The 2010 rendition of "Dog Pound," drawing inspiration from the 1979 classic "Scum," delivers a heightened experience, though not necessarily surpassing its predecessor. However, its denouement falls short when compared to the gratifying conclusion of the original. While many pivotal scenes from "Scum" are faithfully reproduced in "Dog Pound," the stark depiction of the prison environment in the former is favored. In "Dog Pound," there's a conspicuous absence of the callousness exhibited by the officers in "Scum," who are portrayed more as surrogate social workers. Younger audiences, commencing with "Dog Pound," may incline towards favoring it over "Scum." Personally, I found myself more captivated by "Dog Pound," particularly due to the introduction of the lead character. Director Kim Chapiron ought to have acknowledged Roy Minton, the writer of "Scum," for the script. While "Scum" may feel antiquated with its pervasive bleakness, "Dog Pound" falls short by being excessively lenient. Despite some adult characters displaying nuance, the primary plotlines remain strikingly similar, underscoring a dearth of creative innovation in recent film production.
Three young lads, Butch, Davis, and Angel, find themselves within the confines of Enola Vale nick in Montana. Officer Sands duly admits them, keeping a close eye particularly on fiery Butch, known for his previous transgressions. Goodyear, a firm yet fair screw, imparts advice to the lads, urging them to comport themselves for a shot at redemption. Though Butch attempts compliance, he soon finds himself a target for Banks, the alpha inmate, along with his cronies, Eckersley and Loony. Refusing to divulge information, Butch lands himself in solitary confinement. Tragedy strikes when Angel meets his demise and Davis chooses to end his own life. Fueled by a thirst for revenge, Butch incites a riot, only to be thwarted in his escape attempt, leaving him battered and broken by the riot squad.
Three young lads, Butch, Davis, and Angel, find themselves within the confines of Enola Vale nick in Montana. Officer Sands duly admits them, keeping a close eye particularly on fiery Butch, known for his previous transgressions. Goodyear, a firm yet fair screw, imparts advice to the lads, urging them to comport themselves for a shot at redemption. Though Butch attempts compliance, he soon finds himself a target for Banks, the alpha inmate, along with his cronies, Eckersley and Loony. Refusing to divulge information, Butch lands himself in solitary confinement. Tragedy strikes when Angel meets his demise and Davis chooses to end his own life. Fueled by a thirst for revenge, Butch incites a riot, only to be thwarted in his escape attempt, leaving him battered and broken by the riot squad.