Lively, leggy Binnie Hale (when her legs are on display, it's hard to focus on anything else on the screen) and deadpan-funny Gordon Harker fail to salvage this padded non-starter: it spends more than half its running time getting character A, and then character B, and then character C to the lighthouse by various means when no viewer cares at all how they got there; the only chance this movie had to be exciting is if they had all arrived at the same location within the first 10 minutes. The lighthouse itself is a great, atmospheric setting, but it goes perhaps without saying that the "phantom" of the title is a red herring and the solution to the mystery is a mundane one. ** out of 4.
Review of The Phantom Light
The Phantom Light
(1935)
One star for Gordon Harker, one for the lighthouse setting, and three for Binnie Hale's legs
24 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers