I've read dozens of critics reviews of this movie, and I'm still reading dozens of them, but none seem to zero in on some of the story/plot issues that appear so obvious to me. This is a charming film, for sure. J-Lo's magnetism and screen presence is unmistakable, seemingly the best thing the film has to offer. But her character, I wonder about.
She is the titular character who through a series of interesting events ends up in contact with Ralph Fiennes' character, running for Senate or considering a run in New York City. From the moment he meets Marisa, he's entranced, though plays his cards fairly well. Marisa, however, seems to take an interest but then backs away at seemingly the most opportune times. Clearly there's an interest between the two, although whether bounds of chemistry jumps off the screen could be up for debate.
It's strange, though, when Marisa shows up to a ball at the Met, all dolled up and looking spectacular as anyone has ever looked, yet arrives to say she cannot see Chris anymore. She gets these words out, but why? On the surface the reason is that she's been accepted into a management position and supposedly has to cut off contact from this love interest. But that notion is ridiculous for several reasons, not the least of which is that Marisa never desired the position in the first place and it was only her pathetic co-workers, one in particular, that foisted it upon her. And can't this woman, already covering the fact that she's a maid from her new guy friend, also cover that she's romantically involved with someone who has stayed at her hotel and could easily stay elsewhere if necessary? Alas, this plan to break things off doesn't stop Marisa from sleeping with Chris that evening, a point every one of the scores of world-wide critics of this film fail to point out.
A second weird thing. After Chris and Marisa spend the overnight together and it's later revealed that Marisa is indeed a maid at the hotel he frequents, a fact hidden from Chris, everything between the two is...over. Some time later, it's not efforts by Chris or Marisa to re-connect but another funny, sort of serendipitous, situation that brings the two back together.
Who knows, maybe they needed a moment apart to come back again, but why not kindle the flame of love together? Why not dare to reveal oneself and let the love prove itself? Fiennes' character seemed to be up for the moment, but J-Lo was always too hesitant for some reason to give love a chance and be fully open.
She is the titular character who through a series of interesting events ends up in contact with Ralph Fiennes' character, running for Senate or considering a run in New York City. From the moment he meets Marisa, he's entranced, though plays his cards fairly well. Marisa, however, seems to take an interest but then backs away at seemingly the most opportune times. Clearly there's an interest between the two, although whether bounds of chemistry jumps off the screen could be up for debate.
It's strange, though, when Marisa shows up to a ball at the Met, all dolled up and looking spectacular as anyone has ever looked, yet arrives to say she cannot see Chris anymore. She gets these words out, but why? On the surface the reason is that she's been accepted into a management position and supposedly has to cut off contact from this love interest. But that notion is ridiculous for several reasons, not the least of which is that Marisa never desired the position in the first place and it was only her pathetic co-workers, one in particular, that foisted it upon her. And can't this woman, already covering the fact that she's a maid from her new guy friend, also cover that she's romantically involved with someone who has stayed at her hotel and could easily stay elsewhere if necessary? Alas, this plan to break things off doesn't stop Marisa from sleeping with Chris that evening, a point every one of the scores of world-wide critics of this film fail to point out.
A second weird thing. After Chris and Marisa spend the overnight together and it's later revealed that Marisa is indeed a maid at the hotel he frequents, a fact hidden from Chris, everything between the two is...over. Some time later, it's not efforts by Chris or Marisa to re-connect but another funny, sort of serendipitous, situation that brings the two back together.
Who knows, maybe they needed a moment apart to come back again, but why not kindle the flame of love together? Why not dare to reveal oneself and let the love prove itself? Fiennes' character seemed to be up for the moment, but J-Lo was always too hesitant for some reason to give love a chance and be fully open.
Tell Your Friends