Hudson Jellik, a young man travels to the town of Rolling Hills in search of his lady love, Julia. Instead he meets Dr. Wallace Sprague, the town psychiatrist, who undergoes a startling transformation right before Hudson's eyes.
The next morning brings bright sunshine but no further light for Hudson. Meeting other "friendly" residents of Rolling Hills, he becomes a suspect in a most curious missing person's case and still can't find anyone who's heard of Julia.
Mayor Butterbea and Chief Gideon struggle to keep things quiet in town. The twins see something that causes them to draw dramatic conclusions about their father's disappearance. Hudson makes a commitment to work with Maggie - for now.
The town is excited to participate in Gideon's karaoke night. Hudson is desperate to text back Julia but Buddy has other ideas. A mysterious visitor makes Buddy an offer he can't refuse and an ill wind starts blowing through Rolling Hills.
In the wake of an unexpectedly rambunctious Karaoke Night, the once-idyllic town of Rolling Hills is in very bad shape and everyone is on Chief Gideon's last nerve. Then things really start happening.
Laurette and Buddy inch toward better communication. Maggie scrambles to keep things from falling apart. Nick finds himself in a compromising position, Jerry discovers a new talent and Hudson decides he's had enough of Rolling Hills..
Paul introduces Hudson to the local cuisine. Maggie thinks she knows what's going on with the twins but finds a dead end instead. Laurette is forced to reflect on her life choices as Sweetie makes a mistake that endangers everyone.
Maggie and Paul clash over loyalty as Hudson reveals a helpful skill. Tallulah comes clean to Ray about Julia while Jerry discovers his new abilities have limits. We listen in on Roger's somewhat satisfying therapy session with Buddy.
The residents of Rolling Hills at each other's throats with fights breaking out all over. Laurette comes to Tallulah's rescue, Ray finds a new ally, and Jerry might be everyone's last hope - but only if Maggie can fix him up after a crash.
A strange wind kicks up. Ray drafts Cora to do some of his dirty work. Laurette discovers a fact about the twins. Jerry's instincts inconveniently surface while Maggie brews a solution which, unfortunately, attracts some serious predators.
In this episode we learn the real reason chaos has befallen Rolling Hills. Buddy makes a big decision, Jerry's loyalty to Gideon is tested and Tallulah and Sweetie make peace. Hudson shows up when it counts and then there's Julia.