This is going to be a very unpopular opinion, but hear me out before you judge.
The first season of Kidding had some of the best writing and directing for a TV show that I had experienced in years - a truly outstanding gem, and criminally underwatched. The show was just magical, bold and overall amazingly creative. Jim Carrey did a fantastic job and deserves all the praise he's been getting for his performance here. In a few words - I used to love the show.
But when I started watching the second season I discovered very quickly that there was something missing... the magic was just gone. This is most likely due to the almost completely absent directorial genius Michel Gondry, who directed half of the episodes in the first season and was deeply involved in the creative execution of the show. (If you've never heard of him I highly recommend checking out his other collaboration with Jim Carrey "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind", which is a masterpiece in its own right.) Gondry only ended up directing a measly two episodes in the second season, but it doesn't just end there. He actually expressed immense displeasure working on Kidding due to Dave Holsteins excessive micromanaging of all aspects of the show and its execution, which lead to Gondry taking a big step back from his creative involvement in the second season - and this is felt at every moment. The surreal and wondrous energy that Gondry brings to all of his projects was replaced by a more down-to-earth direction, which hurt the overall tone of Kidding and made it wildly inconsistent. Gone is the often surprising and innovative writing from season one - now the characters all act and talk like shells and caricatures of themselves. Especially the writing for Deirdre's character suffered greatly this season - I almost didn't recognize her, and not because of some much-needed character development, but because of how completely unbelievable her character has become. As a result of this Catherine Keener's acting also suffered, which made Deirdre's stories frustrating and boring. Carrey's Jeff unfortunately wasn't handled very well either, but overall more believable than most of the other characters. In addition to poorly written characters we also get whole plots and subplots that are either dropped altogether without any closure or brought to a premature and unstatisfying conclusion. (For example Jeff rebuilding the family of international "Mr.Pickles" representatives - this could have been a very fun and engaging plot if done right.)
Furthermore, the musical Score was recycled to death. The recurring themes did not bother during the first season since it was all new and fresh, and beautifully composed, but when you hear the same darn tune for the hundreth time during the second season it will likely get on some viewers nerves and result in, once again, a lack of joy and innovation. Some of the amazing pieces from the first season (The track at the end of the very first episode gave me chills!) were never heard of again or built up on. This is just a shame since the composer David Wingo did such a fantastic job initially. I can only guess that Dave Holstein cut the music budget. Whatever resulted in this misuse of the music, it is incredibly disappointing.
But where it really started to fall apart for me was the direction, which could not have been more uninspired and dull in season two. Even the editing and cinematography were a let down because of this. The first season was full of memorable moments, like the famous one-shot scene of S1E3 - which was of course directed by Michel Gondry. Moments like these really made the show feel cinematic and special. Season two had no such moments, most scenes felt like the life was sucked out of them.
I could talk for hours about my displeasure with the second season, but will leave it at that. It is mindbloggling to me how so many people did not notice the very obvious shift in tone and decline in quality - to the point where some even say the second season topped the first. Yikes. If there is a third season I hope Michel Gondry will agree to be, once again, more deeply involved and given more creative freedom, since I strongly believe he was what made the show so great in the first place. Actors can only do so much, as brilliant as they may be. If the showrunner runs the show into the ground and the writing and directing are subpar, the whole thing falls apart.
But when I started watching the second season I discovered very quickly that there was something missing... the magic was just gone. This is most likely due to the almost completely absent directorial genius Michel Gondry, who directed half of the episodes in the first season and was deeply involved in the creative execution of the show. (If you've never heard of him I highly recommend checking out his other collaboration with Jim Carrey "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind", which is a masterpiece in its own right.) Gondry only ended up directing a measly two episodes in the second season, but it doesn't just end there. He actually expressed immense displeasure working on Kidding due to Dave Holsteins excessive micromanaging of all aspects of the show and its execution, which lead to Gondry taking a big step back from his creative involvement in the second season - and this is felt at every moment. The surreal and wondrous energy that Gondry brings to all of his projects was replaced by a more down-to-earth direction, which hurt the overall tone of Kidding and made it wildly inconsistent. Gone is the often surprising and innovative writing from season one - now the characters all act and talk like shells and caricatures of themselves. Especially the writing for Deirdre's character suffered greatly this season - I almost didn't recognize her, and not because of some much-needed character development, but because of how completely unbelievable her character has become. As a result of this Catherine Keener's acting also suffered, which made Deirdre's stories frustrating and boring. Carrey's Jeff unfortunately wasn't handled very well either, but overall more believable than most of the other characters. In addition to poorly written characters we also get whole plots and subplots that are either dropped altogether without any closure or brought to a premature and unstatisfying conclusion. (For example Jeff rebuilding the family of international "Mr.Pickles" representatives - this could have been a very fun and engaging plot if done right.)
Furthermore, the musical Score was recycled to death. The recurring themes did not bother during the first season since it was all new and fresh, and beautifully composed, but when you hear the same darn tune for the hundreth time during the second season it will likely get on some viewers nerves and result in, once again, a lack of joy and innovation. Some of the amazing pieces from the first season (The track at the end of the very first episode gave me chills!) were never heard of again or built up on. This is just a shame since the composer David Wingo did such a fantastic job initially. I can only guess that Dave Holstein cut the music budget. Whatever resulted in this misuse of the music, it is incredibly disappointing.
But where it really started to fall apart for me was the direction, which could not have been more uninspired and dull in season two. Even the editing and cinematography were a let down because of this. The first season was full of memorable moments, like the famous one-shot scene of S1E3 - which was of course directed by Michel Gondry. Moments like these really made the show feel cinematic and special. Season two had no such moments, most scenes felt like the life was sucked out of them.
I could talk for hours about my displeasure with the second season, but will leave it at that. It is mindbloggling to me how so many people did not notice the very obvious shift in tone and decline in quality - to the point where some even say the second season topped the first. Yikes. If there is a third season I hope Michel Gondry will agree to be, once again, more deeply involved and given more creative freedom, since I strongly believe he was what made the show so great in the first place. Actors can only do so much, as brilliant as they may be. If the showrunner runs the show into the ground and the writing and directing are subpar, the whole thing falls apart.
Tell Your Friends