The Man Without a Country (1917) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Fine Final Film For Florence La Badie
boblipton25 October 2021
Holmes Herbert is a well-to-do young man, fortunate enough to be engaged to Florence La Badie. Under the influence of her uncle, he joins an organization which urges peace at any price. When the First World War comes to the United States, however, opinions change around him. He is ostracized at his club, and worse, Miss La Badie ends their engagement and becomes an Army nurse. Matters grow worse for him as war fever sweeps the town, and the principal complaint he hears is how the servants and waiters, many of whom are immigrants, are joining the army. Herbert stays firm to his principles, until someone urges him to read Edward Everett's story; that night he dreams of being led like Scrooge amid the ghosts, by Lady Liberty through Phillip Nolan's long exile.

This late Thanhouser feature is a modern dress affair except for the the sequences of the dream. As with all of Thanhouser's production, it is beautifully shot, acted and dressed. Alas, it was pretty much the end of the company's run. Miss La Badie would die in a road accident soon after this, her final performance. The company would produce only four more pictures. Like many of the companies that prospered under the rule of the Patents Trust, it would vanish, so much so that for many decades people forgot its name.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
First Film Star to Die At Height of Her Career, Her final Movie.
springfieldrental25 July 2021
A number of movie actors and actresses have died during the peak of their careers throughout cinematic history. The shock of such deaths come out of left field, which makes their fans paralyzed at the thought of someone dying so young in life while appearing so recently vibrant on the screen. The first popular actress to die at the height of her film career was silent movie star Florence La Badie.

The tremendous popularity of young La Badie was reaching its apex when she avoided two trucks opposite of her car on the road from Albany, N. Y., to New York City after picking up her fiancé. She drove off the road and down a steep embankment, crushing her pelvis along with other injuries. Rushed to the local hospital, La Badie was seemingly on the mend when she developed blood poisoning, killing her at the young age of 29.

La Badie, Thanhouser Studio's top actress, had just wrapped up filming in what turned out to be her final movie, September 1917's "The Man Without A Country." The film became the touchstone to the conclusion of a prominent movie career spanning eight years.

Appearing on the stage, La Badie was introduced to movies by fellow-Canadian Mary Pickford when she introduced Florence to D. W. Griffith and Biograph Studios in 1909. An impromptu appearance in a Griffith movie elicited an invite to join the Biograph stock of actors. She accepted, appearing in 30 Biograph films. La Badie was offered a lucrative contract with Thanhouser Studios two years later and quickly became one of cinema's top female draws. Starring in 166 Thanhouser films such as one of movie's first horror films, 1912's "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde" as Jekyll's girlfriend, her stardom skyrocketed. La Badie's physical bravado is seen in the immensely financially successful film serial, "The Million Dollar Mystery," where she performed her own dangerous stunts.

The irony of her final film, "The Man Without A Country," was the part-Canadian La Badie became an anti-war activist when she saw pictures from a young Canadian soldier in France who sent her images he took capturing the carnage on the Western Front. She created a slide-show of those photos and went on a speaking tour warning her audience of the horrors of war. But once America entered World War One in April 1917, La Badie stopped the tour.

She stars in basically what could be a recruitment film for the United States Armed Services, which was beginning to raise volunteers over the summer of 1917. La Badie's character, Barbara, joins the Red Cross, while her fiancé, played by actor Holmes Herbert, is a vocal extreme pacifist who wears a "Peace At Any Price" button. Barbara breaks off the engagement because of his stance. Herbert is devastated, and with being shunned by his friends and his country club associates, he reads the famous short story written by Edward Hale given to him by an old family friend. He sees a vision of Barbara telling him he's the Philip Nolan in the story and eyewitnesses all the events happening to him as the main protagonist experienced in Hale's tale. The feel-good ending where the American soldiers embark for Europe includes none other than....

The concluding scene of La Badie was on the minds of movie goers when "Country" was released in early September while the actress was in the hospital recovering from the crash. When she died in mid-October, later conspiracy theories began cropping up about her mysterious, premature death. One had President Woodrow Wilson responsible for her accident: the wild story had Wilson impregnating her and had federal agents cut her automobile brakes to bury the affair.

"A Man Without A Country" likely would have been her final movie for Thanhouser Studios since her contract expired and several other studios were in a bidding war for her acting services. A large turnout appeared at her funeral, and she was buried in an unmarked grave at the Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn, New York. A grandson of Thanhouser Studio's founder in 2014 raised money to place a gravestone at her burial site on the anniversary of her 126th birthday.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Florence's Last Film!!
kidboots27 December 2014
Warning: Spoilers
1917 was a sad year for the Thanhouser Company. They were a small studio that operated out of New Rochelle and were able to give their films a spaciousness (parks and wide streets etc) that other studios just couldn't match. They also had the foresight to realise that the writing was on the wall as far as short films were concerned and in 1916 only feature films were produced by them. But in September 1917 Florence La Badie was involved in a car accident and after two months of clinging to life, died of her injuries. La Badie was their leading star and after that, Thanhouser, which was like a big family company, just gave up. By October, the studio was almost idle with no one on the premises.

Holmes Herbert was a beloved character actor of almost 200 films but he wasn't always old and in this patriotic movie, made at a time when Americans were being encouraged to volunteer for war service, he played John Alton, a devoted pacifist who meets orphan Barbara (La Badie) when she is staying at her uncle's house which is where the local Peace Brigade meets once a month. Barbara however doesn't share their views. Her father was killed in a war and she is fiercely patriotic and breaks her engagement to John because he will not put aside his peaceful views.

Barbara goes to France as a volunteer Red Cross nurse but sympathies are changing back home and John now finds himself almost a pariah for his views. An old club member who was best friends with his father gives him Edward Everett Hale's "The Man Without a Country" to read after he hears John utter the same words at the club "D--m the United States"!! Barbara comes to him in a vision and gives him a first hand look at the story of Lt. Philip Nolan who for his same treasonous remarks in 1805 was sentenced to exile on a drifting boat, forbidden to hear or ask anything about the United States for the rest of his life. Nolan ends his life clinging to a little scrap of American history a sympathetic friend has confided to him, and this story, together with the anxiety of receiving no news from Barbara who has been lost at sea, is enough to hurry John along to the nearest recruitment agency.

This is a gently patriotic film - sold very much on the premise of being based on Edward Everett Hale's powerful short story which really only took up about 10-12 minutes of the actual film. Sadly it became known as beautiful Florence La Badie's last film.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed