Eternal Love (1929) is not the film for those who seek originality. The story of ill-fated lovers in the Alps hits every melodramatic beat, from forced marriages to scheming jealous admirers. But it makes up for this flaw with tender performances from John Barrymore and Camilla Horn, who elevate the tired story and archetypal characters to a higher place through their chemistry and yearning. They make this small-scale romantic tragedy feel almost operatic at times, and their fate will leave you sobbing by the end.
Mona Rico also gives a fine performance as the promiscuous and wild Pia, who seeks to possess Barrymore at any cost. Even though her character is unlikable and mean, she has great charisma. It is a shame she never became a star.
EL is not a great piece of cinema, but it is a sweet, skillfully made melodrama that lovers of silent film might like to check out.
Mona Rico also gives a fine performance as the promiscuous and wild Pia, who seeks to possess Barrymore at any cost. Even though her character is unlikable and mean, she has great charisma. It is a shame she never became a star.
EL is not a great piece of cinema, but it is a sweet, skillfully made melodrama that lovers of silent film might like to check out.