These types of "alternate history", or perhaps 'alternate future history' movies usually intrigue me. And, on that level, the movie was worth the time. At least it wasn't an MCU superhero fantasy.
It's not a spoiler to say that it is supposed to be a warning against the course that America is on, at least with polarized politics. But what this movie really is about is the ethics of journalism. It joins many other War Correspondent films such as The Year Of Living Dangerously and Salvador, with a bit of Whisky Tango Foxtrot. This one, Civil War, features the perspectives of 4 main characters with a smattering of others for comraderie.
Placing the war WITHIN the USA while covering it as an almost foreign conflict is jarring, however. Allusion is made to the recent events of Charlottesville in 2017, and the White House attack of January 6th (2021). In that way, the story seems to extend into the inevitable outcome of the current social trajectory in America which could come to a head during the 2024 election battle between Biden and Trump (if it does come down to those two).
I am in Canada, and despite our own political disenchantment, there really is no parallel to this sort of civil unrest and violence, given the comparative lack of guns in civilian hands here, and our cultural milieu that diverged from the US when it had a Revolution against British rule and we stayed a colony within the Commonwealth, at least in spirit. Canada has "Peace, order, and good government" (supposedly) whereas America champions "Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness".
I did not find this movie worked as a realistic scenario, however, in how journalists behave under fire, risking their lives. Kirsten Dunst was very good as the lead, and a short sequence with Jesse Plemons (her real-life husband) was excellent, and the only.15 minutes of the movie that I thought was accurately prophetic.
Therefore, I can only rate it a 6, and was a bit let down from my hopes for a rousing action-drama that made sense.
It's not a spoiler to say that it is supposed to be a warning against the course that America is on, at least with polarized politics. But what this movie really is about is the ethics of journalism. It joins many other War Correspondent films such as The Year Of Living Dangerously and Salvador, with a bit of Whisky Tango Foxtrot. This one, Civil War, features the perspectives of 4 main characters with a smattering of others for comraderie.
Placing the war WITHIN the USA while covering it as an almost foreign conflict is jarring, however. Allusion is made to the recent events of Charlottesville in 2017, and the White House attack of January 6th (2021). In that way, the story seems to extend into the inevitable outcome of the current social trajectory in America which could come to a head during the 2024 election battle between Biden and Trump (if it does come down to those two).
I am in Canada, and despite our own political disenchantment, there really is no parallel to this sort of civil unrest and violence, given the comparative lack of guns in civilian hands here, and our cultural milieu that diverged from the US when it had a Revolution against British rule and we stayed a colony within the Commonwealth, at least in spirit. Canada has "Peace, order, and good government" (supposedly) whereas America champions "Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness".
I did not find this movie worked as a realistic scenario, however, in how journalists behave under fire, risking their lives. Kirsten Dunst was very good as the lead, and a short sequence with Jesse Plemons (her real-life husband) was excellent, and the only.15 minutes of the movie that I thought was accurately prophetic.
Therefore, I can only rate it a 6, and was a bit let down from my hopes for a rousing action-drama that made sense.
Tell Your Friends