Reviews

50 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Streets of San Francisco: Underground (1976)
Season 4, Episode 18
A Different Perspective
12 March 2024
The reviewer FloridaFeld refers to Streets of San Francisco as a "run-of-the mill police show". The facts belie that characterization. Streets of San Francisco was nominated three times (out of five seasons) for the Emmy Award for Best Dramatic Series. The lead actors, Karl Malden and Michael Douglas, were also nominated for acting Emmys for four of the five years that the series was on the air. In five seasons the program received 16 Emmy nominations (at a time when there were a limited number of categories). The series may suffer today in comparison to cable series such as The Wire (of course it does), but in the early 1970s Streets of San Francisco was a quality network continuing series.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
In Reply To Being "Boring"
12 March 2024
Bac-96806 dismisses the episode, "Requiem For Murder" as "boring"; "uninspired"; and "terrible". However the teleplay for this episode, penned by James Johnson Sweeney, won the 1976 Edgar Allan Poe award for best episode of a television series. The amazing thing about The Streets of San Francisco is that even with the plethora of constraints placed upon broadcast television (before the advent of cable) by the various offices of broadcast standards (that is, censors), this series was able to develop compelling stories that captured one's attention on a weekly basis. Given the restraints, that was no mean accomplishment.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
True Detective: Night Country: Part 1 (2024)
Season 4, Episode 1
deja vu
24 February 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Nowhere in the credits is it mentioned, but this series seem to be a remake of a 2021 spanish series called the head, which was created by jorge dorado and was streamed over hbo asia. The only difference that i can discern is that the head transpires in antarctica while night country takes place in the arctic. The named creator of this version, issa lopez, a mexican writer and producer, does not cite the head as an influence, but the parallels are eerie, including the opening sequence where a delivery person finds the research station apparently deserted. The head was a thought provoking series and kept me engrossed. Perhaps night country will do the same.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Deception Paves The Way
9 November 2023
Warning: Spoilers
First, do not access this television series thinking that it has something/anything to do with the 007 franchise. You will be sorely disappointed. I sat through an advance preview of the first two episodes of this "reality" series expecting a television-sized Bond to engage in the espionage for which he is famous. Again, no.

Nine pairs of "everyday" blokes hunt for clues that, if answered correctly, in the end will reward them with one million English pounds. The conceit here, and the element that requires substantial viewer suspension of disbelief, is that each duo is supposed to be in the wilderness (or on a mountain top; or along the canals of Venice) isolated from assistance (other than the disembodied voice of Brian Cox), even though each couple is accompanied by, at a minimum, a cameraman, a sound engineer and a segment director.

