4/10
Read The Book!
24 July 2004
The novel, 'Random Harvest' by James Hilton might be un-filmable.

I read this book every year on November 11. And, every year a lump forms in my throat at the novels' end.

Unfortunately, the movie doesn't deliver. Ronald Coleman is mis-cast (too old), Robert Donat would have been better. The movie doesn't capture the feeling of pre-WWII England sonambulisticly heading into war. Hilton did a great job with the novel; but unlike his 'Lost Horizon' and 'Good-bye, Mr. Chips', Hollywood couldn't put it on the screen.

-30-
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed