Each of the Into the Dark episodes have resulted in similar disappointment. Most have had decent setup before falling into basic follow through. The exception being New Year, New You. Which was overall very good. The rest forfeited any originality for standard boilerplate. Horror movies or anthologies don't always have to fall into a standard formula.
It would be okay to be surprised occassionally. I will continue to watch each month and hope to be pleasantly surprised at some point.