I adore this film. It's touching right to the heart. It was on the AMC channel one night and I happened to catch it. I was pleasantly surprised by how well the film kept my attention, regardless to the fact that it was silent. Usually, silent films tend to be boring at points, if you aren't use to them, but not this one. It was well written, and the music goes perfectly with the story. I have never seen a better silent film (yet, if there is one?). But I would advise that the plot isn't a light-hearted one , and although it has its romantic moments, I see this movie as more of a film for a rainy day, rather than for a date night, etc. But if you haven't seen this film, I strongly recommend it, even if you're not the silent film "type".
Review of The Red Lily
