Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
brilliant
23 November 2003
Warning: Spoilers
POSSIBLE LIGHT SPOILER

As others here have said, this is one of the best new films (certainly one of the best American indies) I have seen in quite a long time: fresh, original, moving.

Rather than repeat what's already been said about the plot, the acting, the structure, etc., the thing that I find most amazing about the film is this: Harvey is a bizarre guy, but not so bizarre that we can't relate. When we see him lose his cool, often engaging in ultimately self-destructive behavior, we can recognize our own similar tendencies and learn from the film. In a parallel fashion, it becomes clear that by dramatizing his own life in comic books, Harvey himself is able to improve himself and find a measure of happiness. Thus the process of narrating his own true story proves therapeutic for Harvey as well as for his audience.

Seeing the film prompted me to check out an anthology of Pekar's comics, which are terrific.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Magnificent!
17 November 2003
The people who are raking this little gem over the coals must either 1) not really like movies; 2) have seen the film on a bad videotape; or if we want to be generous, 3) be having a bad day.

I just came from a screening of a beautiful 35mm print, and I loved it! LOVED IT! Granted, the Christian allegory is laid on a bit thick at times, but the performances are wonderful, and the story will resonate with anyone mature enough to have grappled with his/her own dark side. It's a story of sacrifice and redemption, truly a battle writ large between good and evil.

I also highly suspect that Jacques Demy's BAY OF ANGELS (1963) is an homage to this film. Both use the casino as an apt metaphor for Hell, and in both films, characters are saved by love.

Siodmak is one of the great, underrated filmmakers of the 1940s, and while I don't like this film quite as much as his films noirs (The Killers, Criss-Cross) or his other masterful period drama, The Spiral Staircase, I do think The Great Sinner will satisfy anyone who appreciates the classical Hollywood style.
32 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed