Bane v Superman: The Movie (2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Theatrical movie with a creative actor
rojerfedercon5 December 2016
"Bane v Superman: the movie" is a simple superhero smack down on the surface. Smart, inventive and often funny performances highlight a common place plot and concept. Overall, it's a nostalgic movie that's solid yet quirky entertainment. It possesses a modest stylistic charm and never takes itself too seriously.

Typically within the context of a superhero fan film we expect certain parameters and limitations on characters and everything else. Keith Stahle is an uncompromisingly creative actor in this. He takes on a versatile and specific repertoire of familiar performances including Superman/ Clark Kent/ Kal-El, the Joker, Batman and Superman's father. Stahle's Kal-El is subtly suffering in a raw self psychoanalysis. The differences between Clark Kent and Superman are well defined as the personalities are reminiscent of the iconic Christopher Reeve. The most visceral and impressive aspect of the film however is Stahle's success in recreating the presence of Jack Nicholson and Marlon Brando, two legendary American actor-hero titans, both of whom received top billing for their supporting work in the original Superman and Batman movies, respectively. Not many an actor could emulate the intensity of one of these "acting gods" to the degree of accuracy that Stahle achieves. If for no other reason, I recommend checking it out for that.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A supreme fan-film giving a cheeky kick in the pants to 21st Century Hollywood
jeanpaulhansford18 May 2023
OMG. POW/WOW. HEE-HEE, BOO-HOO.

I adored this ding-dong of a tribute and sideways look at some of the world's favourite superheroes and villains. It is 35 minutes of entertaining joy, written, directed and starring one of Hollywood's lesser known stalwarts, Keith Stahle.

I have only recently started following Keith Stahle's career after first seeing him in the 2006 film 'Wounded.' His unfamiliar surname is almost a metaphor for his career so far.

His versatility reminds me of the first time I watched Rami Malek in 'Band of Brothers.' That versatility is clear to witness in 'Bane v Superman'

Keith Stahle reveals a link between strength and sensitivity. There's a depth in himself and all his characters, but I feel he has even more to offer given the chance.

Bane v Superman left me with a smile of joy and wonderment. As any good film does.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A DC that Marvels !
jameskortar12 November 2016
Bane v Superman: The Movie is totally fun and completely enjoyable. I turned it on thinking I wouldn't want to watch all of it cause most fan film stuff usually loses my interest after it starts. I was pleasantly surprised at how good and watchable this movie was. Warner Brothers is just done with making their movies any fun. Most people I know are super depressed about WB's recent efforts because although they may have some good effects and nice explosions and all that they basically aren't any kind of fun at all. This movie is definitely intense at times yet it still was content on being light enough to make you laugh and smile. It had lots of flashbacks from the past too. I really loved the use of all the classic music! How can anyone not appreciate those great orchestra scores? When I heard the themes set to this movie it really made me heart sing! I want to be able to be up lifted while watching Superman cause I think that's the whole point to Superman. He's suppose to lift you up and take you up up and away.

I love the execution of the Marvel franchise but I must admit I prefer the DC characters and I think a lot of people feel that way. Marvel movies keep working cause they're so funny and they're a good time and that's what this movie consistently reminded of. Batman and Superman don't have just be a doom and gloom bummer all the time. They're meant to be escapism after all and that's what this movie offered me. Bane v Superman: The Movie is a nice escape to a time when the DC universe had fun. The Dark Knight trilogy was good but I think it's time to lighten things up. WB and DC may not agree so in the mean time there's this movie as an option. I don't want to spoil anything but the credits really reminded me of Marvel too. I recommend it to you if you like laughing along with the Marvel style approach and if like me you've been waiting for a DC that Marvels.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Epic Journey on a low budget
jessonstatim12 November 2016
I don't think I've ever seen a little movie with so much travelogue on it. The camera work was very professional and the choice of scene changes was splendid. Some of the sequences cut a little quick and I'm sure that was what they wanted. Still the overall look of this movie was quite good and it had a wide variety of shots and locations. Gotham City was dark and urban and then Smallville was richly layered and Metropolis had it's own palatial contrast. Can't believe all the scene and location changes and nature photography there was in this film. One could argue a certain sophistication in the shots that you rarely get from fan movies. At one point it went from aerial stars to fresh snow falling on the ground. This accomplished a unique knockout that travels from outer space to the Fortress of Solitude. All and all, a standard low budget works because of the edit and the cinematography. It was really balanced and beautiful looking at times. Most fan efforts are shot in someone's back yard or basement and they don't care about giving you scene changes at all. This movie constructed a poetic kaleidoscope that was probably more palpable than the narrative. I mean I guess the story was okay. I'd say the acting was actually good but the look and versatility is what really made the movie passable for me. It had a keen variety in the vision and just when you thought you had seen it all there was another change in land scope. Sort of reminded me of an actual comic book sometimes with all the quick cut flickering imagery. I don't think the cinematography in this kind of a movie had ever been a strong enough focus for my standards, but with this fan picture it was. I'm already over the golden age of comic book movies we're living through. You get a lot more from just watching nature then you do going to most green screen movies these days. In my opinion the natural elements are some of the most timeless elements you can put on film. I really believed the differences in one location to the next because they offered a genuine antithesis. I don't want to say it upstaged the rest of the effort cause it only served to augment the story as a visual construct. I just guess my sensibilities are more about the technical look and this is where it actually delivered. I'm just not as interested in another superhero versus villain boxing match so much as I am at seeing meticulous ambition without the big money and this film got some amazing footage.

