"Dredd"/"Dredd 3D" is not the Judge Dredd film that I'd like to have seen but it is an excellent attempt to bring the character back to the big screen (after the disastrous 1995 Stallone vehicle "Judge Dredd"). It is a simple film in which the titular hero is pitted against merciless enemies in the controlled environment of a locked down super- skyscraper. The genius of the Judge Dredd stories was to make us empathise with Dredd himself and his zero tolerance approach to the law. I can only hope that "Dredd" is successful enough for a more nuanced film to be made, there are many superb Dredd stories to work from.
PLOT OUTLINE
Judge-cadet (and psychic) Cassandra Anderson and her evaluating officer Judge Dredd respond to the scene of a multiple murder in the Peach Trees city block of Mega-City One. They are sealed inside by a ruthless drug- dealing gangster who is determined that they should not escape alive.
REVIEW
Filmed on significantly less than half the budget of the previous movie, the filmmakers have been forced to create a different, and in many ways more credible, Mega-City One. In "Dredd" we see an enormous city dotted here and there with towering, kilometre tall, city blocks. Roads filled with conventional vehicles and everything overshadowed by the towering Hall of Justice with its just-not-quite-fascist eagle emblem. It is a convincing setting that successfully highlights the gritty dystopian nature of Mega-City One.
This more practical approach extends to the costumes which take an intelligent approach to combining the iconic elements from the comics (the shield badge and eagle shoulder pad) into something that someone who isn't in a comic might actually wear.
One small disappointment for me was the guns. The Judge's sidearms were highly convincing but the villains all appeared to be carrying what one would think would be prized antiques (assuming the time-line to be somewhere between 2070 and 2100).
Karl Urban is excellent as Judge Dredd capturing his aggressive and humourless approach toward the rigid application of the law. He looks exactly as Dredd should and speaks his lines with total conviction. Olivia Thirlby as Anderson does a great job of injecting some humanity into the story and providing the audience with someone to identify with. The writer and director (and I suspect Ms Thirlby also) clearly understand that the best Judge Dredd stories are never *about* Dredd but about people who come into contact with him and the circumstances surrounding those events. Lena Hedley has little to do but what she does she does well.
The special effects are good, the addition of the time slowing drug offers some good opportunities for slow-mo violence. Despite the "3D" tag on the film I'd love to have seen this in good old fashioned 2D as I found the 3D elements distracting and jarring. I will be buying Dredd on Bluray as soon as it comes out. The story is, as detailed above, extremely simple and the film is a series of what have no doubt be described as "high-octane" set-pieces with little or nothing else. As several others on IMDb have said, I eagerly await the sequel.
NOTES
It seems worth providing some information for people who may not be familiar with the character of Judge Joseph "Joe" Dredd. Created in the late 1970s for the newly created British weekly comic magazine 2000AD, Dredd is perhaps one of the best examples of a mis-aimed fandom in history. He was, it is said, intended to be a satirical comment on then popular fears of a political descent into fascism (it is worth nothing that "V for Vendetta" was written at around the same time). For anyone who is interested in reading a Judge Dredd comic, I recommend the stories "America" and "The Pit" (both available as self contained graphic novels).
PLOT OUTLINE
Judge-cadet (and psychic) Cassandra Anderson and her evaluating officer Judge Dredd respond to the scene of a multiple murder in the Peach Trees city block of Mega-City One. They are sealed inside by a ruthless drug- dealing gangster who is determined that they should not escape alive.
REVIEW
Filmed on significantly less than half the budget of the previous movie, the filmmakers have been forced to create a different, and in many ways more credible, Mega-City One. In "Dredd" we see an enormous city dotted here and there with towering, kilometre tall, city blocks. Roads filled with conventional vehicles and everything overshadowed by the towering Hall of Justice with its just-not-quite-fascist eagle emblem. It is a convincing setting that successfully highlights the gritty dystopian nature of Mega-City One.
This more practical approach extends to the costumes which take an intelligent approach to combining the iconic elements from the comics (the shield badge and eagle shoulder pad) into something that someone who isn't in a comic might actually wear.
One small disappointment for me was the guns. The Judge's sidearms were highly convincing but the villains all appeared to be carrying what one would think would be prized antiques (assuming the time-line to be somewhere between 2070 and 2100).
Karl Urban is excellent as Judge Dredd capturing his aggressive and humourless approach toward the rigid application of the law. He looks exactly as Dredd should and speaks his lines with total conviction. Olivia Thirlby as Anderson does a great job of injecting some humanity into the story and providing the audience with someone to identify with. The writer and director (and I suspect Ms Thirlby also) clearly understand that the best Judge Dredd stories are never *about* Dredd but about people who come into contact with him and the circumstances surrounding those events. Lena Hedley has little to do but what she does she does well.
The special effects are good, the addition of the time slowing drug offers some good opportunities for slow-mo violence. Despite the "3D" tag on the film I'd love to have seen this in good old fashioned 2D as I found the 3D elements distracting and jarring. I will be buying Dredd on Bluray as soon as it comes out. The story is, as detailed above, extremely simple and the film is a series of what have no doubt be described as "high-octane" set-pieces with little or nothing else. As several others on IMDb have said, I eagerly await the sequel.
NOTES
It seems worth providing some information for people who may not be familiar with the character of Judge Joseph "Joe" Dredd. Created in the late 1970s for the newly created British weekly comic magazine 2000AD, Dredd is perhaps one of the best examples of a mis-aimed fandom in history. He was, it is said, intended to be a satirical comment on then popular fears of a political descent into fascism (it is worth nothing that "V for Vendetta" was written at around the same time). For anyone who is interested in reading a Judge Dredd comic, I recommend the stories "America" and "The Pit" (both available as self contained graphic novels).
Tell Your Friends