Saw this when it first aired and then again as a re-run sometime later, not sure precisely when. Both viewings were little treats.
The plot is simple and has been a staple of books and movies for well over a century: an aged and disillusioned recluse regains his or her humanity through the unexpected and, initially unwelcome, intrusion of an either troubled or in-trouble (or both) waif of some sort. Anybody out there ever heard of Heidi, Scrooge, Silas Marner or Pollyanna?
This working of the theme is both honest and touching as both characters work through their various layers of protection and come to value one another as individuals, quietly and without melodrama. If it ever surfaces again I'll be watching and strongly recommend others do so as well.
As for the other reviews - the dubbing went past me as well and it certainly didn't affect my opinion of Cagney's performance. I can understand an insider's opinion on the matter but my perspective is that of a consumer: if the final product works, that's the product I'll buy.
And if you expected a "Jimmy Cagney" Movie, why? Cagney was in his 80's and well past his hoofer and Bad Boy days. As always, review the movie on the screen.
As for myself, If it does ever resurface, I'll record and archive it on a DVD, prizing it as a little gem.
The plot is simple and has been a staple of books and movies for well over a century: an aged and disillusioned recluse regains his or her humanity through the unexpected and, initially unwelcome, intrusion of an either troubled or in-trouble (or both) waif of some sort. Anybody out there ever heard of Heidi, Scrooge, Silas Marner or Pollyanna?
This working of the theme is both honest and touching as both characters work through their various layers of protection and come to value one another as individuals, quietly and without melodrama. If it ever surfaces again I'll be watching and strongly recommend others do so as well.
As for the other reviews - the dubbing went past me as well and it certainly didn't affect my opinion of Cagney's performance. I can understand an insider's opinion on the matter but my perspective is that of a consumer: if the final product works, that's the product I'll buy.
And if you expected a "Jimmy Cagney" Movie, why? Cagney was in his 80's and well past his hoofer and Bad Boy days. As always, review the movie on the screen.
As for myself, If it does ever resurface, I'll record and archive it on a DVD, prizing it as a little gem.