I will never understand why someone says "here's a great book, let's make a movie... but, we need to change everything." I understand scene deletion, time compression, etc., but to totally change characters and characterizations is ego on the part of the director's to "improve" or "puth their mark" on the story.
First of all... the story... Paul Atreides is a 15 year old who finds out he has been bred to be a potential super-human. His story of coping with becoming a pseudo-messiah is caught up in a story of feudalistic power battles in a galactic empire, as well as ecological, eugenics, religious, and social themes. Paul's father, Duke Leto is ordered by the galactic emperor to take over the control of the desert planet "Arrakis" aka "Dune." Dune is the most important planet in the universe, as it is the only source of the spice "melange" which is used to extend life and gives powers to some to become navigators in space, allowing space travel. However, the appointment is a trap, as the emperor, intends to get rid of the Atreides family because Duke Leto is becoming very powerful and popular among the other planet-owning nobility. Through the arch-enemies of the Atreides, the Harkonnens, the emperor will use his elite shock troops to wipe out the Atreides family for failure to keep the profits of spice production flowing (it's complicated). Paul escapes and lives among a hidden race of desert dwellers, the Fremen, who are actually large in numbers and the best fighters in the universe. Paul must decide whether to take the mantel of Messiah for these people and avenge his father. One of the plot twists is the that the emperor only has daughters, the eldest being Irulan... a basically naive, foolish princess who is to be married to a future emperor and become empress. The power families, including the Atreides and Harkonnens, each have heirs that could be potential mates for Irulan, but the power politics of the main plot line override this point.
Anyhow, this Sci-Fi movie version hardly follows the original story and makes drastic changes to many of the key characters. SImilar to Peter Jackson's "Lord of the Rings"... they may get the names and looks right, but not the characterizations.
The most appalling switch is the portrayal of Irulan, a minor character and mere plot device (and when entered into the novel is rather stiff and not all that inspiring) suddenly becomes the mover and shaker ... traveling across the galaxy trying to solve the Atreides-Harkonnen feud, acting as a go-between... flirting with Paul and Feyd-Rautha Harkonne, etc. William Hurt's portrayal of Duke Leto was also rather weak... and once again, a raven-haired character (Paul) becomes a blonde model. From Thufir Hawat to Baron Harkonnen, this version seems to have tried to appease the critics of the book (some feminists and gay groups felt that women and gays were portrayed negatively in the novel- both mistaken criticisms) and , cheap budget is no excuse for poor scripting and misportrayals.
There is a reason a book is popular, feeling the need to change key plot points and characters is stupid.
First of all... the story... Paul Atreides is a 15 year old who finds out he has been bred to be a potential super-human. His story of coping with becoming a pseudo-messiah is caught up in a story of feudalistic power battles in a galactic empire, as well as ecological, eugenics, religious, and social themes. Paul's father, Duke Leto is ordered by the galactic emperor to take over the control of the desert planet "Arrakis" aka "Dune." Dune is the most important planet in the universe, as it is the only source of the spice "melange" which is used to extend life and gives powers to some to become navigators in space, allowing space travel. However, the appointment is a trap, as the emperor, intends to get rid of the Atreides family because Duke Leto is becoming very powerful and popular among the other planet-owning nobility. Through the arch-enemies of the Atreides, the Harkonnens, the emperor will use his elite shock troops to wipe out the Atreides family for failure to keep the profits of spice production flowing (it's complicated). Paul escapes and lives among a hidden race of desert dwellers, the Fremen, who are actually large in numbers and the best fighters in the universe. Paul must decide whether to take the mantel of Messiah for these people and avenge his father. One of the plot twists is the that the emperor only has daughters, the eldest being Irulan... a basically naive, foolish princess who is to be married to a future emperor and become empress. The power families, including the Atreides and Harkonnens, each have heirs that could be potential mates for Irulan, but the power politics of the main plot line override this point.
Anyhow, this Sci-Fi movie version hardly follows the original story and makes drastic changes to many of the key characters. SImilar to Peter Jackson's "Lord of the Rings"... they may get the names and looks right, but not the characterizations.
The most appalling switch is the portrayal of Irulan, a minor character and mere plot device (and when entered into the novel is rather stiff and not all that inspiring) suddenly becomes the mover and shaker ... traveling across the galaxy trying to solve the Atreides-Harkonnen feud, acting as a go-between... flirting with Paul and Feyd-Rautha Harkonne, etc. William Hurt's portrayal of Duke Leto was also rather weak... and once again, a raven-haired character (Paul) becomes a blonde model. From Thufir Hawat to Baron Harkonnen, this version seems to have tried to appease the critics of the book (some feminists and gay groups felt that women and gays were portrayed negatively in the novel- both mistaken criticisms) and , cheap budget is no excuse for poor scripting and misportrayals.
There is a reason a book is popular, feeling the need to change key plot points and characters is stupid.
Tell Your Friends