I want to openly celebrate this film for how it is able to continually lure you into comfortably thinking you have a grasp of the situation and then completely upturning the entire context of what you've just witnessed, yet what unfolds is so sickening that I'm almost nauseous thinking about it. Pedro Almodóvar does not explore the darkest human behaviour to emphasis the light; he does not orchestrate a grand tragedy of abduction, enslavement, rape, grotesque scientific experiments, incestuous suggestions and sexual mania just to warmly reassure with optimistic triumph.
He's not condemning anybody, even Antonio Banderas - who is so far removed from any image he ever cultivated as a suave Hispanic Clooney – a sociopathic scientist who evokes Doctor Génessier from 'Eyes Without A Face' (1960) more than anybody else, not just in his methods but his brutal persistence in willingly devastating anything around him to achieve his goals. He's losing constantly, losing the trust, admiration, love of those around him, losing control; his human experiment Elena Anaya who he observes in his living room through the one-way glass in her watching cell like a living artwork is losing constantly her identity as she is crafted by his will, losing the tether to her old self as she fails to escape her prison, his Mother a live-in maid is constantly losing her maternal grasp as she watches her family disassemble; it feels like everybody is by default losing until they can stop and win something. Even the ending doesn't promise anything.
So what kind of burdensome descent into darkness is this? Well, it's not descent so much as it is a flaying. The film opens with Anaya exercising most dutifully in her small contained room, posing taut like a sculpture, and then as she receives her food from downstairs and talking to the Mother through an intercom. It's like a bustling hacienda as we see food being prepared, servants working, people communicating in all the ambiance of domesticity in what should be a normal household. But the film challenges our comfort with the scene with odd details that prevent this situation from being usual. Anaya receives her food via dumb-waiter, and downstairs she is being watched on multiple screens. And why does she wear that tight, flesh-toned one-piece, as if she is a human figure not yet finished in its creation? The film doesn't take long to reveal the circumstances of this living-arrangement, but then when we begin to think we understand what is happening and why the film peels back another layer.
The film is strikingly composed like a Kubrikian pallet that burns intensely with certain colours, and if you thought red in the Shining was assaulting take a look at this. The film is so gorgeous in its art-exhibition style that there becomes a cognitive dissonance between the gawking that it elicits from you and the increasing repugnance of what is gradually being revealed, and even when the film is at its most clinical like Kubrick, there is so much abounding passion that it just leaves you dazed. Take the scene in which an assertive, perhaps unhinged man in a tiger costume appears at Banderas' home and tells the Mother that he's her son and he wants to come back into her life. She allows him in and he quickly devolves from assertive to perverted; and the whole thing appears like it's composed too rigidly for the sake of being lurid. But what's happening is important relationships are being tested at a level in which they shouldn't even exist, and the small details of the tiger costume are just realistic details of life; life doesn't stop in awareness of how peculiar it's being and modify itself so it appears normal. It's just f****d up.
And this is Almodóvar, existing in the f****d up, in the most swollen- ready-to-burst Melodrama of life in which people exist in craziness and depravity way beyond ordinary boundaries, and it's as if he is gifting us this madness so we can delight in just how spectacular human behaviour is. Sometimes it feels like it doesn't know what to say or doesn't have anything to say and is doing what it's doing simply for the delight of the perverse, trying on different skins so to speak, but when it pulls back it's skins and reveals whole new truths that you hadn't even contemplated this film really does impact. And it's pulling back those skins that reveal how successful the film is. It wasn't a deception, an elaborate magic trick in which the skin peeling was nothing but provocation eventually to peel back and to nothing but air. Underneath the film is flesh, real substance, and you can look at it and marvel at the creation, and honestly say to yourself as every fortunate human has at some point: "Has there been a better time to be alive?"
He's not condemning anybody, even Antonio Banderas - who is so far removed from any image he ever cultivated as a suave Hispanic Clooney – a sociopathic scientist who evokes Doctor Génessier from 'Eyes Without A Face' (1960) more than anybody else, not just in his methods but his brutal persistence in willingly devastating anything around him to achieve his goals. He's losing constantly, losing the trust, admiration, love of those around him, losing control; his human experiment Elena Anaya who he observes in his living room through the one-way glass in her watching cell like a living artwork is losing constantly her identity as she is crafted by his will, losing the tether to her old self as she fails to escape her prison, his Mother a live-in maid is constantly losing her maternal grasp as she watches her family disassemble; it feels like everybody is by default losing until they can stop and win something. Even the ending doesn't promise anything.
So what kind of burdensome descent into darkness is this? Well, it's not descent so much as it is a flaying. The film opens with Anaya exercising most dutifully in her small contained room, posing taut like a sculpture, and then as she receives her food from downstairs and talking to the Mother through an intercom. It's like a bustling hacienda as we see food being prepared, servants working, people communicating in all the ambiance of domesticity in what should be a normal household. But the film challenges our comfort with the scene with odd details that prevent this situation from being usual. Anaya receives her food via dumb-waiter, and downstairs she is being watched on multiple screens. And why does she wear that tight, flesh-toned one-piece, as if she is a human figure not yet finished in its creation? The film doesn't take long to reveal the circumstances of this living-arrangement, but then when we begin to think we understand what is happening and why the film peels back another layer.
The film is strikingly composed like a Kubrikian pallet that burns intensely with certain colours, and if you thought red in the Shining was assaulting take a look at this. The film is so gorgeous in its art-exhibition style that there becomes a cognitive dissonance between the gawking that it elicits from you and the increasing repugnance of what is gradually being revealed, and even when the film is at its most clinical like Kubrick, there is so much abounding passion that it just leaves you dazed. Take the scene in which an assertive, perhaps unhinged man in a tiger costume appears at Banderas' home and tells the Mother that he's her son and he wants to come back into her life. She allows him in and he quickly devolves from assertive to perverted; and the whole thing appears like it's composed too rigidly for the sake of being lurid. But what's happening is important relationships are being tested at a level in which they shouldn't even exist, and the small details of the tiger costume are just realistic details of life; life doesn't stop in awareness of how peculiar it's being and modify itself so it appears normal. It's just f****d up.
And this is Almodóvar, existing in the f****d up, in the most swollen- ready-to-burst Melodrama of life in which people exist in craziness and depravity way beyond ordinary boundaries, and it's as if he is gifting us this madness so we can delight in just how spectacular human behaviour is. Sometimes it feels like it doesn't know what to say or doesn't have anything to say and is doing what it's doing simply for the delight of the perverse, trying on different skins so to speak, but when it pulls back it's skins and reveals whole new truths that you hadn't even contemplated this film really does impact. And it's pulling back those skins that reveal how successful the film is. It wasn't a deception, an elaborate magic trick in which the skin peeling was nothing but provocation eventually to peel back and to nothing but air. Underneath the film is flesh, real substance, and you can look at it and marvel at the creation, and honestly say to yourself as every fortunate human has at some point: "Has there been a better time to be alive?"
Tell Your Friends