Change Your Image
timothylynn
Ratings
Most Recently Rated
Reviews
Turn (2014)
Don't TURN This One Away
I will start with its drawback: It is indeed LOOSELY based on Alexander Rose's history and research, which, by the way, is equally exciting and intense. I always like my entertainment to also be historically accurate. For instance, Abraham Woodhull was not yet married when he initiated the Culper Ring. And Anna Strong was not widowed (she actually died before her husband) nor is there any evidence of an affair between her and Abraham or an affectionate relationship between her and Hewlett. These are just a few examples of where the AMC production errs. I firmly believe, that even in entertainment, it is important to be as factual and historically accurate as possible. To not be accurate borders on, and may at times cross over into, mere propaganda. Too many people get their history via audio-video media nowadays rather than through thoroughly-researched books and articles.
So... Why do I give it a "9"? Because it is tremendously entertaining AND it gets much of its history right. When I first started watching the series from its first episode, I had to keep reminding myself that this was on AMC, not the History Channel. When I have had to miss an episode, I couldn't wait to watch it on the AMC website. It has its flaws but it is tremendously suspenseful and entertaining.
One more note: Another reviewer somewhere stated that Colonel Simcoe was not as harsh as depicted in the show. There may be a bit of truth to that. After the war, he was made the first Lieutenant-Governor of Canada. There, according to Alexander Rose, he abolished slavery. He also has a lake there named after him. However, during the war, he was quite harsh and ruthless, and his departure was gladly welcomed by the Patriots.
I highly recommend this series, as long as you remember that historical accuracy is sometimes sacrificed for the sake of suspense and entertainment.
Salem Witch Trials (2002)
Entertaining and contains some historical truth...
Although this version has a few serious historical flaws, "Salem Witch Trials" is a relatively entertaining story. I agree that Part I was slow but I chalked that up to historical/cultural background that made Part II more believable. Two things that bothered me: (a) the trials appeared to be judged by two men from beginning to end when, in reality, a panel of several men was sent to try the accused, and (b) the scene of Rebecca Nurse in prison asserting New Age philosophy seemed out of character for this pious Puritan woman. Still, the overall story was accurate and believable.
I found this version to be more historically accurate (if less entertaining) than "The Crucible," simply because "The Crucible" relied on the premise of an affair between two major characters that most likely did not happen. (In reality, she was only eleven while he was in his sixties.)
Another thing that bothered me in both versions was the absence of Tituba's husband, John Indian. He played a relatively major role in the original trials.