Reviews

2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Downfall (2004)
10/10
a few hidden agendas among the ruins of the third Reich
24 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
A great movie: a superb vehicle for recounting the History of the end of Nazi Germany through the eyes of one of Hitler's secretaries, but take it with a few grains of salt. The producers described as History a number of THEORIES concerning the end of the Nazis. The doctor who mixed the knockout drug Finodin that Magda Goebbles gave to her children before killing them was named by the producers as Stumpfnegger, who committed suicide with Bormann. However, much evidence, including a deposition I have personally read in the US National Archives in College Park MD, names someone else (who denied involvement). Herman Fegelein is shown as having been arrested drunk in a hotel room (the Adlon?) and shot for desertion, though he was actually hanged for espionage, a much more involved and interesting albeit detracting story. Eva Braun, portrayed for the first time NOT as a cardboard character, when confronted with evidence of Fegelein's espionage, in fact supported the execution, but this was not portrayed. However, what the producers got right compensates for these nagging errors. A great touch was denying any lines to the evil debauched parasite Goering. Goebbles, Hasse, Shenk, Moenhke, Burgdorf, Krebs, and Weidling were portrayed masterfully. Even Bormann was portrayed as forgettable background furniture, a skilled ironic touch. The most successful technique: The set design often reproduced in exacting detail famous stills taken during the fall of Berlin. I often caught myself thinking, "I remember that," though I was never there.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Counterpoint (1967)
7/10
War of wills between 2 Prima Donnas, a conductor and a Nazi General
1 July 2005
Let me qualify those 7 stars. You have to like Heston, Schell, WWII movies, and classical music in order to appreciate this movie. Heston is the conductor of an orchestra that is caught behind German lines during the Battle of the Bulge. Schell is a Prussian style educated yet cultured officer who is caught between his appreciation for culture and his orders not to delay the battle by wasting time on taking prisoners. The orchestra is USO. A side conflict is provided by the orchestra taking in 2 GIs who are also cut off behind enemy lines and hiding them as members of the orchestra. This is a war, "small w", movie. I remember a lot of grimacing from Heston and Schell, but that is what they do! Look beyond the cardboard characters and you may find a good little picture about a protagonist and an antagonist playing chess without a board.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed