Change Your Image
pascalintow
IMDb member since August 2014
Reviews
A Separate Peace (2004)
Doesn't do the book justice. Gay theme is there if you want it to be.
4 August 2014 - 2 out of 4 users found this review helpful.
The story just doesn't seem to translate well to film. Maybe if it had narration and was voiced over by Gene it would have been better. There's just too much going on in Gene's head to explain in a movie, especially to someone unfamiliar with the book. I didn't care for either movie version. Neither seemed to do the book justice.
The gay question always comes up with this book. We had to read it as a class in 10th grade English and several in the class picked up on the supposed gay theme, including me. Guess we'll never know for sure. Perhaps the good thing about the book is you can make the Gene/Phineas relationship what you wish.
See more▼See less▲