Each couple is required to maintain the illusion that they are alone, even though alternating camera angles make it obvious that "scenes" had to be paused while the camera changed perspective. There is a grating understanding that the audience (you and me) are being manipulated and condescended to - "play along. Pretend its real". No, thank you.
35 out of 81 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Barnaby Jones: The Deadly Jinx (1974)
Season 2, Episode 15
Matte Effect
8 November 2023
There is a misapprehension that animation techniques were used to create the powerboat explosion. Actually, in many television and theatrical films where the budget was limited (which was the case with most television series in the sixties and seventies), the cost would have been prohibitive to destroy a boat just to move the plot along. It was cheaper to simply add a matte effect in post production to make it seem that the boat exploded. Barnaby Jones employed this technique often. In a number of episodes airplane crashes were simulated with the same matte effect. It saved money and was hardly noticeable in the days before HD TV.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pier 23 (1951)
8/10
Worth It For The Dialogue Alone
7 October 2023
This film, which seems like two episodes of what would have been a very enjoyable early television series, has great hard-boiled narration from Hugh Beaumont as a private eye trolling on the edges of respectability. In the late 1950s a more sophisticated version of his Dennis O'Brien character would arrive on television in the form of Craig Stevens as Peter Gunn. The director, William Berke, working on virtually a non-existent budget, has squeezed terrific performances out of Beaumont and a supporting cast that worked for peanuts but succeeded in creating a small gem of a motion picture. Enjoy.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wagon Train: The Isaiah Quickfox Story (1965)
Season 8, Episode 17
No Indian Need Apply
17 August 2023
This is in response to reviewer dlawhead. Quickfox was played by the actor Frank De Kova, who was not Native American, but was of Italian heritage. He was born in New York City and was a schoolteacher before becoming an actor. As with many films and television series, Native American characters were played by non Indians. The same was true of Asian characters (see the history of Charlie Chan, Mr. Moto and Fu Manchu). Not being credited in a film or television program was not the greatest insult; that was routine. Substituting Caucasians for people of color was the great eradication, and was very rarely criticized.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Millennium for the Next Millennium
11 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
One of the central themes of the three seasons of Crimson Rivers is the prevalence of religious mania, at both the fringes and within the mainstream, that so often manifests itself in horrific, ritualized violence. Both Niemans and Delaunay, rational members of the law enforcement mechanism in the European Union, are confronted with corners of society still dwelling in the Middle Ages. Even the episodes that do not touch upon religion directly,possess elements of ritual and secrecy , cloaked in social privilege, that place them outside what would be described as conventional behavior. Crimson Rivers is the closest I have seen any series come to emulating the magnificent American series, Millennium.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Grave (2019)
8/10
Parallel Series About Parallel Universes
27 May 2023
Warning: Spoilers
If you watched the brilliant Fox television series, Fringe, this Israeli program will seem quite familiar. Many of the same issues are addressed and the explanations are as intriguing as those presented in the original American series. Interestingly, both series are also narrated from the perspective of a law enforcement officer: Olivia Dunham in Fringe; Chava Popper in The Grave. The major difference between the two stories, however, is significant. Fringe was provided the opportunity to tell its story over five seasons and one hundred episodes. The Grave was shut down after only eight episodes. But they are an intriguing eight episodes. The Grave is a worthy successor to Fringe.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A Response to Irishmama34
14 April 2023
Your timeframe for The Fugitive television series is off by three years. The Fugitive began its four year run in September 1963. By 1966, the year Dead Heat On A Merry-Go-Round was released, David Janssen's series was entering its final season. The reason that Janssen has no film credits between 1963 and 1967 is that The Fugitive occupied all of his time. He was in virtually every scene. In fact, the series was so physically taxing that David Janssen's heath had begun to suffer, and it was for this reason that the series ended after four seasons. So, it may have been Janssen doing a bit part for a lark, but most likely was not.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mayor of Kingstown (2021– )
10/10
Taylor Sheridan's Dystopian Masterpiece
4 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
When I first watched Season One of this series I was reluctant to write a review because I believed those ten ten episodes were simply a prelude to a more expansive study of the social and civil collapse of the United States.

I am glad that I waited. What we have here is a near-future examination of a society in free-fall, the fictional city of Kingstown standing in for a nation that has been corrupted by its own racism, inequality and avarice. Diane Wiest as Miriam McClusky is both the matriarch of the McClusky family and the voice used to delineate the roots of America's moral devaluation, Slavery and the Native American genocide. It is telling that as the series begins she is teaching the book, Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee.

We know that we are witnessing the future because the death penalty in Michigan was abolished in 1963. At one point we are witness to the gruesome execution of a drive-by shooter, and we see the horror of state ritualized murder. At the conclusion of the killing, a member of the victim's family shakes his head while questioning: "Why didn't you warn me?

There is no respite from the desolation. There is no redemption. There is, however the understanding that when the bell does eventually toll, it tolls for thee.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Spinning Gold (2023)
1/10
The Ultimate Vanity Production
30 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
In 1966 Embassy Pictures released one of the great bombs of all time, The Oscar, starring Stephen Boyd. This film, Spinning Gold, does to the music industry what The Oscar did to the motion picture business. Written, produced and directed by it seems every living member (and one dead presence) of the Bogart clan, it flies in the face of the basic motion picture mantra, "show, don't tell". The film is narrated by the subject himself, Neil Bogart, who has been dead for almost forty-one years. It is a hagiographic gloss on the career of the Bogart patriarch, full of superficial accounts of the fall and rise and fall and rise again of the intrepid creator of Casablanca Records, while even tacking on the cliche of Bogart's purchasing a home and automobile for his long-suffering parents.

Jason Isaac, utilizing some form of an American/New York accent, is wasted in this film, as are the women who flock around the Bogart character to little effect. For a 140 minute film (that's right!), including a tacked on tribute within the tribute, the supporting players are never developed beyond the hanger-on stereotype we have seen in countless films pretending to be biographical accounts of historical figures.

The Bogart family, I am sure, will make an annual ritual of screening this film on Neil Bogart's birthday, reliving the "glory days" of Casablanca Records. For the rest of us, this vanity project will disappear quickly into the great maw of of streaming television's insatiable need for "product".
14 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Fine Film; A Missed Opportunity
18 March 2023
Boston Strangler, written and directed by Matt Ruskin, is more a study of the struggle of women reporters to be taken seriously, than it is an explication of the events surrounding the thirteen murders attributed to Albert DeSalvo. Loretta McLaughlin and Jean Cole were "girl" reporters (a deprecatory term used by the Boston Police Department) who broke the story in the early 1960s when no one else had discerned the pattern linking the murders. It is an extremely well-done film that actually deserved more time to develop its main storyline. This would have been a great miniseries, perhaps eight to ten episodes during which the relationship between the two women reporters could be developed thoroughly. Enjoy the film but recognize that the opportunity was missed to make a compelling miniseries.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Picket Fences: When in Rome (1995)
Season 3, Episode 15
10/10
A Most Important Episode
9 March 2023
The three reviewers of this episode, all of whom have stated that they believe this to be one of the worst (if not THE worst) episodes of the series, misunderstand the importance of what Kelley has articulated, and have missed the point that this is a signature episode explicating the primary point of Picket Fences. David Kelley, in many of his creations, has attempted to expose the hypocrisy of people and communities that pride themselves on their tolerance and liberalism. It amplifies previous episodes that dealt with school desegregation and non-conformists. And it lampoons the casual liberalism of people whose liberalism is seldom challenged. When challenged, they routinely revert to an ugly intolerance.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hawaii Five-O: Most Likely to Murder (1970)
Season 2, Episode 21
A Short Corrective
6 January 2023
Planktonrules' review of this episode mentions that the guest star, Tom Skerritt, was a young man in one of his earliest roles. Actually, Skerritt was 35 years old at the time this episode was broadcast and had appeared in twenty-five different television series and motion pictures, including Robert Altman's MASH. His reputation was significant to the extent that he was the lead guest star in this episode. He was a significant presence in the early part of his career with multiple appearances in such series as Combat and The Virginian. This corrective in no way should be seen as a criticism of planktonrules' review.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Killing Eve (2018–2022)
9/10
The Extended Fantasy
3 January 2023
Killing Eve is an exceptionally well-made fantasy that treads ground similar to the series Alex Rider and Slow Horses. It perpetuates the myth that the British espionage services are viable players on the world stage. To watch and enjoy, one must suspend disbelief (which is necessary with most films and television that rely on the fantastical as a driving force). The acting is first rate, from the leads Sandra Oh and Jodie Comer to the supporting players populating the periphery (although, as is customary with much British drama, these ancillary characters are barely fleshed out). As my 9 rating indicates, the series is woth watching.
16 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Pennyworth (2019–2022)
10/10
Everyone Has A Double?
11 December 2022
This is not actually a review of this brilliant series (maybe that does qualify as a review, after all) but, instead an observation on the similarities between fiction and life. Anyway, is it my imagination or is Ben Aldridge/Thomas Wayne the spitting image of the cartoon character Bob Belcher from Bob's Burgers? The mustache alone would seal the comparison. Other than that trenchant analysis, I will say that Pennyworth is a worthy successor (or actually precursor) to the fabulous Fox series, Gotham. I considered Gotham to be one of the few network series that looked and felt like a cable series.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Andy Griffith Show: Guest in the House (1965)
Season 5, Episode 24
Answering mpotter's question.
26 October 2022
I believe that the song playing in the background of the diner scene is an instrumental version of "All of Me", written in 1931 by Gerald Marks and Seymour Simons. It was recorded in 1931 by Ruth Etting and was also recorded four different times by Frank Sinatra. The song is considered so significant that in 2000 "All of Me" was presented with the Towering Song Award by the Songwriter's Hall of Fame. Many versions of this song were performed. This instrumental version may be the composition recorded by Paul Whiteman and His Orchestra. Goober being Goober, his dancing is a counterpoint to the actual tempo of the song.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Dead Zone: Total Awareness (2004)
Season 3, Episode 5
9/10
Another Prescient Episode
8 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Long before Edward Snowden revealed the existence of PRISM, the NSA's mass data collection operation, this episode of the Dead Zone postulated a similar program of total government surveillance. In 2004 total surveillance was in its infancy and was looked upon as an intolerable intrusion into personal privacy. Today, most people have accepted surveillance cameras everywhere and have come to believe that such a surveillance state is natural and necessary. This episode of the Dead Zone was a voice of dissent and it is remarkable to see how much privacy people have been willing to surrender for the nebulous guarantee of security. Watch this with a jaundiced eye.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Dead Zone: Plague (2003)
Season 2, Episode 14
9/10
It's Fiction!
4 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The irresponsible political rant by LHAVEN (which is being passed off as a review) uses this fairly prescient episode as an attack against the Biden Administration and an affirmation of Trump's criminal mishandling of the coronavirus. LHAVEN treats this episode as reality; that because chloroquinine is the miracle cure in Plague that it would also have been the miracle cure for Covid-19. There is not a shred of evidence that the quack remedies trumpeted by Trump would have had any positive effect on Covid-19. It is amazing that LHAVEN's review was even approved for publication. Fiction and its attendant exaggerations and distortions should never be mistaken for reality.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Father Knows Best: The Promising Young Man (1956)
Season 3, Episode 16
Reviewing A Review
10 August 2022
This is more a corrective to the review by MichaeleMartinDesapio than it is an analysis of the episode. The reviewer misuses the word "protege". Jim Anderson is actually a "mentor" to Elwood. Elwood is the protege. Also, the reviewer states that Richard Crenna is probably best known for his character on Our Miss Brooks. More likely he is best known for his portrayal of Luke McCoy on The Real McCoys. He played Luke for almost three times as many episodes.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
One After Another
25 July 2022
There are so many of these short form British procedurals that they have a tendency to bleed (no pun) into each other. This is no better, and no worse, than the rest of the programs that have proliferated over the past decade. The acting is serviceable. Character development is by the numbers (new baby; recent divorce; secondary players barely fleshed out). The four cases in Series One provide few surprises (if you are familiar with this kind of stuff) and are essentially comfort food for brains on autopilot. Six hours to dampen one's expectations. That is, if you come to these four episodes expecting very little you will not be disappointed.
12 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bosch: Legacy (2022– )
1/10
Earnest Is Not The Same As Good
31 May 2022
The substandard elements on display in the original Bosch series - stilted dialogue reminiscent of a vintage episode of Dragnet; the absolutely underwhelming acting of Madison Lintz; and the righteous earnestness of Harry Bosch's search for truth and justice - are here magnified to a level usually encountered only in the cookie-cutter procedurals on display nightly on CBS.

Bosch is/was successful because it never exceeds the expectations of an audience conditioned to expect less - there is never a "wow" moment associated with this series. The actors are never asked to stretch the limitations of their characters, and it is distinctly possible that such gymnastics are beyond their capabilities.

This could have been a much better series. However, better would have meant a greater commitment by all involved to actually care about what they were doing. "Legacy" will certainly make money (it has already been renewed for Season 2). For many, that is all that matters.
21 out of 38 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
For Downton Devotees Only
19 May 2022
Warning: Spoilers
The film, as an extension of the television program, demands that one be intimately familiar with the main and subordinate characters as presented in the PBS/Masterpiece series. There is absolutely no character development, on the assumption that anyone with a desire to submit herself to this trifle will be intimately familiar with the narrative and will be predisposed to laugh when prompted and shed a tear when appropriate.

The literal film within a film concerns itself with the momentous cinematic transition from silent film to sound. One can be forgiven if this portion of "A New Era" reminds one of the central plotline of "Singin' In The Rain", since the two stories are virtually interchangeable. Julian Fellowes probably should have added a script credit to Betty Comden and Adolph Green.

The advertising campaign touts this film as "escapist fun". Escapiist it may be. Fun is in the eye of the beholder. For Downton fans only.
11 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Slow Horses (2022– )
5/10
The Myth Of British Relevance
12 May 2022
Whenever one observes a film or television program involving British "intelligence" services, one must spend an exorbitant amount of time engaged in the suspension of disbelief. Anyone familiar in the least with the geopolitical circumstance of the world is cognizant of the fact that Great Britain has been an irrelevant player on the world stage for decades.

The British intelligence apparatus is relevant only to the extent that the United States permits it to be. Huge sums of public money are expended to perpetuate the myth of British relevance. This program, especially Episode One, places on display a massive MI-5 intelligence operation comprised of, it appears, thousands of employees engaged in a fantasy world of spy-vs-spy.

There are so many better British television series with which one can and should engage. It is not so much a waste of time, as it is a candy bar best left unchewed.
15 out of 43 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

Recently Viewed