There's a lot to see in this movie. I replayed some of the sequences twice to notice all the detail and I think the logistics of the scenic changes played a huge part in my appreciation of this. Like I say if you've seen most fan films they consist of one down played indoor set up to save time and money. This one went the distance to show you don't need a huge budget to find and attain natural beauty.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amalgamated Super-Nerd fan film
kittyrevolution17 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
SPOILERS--- SPOILERS

This short is a chick flick 20% of the time. I'm a nerd so I got into this movie. I got Kill Bill though. Some people just enjoyed Kill Bill on the surface as popcorn. I saw how it combined lots of shots and or characters and or costumes and or ideas from "Five Fingers of Death", "Game of Death", "Lady Snowblood", "Shikoku", "Kung Fu", "The Green Hornet", "The Searchers", "Once Upon the Time in the West", "The Good the Bad and the Ugly", "Swithblade Sisters" and even "Charlie Brown" plus much more. Bane v Superman: The Movie is similar to Kill Billl as it's a remix geared for the comprehensive geek's consumption.

Just a few examples include a shot of Cat Woman like in Batman Returns with the bat signal/ powerless Clark Kent walking through the snow like in Richard Donner's Superman II remastered director's cut/ "Earth Angel" song cue from Superman III --etc. This is the kind of extracted exactness that clued me in. Countless other specific actor moments and line lifts from the aforementioned movies equals crazy nerd appreciation."The father becomes the son" prophecy has never been more poignant and relevant as it is in this movie with the same actor playing the father and son.

Hypothetically, I speculate it's the next step in the Christopher Reeve time-line. Superman's connection with his father and the Fortress of Solitude is gone and no one knows what Superman knows- cause he kept spinning the world in reverse-. Zod is dead and allegedly so is Batman. Jack Nicholson's Joker is somehow alive so he's sort of the Dark Knight Joker, somehow? My theory is the plot plays like Superman V in abstract rendezvous with a time-line after the four early 80's/90's Batman movies combined and within the trilogy of the Dark Knight Rises. Bane is alive and looks like the Hardy version but he's just the muscle or the "soldier" type villain, like the archetypal "Nuclear Man" in the last Reeve movie.

Superman seems caught in a time loop after all that reversing the world on it's axis stuff. Clark Kent's leading man act has become solitary confinement and his tired time-traveler like perspective has left an isolated understanding of a time-line that the ladies in his life know little about. Which explains why the actress in this looks so young. Which actually reminds me Kate Bosworth being way too young as the five years later version of Lois Lane. The result of the same actress as Lana and Lois is that they look like identical twins- save for hair color- which is exactly the way they were drawn in the early comic books. Wonder-Woman and Superman seem to have a thing in the end, in keeping with the "new 52". Additionally, Superman fights floating like a butterfly like the late Ali when he stings Bane like a bee and this may just be a reference to the legendary "Superman vs Muhammad Ali" comic book.

Just my nerdy thoughts but it's fun to see some thought went into this fan made effort. Some people just saw Kill Bill as stupid fighting film. Certain other geeky people know that there's a play on a bunch of genre type films that came before and now they're all combined into one super- nerd concept. Then again- I'm slower than most super fans so maybe there was more or even less going on than the references I realized.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Actually pretty good
smithclarkst12 November 2016
I have to say that I'm glad I caught this one. I wasn't ecstatic when it finished but it did have some hooks that surprised me and I did appreciate it. It's basically a thinly veiled story to accomplish a couple of fight scenes and some impressions. The special effects were actually legit. If you can make a fan film that's better than most of the old Batman or Superman movies that's hardly really saying much. A number of those actual movies were just terrible.

Fan films are getting kind of common and over done. This one has a little bit more polish than most even if it is a bit long. However if you're a really fan who digs this kind of thing I doubt the running time will be an issue.

Keith Stahle writes and directs this fan salute that seems to like the idea of spot lighting some favorite aspects from the old movies and slamming it into one. The guy who played Bane looked really cool and I wanted him to talk more. Unfortunately this whole thing is kind of a predictable excuse to see a quick fight scene with Superman having no powers. Which I get I guess. Special Effects Superman is hard when your flying shots look only slightly more evolved than the 1950's TV show. Still it's kind of trite until Joker and Harley steal the show. I have to say I liked a lot of the Joker-Harley relationship better in this than in Suicide Squad, that's for sure. The Clark Kent was definitely the Superman pretending to be a klutz version which was fun to see as it's completely void in the Cavill version. I wish this movie was the tour DE force Bane with venom powers versus Superman with Super- powers. Could even go for some krypton or other weapon at some point. Alas this is not the right budget to accomplish that. If you can get over that expectation it is quite watchable. I liked it more often then I didn't. There's a weird twist in Clark's perspective in the way he views Lana that is actually pretty Trippe and I wonder if most people will pick up on it. He seems to be fixated on a past incarnation of her instead of seeing her as she is. The multiple part casting in the guy and girl leads make for some wacky parallels between Clark/Lana/Lois and then to Joker and Harley cause it's all the same actor and actress talking back and forth. It makes the movie a little different and slightly more memorable than most and I'm sure some people won't think of the parallel implications that I did. I didn't mind it cause it made me think about some similarities between the good and evil characters and therefore served as an original dynamic if you view it with some insight. My advise is check this one out. If you don't expect too much from it you might not be let down.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed