1/10
A nonsensical adaptation of a great book
6 September 2020
After having read the complex and interesting Hugo award winning novel, I had high hopes for the 4 part miniseries. Alas, the screen adaptation needlessly departs from the tight, well thought out plotting of the novel to introduce a distracting and implausible Hollywood romance element, confusing flashbacks while garbling the plot.

The book requires acceptance of only a single premise: that two cities exist side by side with strict prohibitions on interactions between the two.

Do yourself a favor and skip the miniseries and read the book.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed