I love this show. I watched it growing up following the love boat and have every episode now. In season four episode 21, the Devils triangle, Mr. Roarke explains the plane went down in an area known as the Devils triangle which is very close to Fantasy Island. This would obviously put fantasy Island in the Atlantic ocean very close to the Caribbean. I've never understood why they always say this takes place in the Pacific one references throughout the show specially when it comes to planes flying over or to the island make it clear it's in the Atlantic. The overhead shots of the island and of the waterfalls or of course from the Hawaiian Islands. That being the case it's the only reason I can think of the people often say it's in the Pacific.
Review of Fantasy Island
