By virtually every measure, the name of the film is a misnomer, as the title character repeatedly explains that he doesn't hang anyone, he just captures outlaws and brings them to justice. Figuratively speaking though, Mack Bovard (Robert Taylor) is in the law and order business, and once he's got his sights set on a target, they're as good as done.
The film is quite the interesting character study of Bovard, who cynically decries human nature with the admonition that 'everyone has his price'. The deputy U.S. Marshal is about to test that theory once again when he tries to convince the widowed Selah Jennison (Tina Louise) to identify a murder and robbery suspect involved in a Wells Fargo heist. Failure to secure the capture of Johnny Butterfield will mean that he's liable to go scot-free, since the last remaining outlaw involved in the Wells Fargo job is about to hang; he's the only other person who knows what Johnny looks like.
The picture makes a pretty good guessing game out of the identity of Johnny Butterfield/Bishop (Jack Lord), possibly the only cowboy in Western movie history who doesn't have an enemy in the world in his settled, unnamed town. Bovard makes an immediate assumption that Bishop is his target, the one stretch that eventually bears out correctly, but it takes some maneuvering to get there. The film briefly detours into comic territory somewhat when Selah Jennison, who knows Bishop's true identity, handcuffs herself to Bovard to waylay the inevitable.
There's also a humorous gimmick running throughout the early part of the picture as Miss Amy Hopkins (Mabel Albertson) attempts to catch the deputy marshal's eye, but finally gives up, upset that she couldn't attract his attention to her matured charm and appreciation. Personally, I thought she was a busybody. The other character who caught my eye was the pretty waitress Molly (Betty Lynn) who just a few years later would have the unenviable task of being the girlfriend of hapless Barney Fife on "The Andy Griffith Show".
As almost all the other reviewers on this board have mentioned, the ending of the story comes almost out of left field, although attentive viewers might have seen it coming. Making it even more incredible was the way Sheriff Buck Weston (Fess Parker) handled it, he just stood there waving good-bye with no remorse. Maybe he was just too stunned.
The film is quite the interesting character study of Bovard, who cynically decries human nature with the admonition that 'everyone has his price'. The deputy U.S. Marshal is about to test that theory once again when he tries to convince the widowed Selah Jennison (Tina Louise) to identify a murder and robbery suspect involved in a Wells Fargo heist. Failure to secure the capture of Johnny Butterfield will mean that he's liable to go scot-free, since the last remaining outlaw involved in the Wells Fargo job is about to hang; he's the only other person who knows what Johnny looks like.
The picture makes a pretty good guessing game out of the identity of Johnny Butterfield/Bishop (Jack Lord), possibly the only cowboy in Western movie history who doesn't have an enemy in the world in his settled, unnamed town. Bovard makes an immediate assumption that Bishop is his target, the one stretch that eventually bears out correctly, but it takes some maneuvering to get there. The film briefly detours into comic territory somewhat when Selah Jennison, who knows Bishop's true identity, handcuffs herself to Bovard to waylay the inevitable.
There's also a humorous gimmick running throughout the early part of the picture as Miss Amy Hopkins (Mabel Albertson) attempts to catch the deputy marshal's eye, but finally gives up, upset that she couldn't attract his attention to her matured charm and appreciation. Personally, I thought she was a busybody. The other character who caught my eye was the pretty waitress Molly (Betty Lynn) who just a few years later would have the unenviable task of being the girlfriend of hapless Barney Fife on "The Andy Griffith Show".
As almost all the other reviewers on this board have mentioned, the ending of the story comes almost out of left field, although attentive viewers might have seen it coming. Making it even more incredible was the way Sheriff Buck Weston (Fess Parker) handled it, he just stood there waving good-bye with no remorse. Maybe he was just too stunned.