Were your emotions stirred? Did you pay attention? If you answered yes to either or both, the show worked,
Try thinking of it like a cover of a classic song, say... "You Really Got Me" You loved the original and the cover was awesome too. They were different and great on their own. Each one was unique and true to the song. Stop trying to compare this show so critically to previous versions. Each had its merits and its WTFs.
I have never loathed a story's character as much as Parker Posey's Dr. Smith. Please make more.
Try thinking of it like a cover of a classic song, say... "You Really Got Me" You loved the original and the cover was awesome too. They were different and great on their own. Each one was unique and true to the song. Stop trying to compare this show so critically to previous versions. Each had its merits and its WTFs.
I have never loathed a story's character as much as Parker Posey's Dr. Smith. Please make more.