Paul T. Goldman (TV Mini Series 2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
38 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
It is like watching Seinfeld's Kramer play the role of Marlon Brando's Godfather!
Erik_Surewaard2 January 2023
Wow! And I say that for a reason! This show is just so much different from anything that I have ever seen. Anything?! Yes, ANYTHING!

When watching the first episode, I was completely caught. And it was not only the story - which by the way is pretty interesting in itself - but more so on the way that this story is brought to film. It is namely shot in a very professional way - studio included - but with the real person as the main actor. And this is exactly what makes it special! Because the guy has totally no acting experience and he can't keep himself from smiling. It's like watching Seinfeld's Kramer playing Marlon Brando's role of Godfather!

So yes, it is in my opinion pretty amusing to the point of hilarious.

That a company like ComCast - with its valuable Peacock brand - is willing to experiment with content of this kind, deserves a thumbs up. But who in his right mind would have ever expected this to be so good. I mean... just watching the guy explaining how he is being screwed - literally actually - is an awesome experience to see.

And I hope that the actual mr. Goldman reads my review, because I want to give him credits for the most innovative tv format in a long time!

And the score? A well deserved 8.1/10, which results in an IMDb score of 8 stars!
18 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A send up of those terrible netflix trume crime series
rob-hodges897 January 2023
I'm not sure how much the titular character is aware of what's happening, and it's hard to have sympathy for he comes across as quite an unlikeable egomaniac. For fans of obscure B-movies, he is essentially a Neil Breen type character, who is caught in the writers' and director's web. He thinks they are making an emmy-level documenatry while they essentially parody the recent spate of cheap Netflix true crime documentaries (e.g The Tinder Swindler). By largely allowing Paul T. Goldman to tell the story, and leaning into the more asburd elements of the story (e.g a psychic medium), they beging to reveal the embellishments and question if any of this really happened. In turn, this makes it much more honest than other so-called true crimes. Your enjoyment of the show will depend on whether you can tolerate the strange title character, and enjoy seeing a well-loved genre be torn apart.
12 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Interesting
df16699n22 January 2023
I think the best word that can be used to describe Paul T. Goldman would be: Interesting. When I say that it is interesting, I do not mean that in a good way or a bad way. In fact, I don't know whether I loved the show or was disgusted by it. However, I will say that this show is very unique and unlike anything else you will see on TV, so that is a huge plus for the series. It is definitely out of the box, but if that is what you are in to you will most likely enjoy this show. I didn't know how to feel about the subject matter most of the time, but through it all, I still found myself intrigued and interested enough to keep watching till the very satisfying finale. This series has its flaws in my opinion, but overall I think that it is worth the watch due to how unique and innovative it is. There were times where I was even questioning if Paul T. Goldman was even a real guy or if he was just some famous actor in disguise pulling a prank, and honestly if that where true, that wouldn't have even been as surprising as some of the other plots in this show. With all this being said, all the mystery and ambiguity is what makes this show work and I think audiences will enjoy Paul T. Goldman if they give it a chance. (Also, what does the T in Paul T. Goldman stand for?)
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Most intriguing format I've ever seen
dahveed31116 January 2023
I love the format of this show. There are so many layers to it and is the most interesting thing I've seen on TV in years. For all of the people saying this is parody; you're completely missing the point. This whole enterprise is bursting with sincerity. For a decade, Paul has been trying to get his stories told through a movie/series. The production team he is working with is making that happen for him, and presenting it in a truly fascinating spectacle. There's interviews with real parties involved, re-enactments written by Paul, real behind the scenes footage documenting this, and re-enactments of behind the scenes as Paul wants to tell it. This blending of storytelling is a warm welcome in the current landscape of mediocre unoriginality.
25 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A hilarious One-Man Rabbit Hole
rowjlan14 January 2023
Paul T. Goldman is part Tommy Wiseau from "The Room," part Forrest Gump, a dash of Gene Wilder, a healthy dose of straight up "Florida Man," and all parts ridiculously funny.

His story never stops spiraling, from seriousness to absurdity and back again, like "Serial" meets "The Rehearsal." The more Paul tells us about his life, the less we believe him, and the harder we laugh and shake our heads.

While the show continually "zooms out" to the behind-the-scenes, and even behind-the-behind-the-scenes, for all its confusion it tells the story of a man who is so wildly unpredictable you can't take your eyes off him.

One of the few new shows that made me want ti rewatch episodes. I seriously hope there's another season. Who knows what zany adventure this guy is going to get into next.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Intriguing, hope it ends up being worthwhile
smoratti3 January 2023
Having watched three episodes it was entertaining, though the main character gets more annoting as time goes on - I can see why his wives left him! It is next to impossible to tell what is real or not - maybe the whole show is one big spoof in which case I will be rather annoyed at the end.

Still I will keep watching though with guarded reservations. Its also not clear whether the movie in a movie concept is real or just something for the show - e..g will it see the light of day separately.

If it turns out that the whole show is fake then the lead character Paul deserves an Oscar for playing someone so gormless so well.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Under-rated
scl75616 January 2023
This is original and highly entertaining. The creators manage to balance out the self indulgent nature of Goldman, as well as the tragi-comédie of his life story. Despite this naive protagonist being horribly duped and taken advantage of, this is by and large a comedy. Am quite surprised by the relatively low rating here (I think many are taking it too seriously) and think it deserves more credit for a really enjoyable spin on true crime storytelling. While one can't help but laugh at the goofy Finkelman/Goldman throughout, he is certainly lovable enough to garner the necessary sympathy to convince the viewer to root for him. I found this far more entertaining than almost anything else on the major networks.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
This is "The Room" of TV shows
Vivaladas3 February 2023
I've only watched 2 episodes so far, but I felt a need to see if anyone had similar feelings as I do. If you've ever seen the cult movie "The Room" written, directed and starring Tommy Wiseau, often referred to as the best, worst movie ever...this has that feel. This feels like everyone involved was highly aware of what the end product would end up being by having the title "character" Paul as the lead actor, if they kept this a straight series. They had the foresight to have a hybrid series/behind the scenes documentary, so the audience is in on the whole process of what this project is and how it came to be. I'm all here for it. They all look like they are having fun telling this crazy story and I can't look away for some reason. Kudos to all the actual actors in this.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I'm not a wimp anymore.
daphneismyname22 January 2023
What if Werner Herzog and Nathan Fielder had a child?

They would have named him Paul T. Goldman.

The line between real and fiction is a thin and blurry one, often crossing and blending together in various forms of media. In literature, for example, authors often take inspiration from real-life events and people, but then add their own imagination and creative twists to create a fictional story. In film and television, real-life events and people are often depicted in a fictionalized manner, blurring the line between fact and fiction even further. Thanks ChatGPT for providing 400 characters needed it to publish this review.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Weird journey.
bfondurulia25 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I went through a very bizarre life situation that let to a very strange divorce starting in 10/2021. It was so absolutely opposite of the reality that I'd been living I very much began to question the reality of the whole thing. I know that I acted erratically during this time but it was a very tumultuous time in my life.

I really had no interest in this show until I was bored one day and watched the first episode. Going through what I went through I immediately related to this guy and when it ended to where he's basically just a guy that's been scammed and tries everything to justify this just to feel normal.... I get it and frankly it was very depressing to feel that again. If this is actually remotely a true story (obviously the weird fantasy of sex trafficking and the chronicles are fantasy) then I both feel sorry for the guy but basically because he's a person that simply can't admit to himself that he was duped twice and that his beloved son simply left for his mom. This is a sad story overall for multiple reasons but promise you I totally understand trying to figure out if you're living in a fantasy world or not and waking up to simple reality though difficult is a very cathartic experience.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
2/3rds off the mark
jjr427 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
At one point the main protagonist says "i wrote it with a two hours movie in mind, but it needs to be a series"

Too bad, it would have been a great two hour mini series worth a 6 or 7 star rating.

This is both a sad and ironic tale of a man whose real life hurt turns him into a raging mythomane.

The work by the producers/director is great as it leads us neatly from accepting this man as unbelievably wronged, taking a courageous even if conceited stand, to realising that he has invented / made himself believe most of what he told us.

Therefore it is also an intelligent warning about how we're at risk of being manipulated by any true crimes program, the producers of which would not be as honest.

But god it's awfully too long to get from point A to Z.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Chaotic in the most amazing way.
sallythedoll24 January 2023
This guy is a real life Michael Scott. It reminds me of his he wrote screenplay of Michael Scarn. He's kooky but has an innocence to him that makes him likeable. His life is unbelievable sure, but mainly because of what he does and the choices he makes. The cast is unbelievable, and help make the story come to life. The way it all unfolds is creative and you get a real life behind the scenes as it's told. One of the most entertaining series I've watched in a long time and I haven't been this excited about a show since Tiger King. I binge watched it all in one night. Definitely worth your time.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Just lost a star - On Episode 4
thejdrage25 November 2023
This seems to be an interesting Vanity therapy project done in, as one reviewer put it, a most intriguing format. Also, had to stop watching after Episode 4. It went literally from fact to fiction and I wasn't in the mood for his fiction.

The more I get to know Mr. Goldman (NOT his real name), the more I understand why women who are legitimately looking for a long-term relationship don't go back for a second date. And why people who are looking for targets chose "this guy".

