4/10
It's great to see lesser-known Columbia movies again. But ...
6 January 2007
This movie has many charms. It has a fine cast. William Holden, in an atypical role, is fun as the dreamer who sings many standard songs. (It opens with him singing in black-face, though. That is always shocking when encountered today. And I wonder if it wasn't viewed as somewhat inappropriate even in 1950 when this was released.) Coleen Gray makes a charming love interest for Holden. And Charles Winninger is always a welcome presence.

The supporting cast is excellent too. Stuart Erwin gets low billing but what a fine actor he as! And the two spinster sisters who are interested in Holden are nicely cast also.

It is indeed a pleasure to see Columbia pictures other than the Capra films and those with Judy Holliday (whom I love) turn up. A few with Jean Arthur have been around in the VHS/DVD era but none to compare with the great number to which we were treated in the 1960s and seventies when local TV stations showed old movies.

However, the print of this one was terrible. At first I thought it was a nighttime scene. But it wasn't. It was very, very dark.

I am delighted at the Columbia movies trickling out again. Now, what about the Republic movies other than the ones that star John Wayne?
8 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed