Reviews

3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Kyatapirâ (2010)
8/10
very impressive
22 February 2010
Warning: Spoilers
A soldier from the Chinese-Japanese war returns to his home village. Being completely disabled (no limbs, facial burns, impaired hearing and speech), his survival seems a miracle and he soon is being proclaimed to be a "god of war". His wife, suffering from the burden of care and his unfaded crudeness towards her, becomes to understand the absurdity of the war and war propaganda, but brings herself to enjoy the compliments from the villagers about how well she cares for the "god of war" and clings to singing propaganda songs to calm down herself.

Repeated power failures and the dimming of his room with only the flame of a petrol lamp left make the soldier recall the memories of him raping and slaughtering a Chinese woman in a burning house. Unable to articulate himself he is haunted and overwhelmed by his fault and eventually commits suicide.

The story tells us that war does not create heroes but only victims, in the first as well as the last front line -the wife at home. The movie doesn't need sentimentalism or any bloody reflections of the war - except for the repetitive showing of the soldier's crime. In fact, most of the acting is set in the house of the couple. The film conveys its message very subtle but thus even more mind shattering: I remember the scene where the body stump of the man is seated in typical Japanese tradition in the middle of the room, slightly lifted on a pillow, and circumvented by war insignia and a newspaper article about the "lord of the war". Sitting in this honorable position, you couldn't think of a better picture to show the absurdity and pitifulness of his existence as " god of war".

I strongly recommend this movie. The acting is great. It has deserved many people watching it.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Avatar (2009)
3/10
over-rated
21 February 2010
This movie is like a little man wearing too big clothes: too many special effects for the thin story, which has been conveyed many times before in simpler - real world-settings. What can computer animation add to it besides a little bit of extra entertainment? The creation of a virtual world would be more appropriate for a truly imaginary story (eg, like in Howl's moving castle). Apparently, this movie wants us to reflect on our cultural behaviors, so why placing the action on another planet, if you would be able to find a suitable setting for it on earth ? A little bit less good guy/bad guy cliché and more development and complexity in the characters would have given the movie more sophistication and credibility. People who are into "story-telling" will like the movie, but viewers who expect some artistry and originality will be disappointed.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Zen and the City
6 August 2005
In my interpretation this movie is a reflection on Zen philosophy: Just like Zen monks that sweep the courtyards of monasteries and devote themselves to the most humble tasks to find inner harmony, Niki finds inner rest in the daily work of removing the sand, solving water supply problems and living a confined live. The movie suggests the modern lives we live in the big cities isolate us from our needs and ourselves. Just like a Zen garden, that is designed to mirror nature and men, the people in the dunes reflect our daily struggles and confinements. The surreal setting is a necessity to convey the message of the film. There is nothing goofy about the pits and how people behave in there. It is just hard for us western people to see the transcendence there.

I watched this movie on a Japanese Film Festival in Berlin in 1993. I can't remember all the details but the movie really mesmerized me. It is a very unique work and I wonder why it doesn't have the cult status of other movies.
48 out of 67 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed