Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
Lets sue the makers instead
7 January 2012
Warning: Spoilers
So a young man studying to be a lawyer is going through a tough time. His mother is killed by a drunk driver, his life is going nowhere and one day he decides that Satan is to blame for all his problems and the world's problems and decides to sue him. He goes ahead and files a petition in the court. On the appointed date, a man turns up claiming to be Satan(Malcom McDowell). This sets the scene for a courtroom drama between an ordinary and boring young man and Satan himself. There's a hint of satire to this. It could have easily been a biting satire about man using religion as a crutch and a few times in the movie it feels like the director isn't sure how to play the material. Almost like he could have gone in a religious satire direction but pulled back and played this material straight. So what we have is a film that is devoutly and embarrassingly Christian. The Bible is quoted left, right and centre and Satan is a jerk.

The acting is campy at best and plain old horrible at worst. The writing isn't all that hot either and the 2 main leads, Malcolm McDowell and Bart Bronson are bad in very different ways. McDowell plays Satan like a parody. He knows this material sucks and the lines he's mouthing are just plain bad and decides to ham it up all the way. Bronson on the other hand plays it straight and earnest but he's a very poor actor and most times you just wish Satan would smite this sorry loser and get it over with. The supporting cast doesn't have much to do and is uniformly bad in the little that they do have to do. Tom Sizemore as a TV commentator analyzing the trial looks embarrassed to be part of this.

Leaving the entire religion angle aside and just judging this movie on writing, acting and direction I'd say this is bad. The actors are mediocre at best but frequently horrible, the direction feels like its tugging the film in two different directions and the writing is just plain embarrassing.

I'm sure there must be better films out there that show Christianity in a good light. I don't know and I'm not going looking for them. As it stands, Suing the Devil is a pretty bad piece of film making. Only worth watching if you want to see McDowell ham it up in a truly campy display. Otherwise, avoid.
12 out of 68 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sarkar Raj (2008)
2/10
Terrible, terrible terrible
16 June 2008
This movie feels like a collage of all of the director's favorite scenes from The Godfather 1 and 2 stitched together with a plot that seems added on at the last minute. The basic gist is that Aishwarya and her Dad (a sorely underutilized Victor Banerjee) want to set up India's biggest power plant in Maharashtra. The duo come to Sarkar (AB Sr.) for help and after some initial doubts, he relents. There's also a trio of baddies all of whom overact horribly (and mind you, they are all fine character actors from Hindi films and Marathi Theatre) and conspire to bring down the Sarkar family. What follows is basically a a movie that seems content to build up the characters of the Sarkar family as do-gooders with purely altruistic motives. Both, father and son launch into Maharshtra loving monologues at the drop of a hat and in the wake of the Raj Thakeray outburst against the Bachans this seems like a calculated piece of subliminal propaganda. The monologues are badly written but then the writing and the dialogs are terrible anyway.

The acting is uniformly bad. Amitabh looks tired and is just going through the motions here. It is at best a performance that has been phoned in by one of our finest actors. Abhishek was a lot better in the first movie and I actually thought he's learned to act but he's very disappointing here. Aishwarya could never act and she continues in the same vein.

Another thing that really hurt the movie was the final conversation between Amitabh and Aishwarya where Sarkar joins the dots and explains the conspiracy against his family. It seemed like a ridiculous last minute add on and was any body else reminded of the scene from Godfather where Michael has his last conversation with his brother -in-law? A word must also be said about RGV's directing of this film. While the content itself seems pretty weak, his over reliance on weird camera angles and even weirder lighting makes this movie irritating to watch. Sarkar Raj in fact feels like a movie made by a director who has lost his power over the medium. I'd blame the failing of this film mainly on RGV, Abhishek (who comes up with a truly bland performance) and Aishwarya (who desperately over emotes in her quest to come across as a tough as nails business woman).

This is a weak, dull and ultimately boring sequel to a movie that was pretty good. Re-watch Sarkar but stay away from this sequel.
6 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed