What worked: -The "you can get there from here" sequence at the beginning. Turmoil in the Middle East combined with an over-regulated industry in the US means massive oil shortages, so cars and planes are no longer viable and trains have come back in a big way. Probably wouldn't stand up to strong economic scrutiny, but it gets you into the movie -The acting, mostly. Especially when they were allowed to explore their characters beyond the limits of the book. In the book Ellis Wyatt is dynamic, but still part of the crew of noble, rational businessmen. Here he's a Texas oilman by way of Colorado, bold and passionate. In the book Hugh Akston works in a diner, but keeps his speech at the level of a professor and is said to be immaculate in his dress. Here he looks and acts like a blue-collar worker, specifically because he's hostile to the main character at this point in the story.
-The production design and cinematography. All the 10-million-dollar budget is up on the screen in sweeping vista shots of landscapes and location shots of the steel plant, as well as the opulent boardrooms and homes of the tycoons. And during the low-light sex scene, watch for reflections off the bracelet of Rearden Metal for the kind of symbolism that Rand loved. The only glaring error in the design is that the windows of James Taggart's office, which are quite distinct in looking like melted metal and stained glass, and thus appropriate for the man who never has a straight thought, are recycled for the office of the John Galt line, which is supposed to be A) a big come-down from the fancy office, and B) the setting for Dagny, who is a much more rational character. But in particular credit should be paid to the design of corporate logos and news broadcasts, which weren't hyper-modern so as to give it a science-fiction feel, but fit in with the realism.
What didn't work: -Fransisco D'anconia and Robert Stadler. Frisco's part was cut down heavily, and the actor Jsu Garcia didn't have a chance to get into it. Stadler had some bizarre accent completely divorced from the character, and looked nothing like a man who had been beaten down by 12 years of treason and strife.
-Dialogue shoehorned in from the book. Where the script re-wrote the words to fit the situation (or the actors ad-libbed for all I know), it flowed naturally and let the emotion come through. When they quoted the book it felt stilted. In particular Dagny at times seems to turn into Commander Data and stop using contractions when any normal 21st-century person would. I like the book, but it's not a screenplay.
-The production design and cinematography. All the 10-million-dollar budget is up on the screen in sweeping vista shots of landscapes and location shots of the steel plant, as well as the opulent boardrooms and homes of the tycoons. And during the low-light sex scene, watch for reflections off the bracelet of Rearden Metal for the kind of symbolism that Rand loved. The only glaring error in the design is that the windows of James Taggart's office, which are quite distinct in looking like melted metal and stained glass, and thus appropriate for the man who never has a straight thought, are recycled for the office of the John Galt line, which is supposed to be A) a big come-down from the fancy office, and B) the setting for Dagny, who is a much more rational character. But in particular credit should be paid to the design of corporate logos and news broadcasts, which weren't hyper-modern so as to give it a science-fiction feel, but fit in with the realism.
What didn't work: -Fransisco D'anconia and Robert Stadler. Frisco's part was cut down heavily, and the actor Jsu Garcia didn't have a chance to get into it. Stadler had some bizarre accent completely divorced from the character, and looked nothing like a man who had been beaten down by 12 years of treason and strife.
-Dialogue shoehorned in from the book. Where the script re-wrote the words to fit the situation (or the actors ad-libbed for all I know), it flowed naturally and let the emotion come through. When they quoted the book it felt stilted. In particular Dagny at times seems to turn into Commander Data and stop using contractions when any normal 21st-century person would. I like the book, but it's not a screenplay.
Tell Your Friends