This movie is a difficult one to review, because it alternates between being clever and uproariously funny to being just plain stupid. So, I'll blame the director and screenwriters for its failures.
For example, early in the film, when Fred MacMurray is trying to explain who Eleanor Parker is to his fiancé and soon-to-be father-in-law...now that's clever and uproariously funny. As is the slapstick scene in a diner. But every time Parker faints...well, that's just stupid. Much the same can be said about the romantic scenes between MacMurray. One minute they're falling in love, the next minute Parker is being manipulative and downright obnoxious.
MacMurray is never funnier (and he could be a very funny actor) than when a situation befuddles him. That happens a lot in this film. On the other hand, this film is quite a departure for Parker...and it shows. She really fits better in dramas, and this screwball comedy proves that. Although, I have to admit I enjoyed her discomfort in the role.
Although I'm only giving this a "6", watch it and decide for yourself.
For example, early in the film, when Fred MacMurray is trying to explain who Eleanor Parker is to his fiancé and soon-to-be father-in-law...now that's clever and uproariously funny. As is the slapstick scene in a diner. But every time Parker faints...well, that's just stupid. Much the same can be said about the romantic scenes between MacMurray. One minute they're falling in love, the next minute Parker is being manipulative and downright obnoxious.
MacMurray is never funnier (and he could be a very funny actor) than when a situation befuddles him. That happens a lot in this film. On the other hand, this film is quite a departure for Parker...and it shows. She really fits better in dramas, and this screwball comedy proves that. Although, I have to admit I enjoyed her discomfort in the role.
Although I'm only giving this a "6", watch it and decide for yourself.