I just finished X+Y and I gotta say, I rather enjoyed it, even though it is quite clichéd and predictable to the point where "you can plot the vectors of the narrative from the angles of the opening moves" (Kermode), yet it still managed to capture me, because it never went too overboard into becoming sappy and mockishly sentimental, and because I'm a big sucker for these kind of stories. The performances were really good all around and I agree with LostMartian here; I also especially liked the performance of Jake Davies (Luke; dead parrot) who gave a particularly touching performance.
But enough of that. I wanna get into the clichés (particularly those the movie successfully avoided) a bit. This is where we go into spoiler territory.
So, throughout the first act of the movie, I think to myself: I'm really liking this, but it is setting up all those clichéd story lines, that'll make it become a Disney Channel movie. I know this may sound a little paradox. The best example I can think of here is the movie Saved! with Jena Malone, Mandy Moore and Macaulay Culkin, enjoyable and kinda clever for the most part, but completely ruined by the third act. Well, this movie avoids that for the most part.
So, here are some of the things this movie successfully avoided:
1. Richard (Eddie Marsan) talks to Nathan (Asa Butterfield) about how Nathans mentor Mr. Humphreys didn't lose the IMO just because of his illness, as he was told before. Perfect set-up for a sappy dramatic liar-revealed moment. AVOIDED, thank god
2. Isaac (the sort-of bully) becoming cartoonishly evil in the third act by doing something completely unethical to advance his chances of winning. AVOIDED, thank god It would not have made sense anyway in the way this competition was set up, but that hasn't stopped other movies from doing it anyway.
3. When Nathan and his mother decided to chase after Zhang Mei, I was half expecting an airport chase a la Love Actually, but then it just showed the bonding moment between him and his mother in the car, and then directly him on the train with Zhang Mei, so AVOIDED although I wouldn't have mind the grand airport chase, but I'm still glad it didn't go for that.
Apart from that, the movie did tap into many clichés (the outcast,rough- around-the-edges wise cracking mentor Mr. Humphreys, the relationship between Mr. Humphreys and Nathans mother, the dramatic climax during the IMO and so on and so forth), but the movie still managed to bring these things across in a more understated manner than most of the competition, and it managed to stay content and intimate overall.
3 out of 7 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Tell Your Friends