I really do not get why most oft he reviewers like the movie. I think that there are a lot of gaps in the plot and I really disliked the movie.
This review contains spoilers.
I will roughly go chronically through the movie and let you know what I find wrong from my point of view. Adrián and Belén moved from Barcelona to Bogota because he got an offer as a conductor. For some reason they moved after eight months into the house (the eight months are only a guess, because Adrián mentioned that he is living for two months in the house and we also know that it is the end of his one-year contract). The widowed landlord, Emma, wants to go back to Berlin and leaves her dog there (why does someone leaving her dog behind?). But this is not really a problem, because Belén is into dogs and works from home as a shoe designer. Always when Belén is in the city she sees Adrián talking to Veronica and thinks that they have an affair (I do not why it looks like that they are talking to each other..., but maybe Belén had some bad experience with Adrián before, we will not know....). After Belén checked Adriáns cell phone he confirms the affair. Belén and Emma are meeting for the last time and they came up with the plan that Belén split up with Adrián via video and observes him from the safe room. The safe room has roughly 20 m² and no one every though that there is a hidden room? I cannot believe that. Also why is it not possible to communicate with the outside, shouldn´t that be important in case of a home invasion? Why is a key needed to enter/exit the room? How long planned Belén to stay, only for a short amount of time, because she is not bringing any kind of food (the cans she is eating are looking quiet old)? What does she want to see? For me it is clear that Adrián loves her because otherwise he would not ask if she wants to join him to go to Bogota and also some scenes are suggesting that.
Due to the farewell video which is the starting scene of the movie I would never come up with the idea that Adrán planned to kill Belén and there was never a real evidence for that. After Adrián listen to the video he starts crying (here Belén want to leave the room and figured out that the key is missing, she only wants to see him cry after she left him (really that is all?)) and he got wasted at a bar. The waitress Fabiana picked the drunk Adrián up and drove him to her place where he is sleeping at her couch. Next evening, they meet again and start a romance. This is one of the few logical parts of the movie the sad Adrián want to have a distraction from the break up. But then Fabiana starts living in the house (why?) and got haunted by Belén which tried to communicate with the outside world (ether by beating the pipes or changing the water temperature. Nevertheless, Fabiana figured out that Belén is in the safe room, but she did not rescue her because she might think that Adrián drops her. After the policemen who hits the whole movie on Fabiana (why, are there not enough other girls around) showed her some photos of Adrián having an affair. She has a change of heart and wants to save Belén. Belén pretends to be dead, hits her with a bottle, close the room and leaves the house. Adrián enters the bedroom, finds a picture of him and Belén and the key to the safe room, but he is not aware that the room exist. Also we know that house will get sold. (Why is Belén trapping Fabiana in the safe room, wasn´t it Belén fault in the first place?).
Overall I think that the movie has a lot of logical mistakes and most of the time the motivation of the characters is not clear. The only nice parts are the cutting and some acting moments.
14 out of 24 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends