Most of the reviews of this movie are sharply divided between great and terrible, with few opinions falling in the middle ground. I am no different; I think it is one of the greatest spectacles in the history of cinema.
Instead of simply reviewing the movie as many others have done more eloquently then I could ever hope to do. I will instead attempt to address a few specific issues that many people are pointing out again and again.
First and foremost of course is the charge that the movie is anti-Semitic. The Idea that this movie by any stretch of the imagination could be considered anti-Semitic goes so far beyond ridiculous as to be ludicrous. I cannot even find the adjectives in my vocabulary to explain my disdain for this accusation. A few words that do come to mind are; preposterous, absurd and yes even stupid. As Mr. Gibson himself has pointed out, there were only two groups of people present at the events portrayed in this movie, Jews and Romans. What
Did you expect Mr. Gibson to use Russians and Aborigines? It was plain that not all of the Jews or Romans wanted Jesus to suffer, just as it was plain that some on each side did. If anything the Romans were depicted as the blood-thirsty savages, the Jewish leaders were simply following their own rules. Blasphemy was a crime under Jewish law and they were blind to the truth of Jesus being the Son of God. So when Jesus uttered the phrase, ` I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.' they were bound by Jewish law to condemn him to death. The greatest crime committed under Jewish law as applied to this case was the fact that they conducted an Illegal trial at night. There are other aspects of the capture and trial of Jesus that were questionable but this is not a forum for debating points of ancient Jewish law. People that find this movie anti-Semitic need to look deep into their own psyche, as they must have issues with hate and anger that need resolving. Instead of hate and anger toward any one person or group of people depicted in this movie I felt pity and sadness for them. They were only fulfilling a destiny that had to be fulfilled. As Jesus himself said `Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.'
Some have made the statement that the movie is not true to the scriptures or left out important details or added others. Two thoughts come to mind. First this is a movie and a movie will never satisfy all of the preconceived ideas and opinions that have formed in peoples minds of a well-known topic, especially a topic as well-known and deep seated as this one. Second, although there was obviously some dramatic license taken in the making of this movie, I could find NOTHING that was counter to the accounts given in the four Gospels. There were things shown that are not mentioned in the Gospels but just because something isn't mentioned we don't know that it didn't happen. It quite obvious to anyone who has read the Biblical accounts of the events portrayed in this movie that not even the authors of the four Gospels saw things in exactly the same light. There are events in some that are not in others, and words spoke in some that are not in others. It is as the saying goes `A matter of perspective'. This is Mr. Gibson's perspective on Christ's suffering.
Others have said the movie was nothing but a gore-fest with little or no attention paid to the events that precipitated the events portrayed in this movie, or what happened next. Did you read the title? The movie is titled `The Passion of the Christ'. The word PASSION when taken in its ordinal meaning and when applied to the crucifixion, means something completely different that what it means today. Today we equate the word passion with lust and desire, but its original meaning was suffering. So to make it a little simpler for those who don't understand you could re-title the movie `The Suffering of the Christ' and then it might make this a little clearer. The movie did not attempt to show the entire life of Christ or even the events after his resurrection. That has been done many times before, and who on this planet does not at least have a small concept of the story of Jesus Christ. This movie was about his suffering, the day that defined his love for mankind. That is why PASSION means suffering; he loved us all so much with such a pure PASSION that he willingly endured this SUFFERING for the salvation of mankind. This is even more amazing that if as a believer you consider that at any moment he could have called on God to stop the suffering and God would have done so. Jesus himself said that if he wanted God would send more than twelve legions of angels to save him. Even if you are a none-believer you must realize that when brought for trial before the Jewish elders he could have denied being a prophet and escaped the torment that was sure to come. But without his sacrifice there would have been no hope for mankind.
Although I am not a Catholic, I am a believer and I believe God is reaching out to mankind in any way he can in today's world. All God is looking for is a `Willing Vessel' to do his work and he has found one in Mel Gibson. Kudos to you Mr. Gibson for following you heart and producing a thought provoking film that is speaking to the hearts of many people. I myself have seen people who have not darkened a church for many years return after seeing this film.
0 out of 3 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends