I just watched a nitrate print of this film that was wrongly identified as "Yesteryears" with replacement inter-titles and I was able to identify Mary Pickford, Mack Sennett and Donald Crisp. Then I cross referenced the cast using the IMDb (thanks guys) and using a plot description found in another database verify "The Italian Barber" was the title. Below is the plot description I used and now share.
SPOILERS: A barber becomes enamored of the little newsgirl (Mary Pickford) on the corner near his shop. She allows him to escort her home. They become close friends until the barber sees her sister. A complicated problem arises and is eliminated when another young man enters the scene. He (Mack Sennett) becomes interested in the heartbroken and jilted young woman, and his attentions mend her emotional wounds.
SPOILERS: A barber becomes enamored of the little newsgirl (Mary Pickford) on the corner near his shop. She allows him to escort her home. They become close friends until the barber sees her sister. A complicated problem arises and is eliminated when another young man enters the scene. He (Mack Sennett) becomes interested in the heartbroken and jilted young woman, and his attentions mend her emotional wounds.