There are some excellent character actors in this limited series: W. Earl Brown (Tombstone), James Remar (Dexter), Dennis Haysbert (24, but you'll recognize him and his voice!), Christopher Stanley (Mad Men and tons of other shows), Paul Ben-Victor (In Plain Sight, Mad Men) and, Melinda McGraw (too many shows to list!) deserves all kinds of awards for putting up with "him"!

Goldman is childlike as he tells his story of seeking revenge and it shows many people trying to wrangle him to make this series successful in spite of himself. And it's actually a unique and fun format! Brilliant in hindsight,.

Goldman makes some major errors, but he still didn't deserve to be a victim of any kind. None of us do.

Goldman did something about it - and we can take some hints from him! (On how not to do things, if nothing else, including not to be an actor in your own autobiography.)

It is interesting on so many levels. Give it a go. Make your own decisions.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Highly Entertaining, BUT...
rachelgeorge-1334913 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I think it's cool he lived it, he wrote it, he's acting it. It's the perfect balance of laughing with him and laughing at him...the crew calling him out on lies is hilarious. It's also very entertaining the scenes and dialogue he has to make up, especially what he thinks women would say or do. I did get offended by his line "Typical hooker: no brain" when in fact most if not all prostitutes I've met are very resourceful and a lifestyle like that requires brains. Interesting he judges woman that way when the story he is telling demonstrates time and time again, he is the one lacking brains. I guess his naivety makes him kind of sweet but he's also terribly ignorant.
20 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Started off good
katiekakes-8372517 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Started off great. Interesting story, interesting concept, interesting way to make a series. As I continued watching I realized this is just a narcissist who got a chance to make a TV show. He takes his son on first dates with him, he uses his relationship with his son's mother as a sob story when he was a willing participant and initiated the whole thing. He plays the victim card very well. He's a seemingly good guy who got screwed over, except as he goes on he tells us he has made up a lot of it. "This is the script now, it will be great," is a line he likes to use. Instead of embellishing the end, he should have just kept it as the truth. He would have been much more sympathetic and much more likeable. I am writing this review with the last episode not yet released and I will watch the last episode, only because I have to see what nonsense he comes up with for the ending. Don't waste your time.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Quirky, Unique and Out of the Ordinary
dancingvegan17 January 2023
I love the premise that a non-actor played the lead role about a story that actually happened to him in real life.

I do understand that It was probably a bit frustrating for the actors and the entire crew to work with someone with no acting experience. But, hey, who better to play the part than this quirky, gullible and real man? I found it refreshing!

The way the movie was put together is quite rare and I love rarities in life and in movies.

I have done some writing about things that have happened to me and if there isn't some sort of embellishment of a true story you might not grab the audience's attention as well. And, in my eyes, and my words, there is nothing wrong in embellishing.

Kudos to all the non-actors. Actors, director, and the rest of the entire crew for presenting something so quirky, unique and out of the ordinary!!
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gump, Borat, and Rudy, all-in-one
moneillg20 June 2023
Jason Woliner does a wonderful job directing the spectacular train wreck that is Paul Finkelman's life. You root for him, you laugh, you feel sorry for him. Some of the best scenes are Woliner's, and the actors, expressions when getting "input" from Finkelman. Some of the saddest moments are the candid shots when the uber-lonely Finkelman appears to be hitting on the actresses in the series. You really do feel bad for the way Finkelman gets manipulated. But, true to his credo, he turns lemons into lemonade by getting his story both published and filmed. Finkelman is Borat, Forrest Gump, and Rudy, all rolled into a oddly lovable guy who punches above his weight class in this uniquely weird series. Totally worth watching.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Highly Recommend! Good story and overall very entertaining
cparsons-3939722 January 2023
I don't write reviews for movies or shows but I feel this one needs to be bumped up higher in people's watch lists. The editing is top notch and the story is a great lesson in understanding why facts and context matter! For those who quit the show a few episodes in, consider watching it all the way through!

Pasting 2 more times to beat the minimum character limit! 😀

I don't write reviews for movies or shows but I feel this one needs to be bumped up higher in people's watch lists. The editing is top notch and the story is a great lesson in understanding why facts and context matter!

I don't write reviews for movies or shows but I feel this one needs to be bumped up higher in people's watch lists. The editing is top notch and the story is a great lesson in understanding why facts and context matter!
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
This guy is an a$$hole
kelbel-081606 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I almost turned this off after the first few episodes because this guy is so impressed with himself and has absolutely no self awareness-it's physically painful to watch. The doc trailer teased a turn at the end so I hung in there.

It only gets interesting when you start uncovering all this guy's bullish!t-which is a mountain. If I could slap his face off of his head, I would. And if you watch the other actors throughout the first few episodes, you'll see them resisting his punchability as well. They're all saints for being nice to him.

