home instead of calling the cops"

Also, I'm 100% fine with gay and lesbian relationships - but if they don't have chemistry they don't have chemistry.

I get the writers are in strike, but that doesn't mean we should hire teenagers to write the script.
43 out of 53 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Want more
lucialuvsu20 August 2023
Stumbled across this show accidental click , so gladni did So far I think its great ! So far totally invested started to watch now need to finish , definitely got drawn in by everything going on. You have to like these type of mysteries, and if you don't log off and stop with the negativity people! Can't wait to see more on Thursday, the actors are great so far , each episode gets better and better ! Watching this series is making me want to read the book so i can see what happens next . A-lot of twists to the plot of the story, definitely trying to follow to see how all these people tie in together, cant wait to see more ! Hoping for another season!
14 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
like the group
SnoopyStyle22 November 2023
Mickey Bolitar (Jaden Michael) is still haunted by his father's death. He's living with his aunt Shira Bolitar (Constance Zimmer) and starting at a new school. He's taken with fellow new student Ashley who joins cheerleading with Rachel Caldwell (Sage Linder). Suddenly, she's gone without a trace. Mickey investigates with his new friends, Arthur "Spoon" Spindell (Adrian Greensmith) and Ema Winslow (Abby Corrigan). There is the mysterious Bat Lady (Tovah Feldshuh) in a spooky house. Shira reconnects with high school mate Hannah (Missi Pyle) who is married to police Chief Taylor (Lee Aaron Rosen). Their star athlete son Troy Taylor (Brian Altemus) is a school bully and Rachel's boyfriend.

I don't know anything about the book. I didn't know where this show is going initially. With all the supernatural shows, the reveal somewhat surprised me. I actually wasn't sure about that for awhile, but the premise does grow on me. As for the three young leads, I like all of them and they are a good underdog group. I even like expanding the group. I like the show. It's canceled after one season. I wouldn't have minded this group tackling another Scooby Doo mystery for another season.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Waste of time
kgygkmrhh4 September 2023
Im convinced whoever wrote this doesn't know a single teenager in real life. The dialogue and characters are comically bad. The plot could be cool if it wasn't littered with Disney villains and goons. Literally the bad guys are a creepy old woman named "Bat Lady", bald man in a suit and sunglasses called "Sunglasses Man", and some Eastern European guy with an octopus tattoo they call "Octoface". Nothing ever makes any sense at all. The main character is in love with a girl he literally has 3 conversations with. It's so cheesy I feel like it'd be better branded as a spoof of a crime mystery drama. Trying to pass this off as serious is laughable.
22 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed