User Reviews

Since there's a summary the tells the whole story, I'll just mention a couple of gags. Since the fight's admission is one egg, Julius refuses to let someone who's not a chicken (I think he's a bear) come in. This bear proves he can lay an egg by, when Julius is not looking, takes one from the hanging scale above the cat and removes it from under him as Julius looks back puzzled! As the puzzled cat looks back inside the entrance, a snake balances an egg on his head before eating one. He then eats two more before the cat catches him and squeezes the eggs out of the snake! Highly amusing animated cartoon. Worth seeing if you're an enthusiast of early Walt Disney.

. . . for me to see that Dizzy Nature had explored egg plants on film nearly a century ago. Since I had minored in Egg Plants at Northern, I was literally at the edge of my seat watching ALICE'S EGG PLANT. You probably can imagine my disappointment, then, to find out that Alice does not seem to know her egg plants from her rutabaga. There is absolutely no indication here that Alice is aware that egg plant is a delicate, tropical perennial growth often cultivated as a tender or half-hardy annual in temperate climates. Does Alice reckon that her plants have spiny stems, flowers white to purple in color and egg-shaped green fruit? Doubtful. Though she's pictured taking an order for her product, it does not seem to originate from such likely sources as Asia or the Middle East. Could Alice's confusion be due to her being more familiar with this plant as 'West African Squash'? I see no proof for that here. Has Alice ever whipped up a batch of tamarind lentil stew featuring her crop? What do YOU think?

OF the 10 or so ALICE IN CARTOONLAND Series Cartoons which we have seen, this one rates pretty high on the ratings chart. Of course it must seem to be very primitive to the uninitiated viewer; and certainly it was that way!

BUT it also provides us with a glimpse at the yet un-emerged talents and quality of style which would indeed be the Disney Hallmark. For example, it is most insightful to be able to calculate the rapid rise in the sophistication and complexity that became the typical animated cartoon short or cartoon feature in only about a dozen years. The difference is like the proverbial night and day.

ALICE'S EGG PLANT (Walt Disney Productions/Margaret J. Winkler Distributors, 1925) has a great deal of fun in it. There is a great deal of that interplay between Alice # 2 (Anne Shirley) and her vast herd of funny animals; but in this one, we have a few twists and turns that were out of the ordinary.

THE Egg Plant in the title is not the popular Mediterranean vegetable; but rather a plant as in a building or complex devoted to production of a particular item or consumable food stuffs. In short, young Miss Alice has a Chicken Farm, specializing in Egg production, rather than the Poultry end of the business.

WHEN Alice and her right hand 'man', her cat, Julius, receive a rush order for 5,000 eggs; they must decide on a plan for stepping up production as they find their work force of hens has been influenced by "Little Red Henski, from Moscow, Russia"; who now has them 'On Strike!' The day is saved when young Miss Alice hits upon the idea of staging a 'Cockfight' between two Roosters on the farm. This would be with gloves; conducted strictly under Marquis of Queensbury Rules. They would charge an admission of egg and were successful up to a point. The trouble began when………….(We'll never tell!)

WE find it indeed interesting that the central theme of this one reel cartoon of 1925 was that of Labor Relations and the corruption of any legitimate Labor Movement by agents of Comintern (Communist International Movement). We don't say this because there weren't such problems right here in the good old USA as well as the rest of the World; for there were most definitely were many such major upheavals during this period. It's just that it seems to be an odd subject with which to tickle our funny-bones.

IN its own little way, ALICE'S EGG PLANT remains a curious example of an irony that was born in the early Hollywood Animation scene. Possibly there had never been such a mixture of serious business of World Economics and Political unrest with the totally fluffy nonsense of a Theatrical Cartoon.

AND just think of how this simple, little nearly forgotten Cartoon relates to Today's World; what with some of our top Political Candidates having such decidedly Socialistic leanings and the emergence of a Guy like 'Joe the Plumber' as a sort of counterbalancing Folk Hero.

WE guess that some things never change, right Schultz?

POODLE SCHNITZ!!

Yes I had to go there. "Alice's Egg Plant" is an 8.5-minute cartoon from 1925 and as always with Walt Disney's series about this young girl, the only live action character in this animated world is Alice. As the title already says, she and her pal Julius operate an egg plant here (which means a chicken farm, not a biological plant) and I felt that this little movie here had more of a story and plot than they usually do. of course, it also goes for comedy, but there is a touch of union talk and maybe even a slight ounce pf politics in here. Unfortunately, it still stays a fairly absurd watch and neither the characters nor the animation are good enough to really say this is an enjoyable little film, even if it's among the most known from the Alice series. The title character here is played by Anne Shirley and this is her only performance as Alice. She went on to become an Oscar nominee later on. But here she cannot show us her talent yet. I don't recommend the watch.