The General should fire him. He mentions and is on film several times answering insurance calls, and seems to think it's below him.

He also doesn't respect women. He pretends to. He purchases a mail order bride and divorced her when he stops getting sex. He marries a second woman and actually admits there was no emotional connection when he thinks she's finally going to open up to him. He calls women "h- - kers" and refers to "pu$$y" and has a full on funeral with naked women (bc if you are a secks worker you obviously still mourn in skimpy dresses). * HARD EYEROLL*. He immediately turns convo back to himself when Roseanne argue tre is talking about the actual real work she does to help women. He's desperate, disgusting trash.

One thing that didn't add up, if this lady married him for his money, how does he have businesses and multiple homes answering insurance calls? Why is he living in an apt?

This poor director.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
We (the viewers & reviewers) are the joke.
theiges17 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Based on its social media hype, I sat down today to binge the series. Have officially finished Episode Five.

The story is initially incredulous, jaw-dropping, hilarious in an only-would-happen-in-Florida way and I could not get enough of each episode.

While this has been well thought through & elements have been placed to make the viewer believe it's legit--Amazon book placement, YouTube posts, etc.-we have each been duped. And for that it makes it all the more brilliant. Paul T. Goldman (Finkelstein) is the perfect foil for us to get invested in every next episode.

With Episode Six looming and to be loaded in a few days, I do believe that Paul T. Goldman is...Steve Carrell in some ground breaking prosthetics & beautiful CGI.

Seth, Evan and the entire back and front of camera team...very, very well done!
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This man is a putz with a story to tell....
aelaennn3 January 2023
As you keep watching, you start to realize that he is not always totally honest. Who doesn't embellish once in a while, but this is supposed to be a true story.

He is now writing detective novels based on himself and his story under the pseudonym Ryan Sinclair.

I hate to leave a bad review, but I am struggling to see the point of this show. I think Seth Rogan was just super baked when he got the raw footage, and thought he could turn it into something interesting.

The format is interesting, but you can see the raw pity on all the actor's faces in the 4th wall breaks. I would feel for this man, if i felt i could believe his story is 100% the truth, but he has already admitted to embellishing by the 2nd episode.
29 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Nerds rule!
mageh22 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This is one of the most unique concepts I saw for true crime/true story series.

Yes, it is not perfect, but definitely beyond entertaining. As other reviewers noted, it evokes a range of emotions and yet left me with a good feeling in the end.

To summarize, this is a story where average guy, nerd so to speak got taken advantage by a classic "gold digger".

These series are a personal revenge and vindication for what she has done. It seems like he was especially hurt by her since she took advantage of his vulnerability and practically got away with it. The series make him sort of celebrity, "somebody" after she probably made him fill worthless.

Overall, highly recommended for entertainment value and please, watch till the end. It makes the whole difference.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Bless his heart, he just wanted love!
MyMovieTVRomance26 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This was all over the place- a lighthearted docu-series dealing with heavy topics, centered around a fun, funny guy. But don't laugh too loud, cause ultimately, it's a sad cautionary tale that made me cry.

The one issue I have is that they kinda gave away how this would end from the start, by protecting the identity of the supposed guilty party by covering her face the whole time. That was far too telling. But it's still a good mini-series.

I liked it a lot and really rooted for its goofy protagonist. Bless his heart, he just wanted love!

Very impressed with Peacock's content lately! And to think, I thought they would never amount to anything that rivals Netflix or Hulu, but they have! Keep up the great work, Peacock TV!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Curb Your Cohen Brothers Television
chris-politz2 March 2023
Was I laughing at him, or with him? Honestly, it doesn't matter. I was laughing.

Likewise, I mentally heard the musics from Curb Your Enthusiasm, and a for minute or two I thought Paul was Timothy "Speed" Levitch. Then after another moment of anger that this wasn't a Cohen Brothers movie I cozied into my couch, and ended up binging the whole thing.

Is it real, not real? I'm confident it is real. No joke I got scammed by a woman, not to his extent, but man it got weird.

This is essentially a meta true crime reenactment starring many of the people who were initially involved. Part of which is Paul T Goldman putting together his story.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Foolish Man (insert face palm here)
erinsdoss23 January 2023
Warning: Spoilers
He's so self-absorbed and selfish that I cannot like him. What got me to truly despise him was when he married a Russian woman, brought her to California to live with him, had a child, divorced her, then took their child all the way, as far as he could go, to Florida. And the only reason he gave was, she was sleeping in another room. Not only divorce, but threaten to take custody because she's in med school. It's awful and cruel for him to remove their child from her and simply laugh about it, and make it seem, in his book, that she was angry when in fact she was devastated. It's all about him.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed