The Invisible Menace (1938) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
22 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Eddie and his new bride are idiots....and their timing couldn't be much worse!
planktonrules30 April 2019
When the film begins, Private Eddie Pratt (Eddie Craven) and his new bride, Sally (Marie Wilson) are sneaking onto the military base. Why? These idiots just got married and were looking for a cozy hidden spot in which to consumate their marriage! Romantic, huh?? Well, they just happened upon a dead body...and they hide. Soon, the body is discovered and Eddie and Sally are certainly in hot water. But attention soon switches to Jevries (Boris Karloff)...a man with a very checkered past.

This film was made by the B-movie unit of Warner Brothers....meaning it's short (55 minutes) but has reasonably good production values. It helped that it had Boris Karloff and Regis Toomey (an old reliable B actor) in the picture. The plot itself is pretty much the standard detective film but instead of the usual smart amateur sleuth (often a reporter), here the folks investigating are Army officers....a decent switch from the norm but still a very standard sort of story.

Overall, quite enjoyable for what it is. I might have scored it a 7, but took away a point because the notion of ANYONE taking his new bride onto a military base to boink her....well, that's ridiculous!
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Entertaining quickie
utgard1417 December 2015
Fine B mystery from Warner Bros. with nice foggy atmosphere and a good performance from Boris Karloff in a small but important role. Directed by John 'father of Mia' Farrow, it's a good-looking picture that has a horror movie feel to it. The story involves a murder on an army base, with Karloff as one of the suspects. There's also some comic relief from Eddie Craven and Marie Wilson as a pair of newlyweds trying to have their honeymoon on the base without anyone knowing. The comedy upsets the fine mood Farrow sets but I'm sure his hands were tied on that front. The rest of the cast includes Regis Toomey, Charles Trowbridge, Frank Faylen, and Henry Kolker. Cy Kendall plays a brutish investigator brought in to solve the crime. His method is to slap suspects around until they confess. Sherlock Holmes he's not! It's worth a look for Karloff fans or anyone who enjoys old B mysteries. The short runtime helps a lot.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Neat Little Mystery Thriller Featuring The Great Boris Karloff
krorie16 November 2005
This is a very watchable programmer centering on a murder mystery that takes place at an island army arsenal. Director John Farrow (husband of Maureen O'Sullivan/father of Mia Farrow)wisely keeps this thriller short and breezy. The only part of the movie that sometimes falls flat today is the humor, which I'm sure was much better received by the audiences in 1938. Marie Wilson tries to be a Gracie Allen clone. This persona worked much better years later when she played My Friend Irma opposite Martin and Lewis. Eddie Craven does fine as Marie Wilson's comedy partner but again much of the humor is dated.

It's good to see the great Boris Karloff strut his stuff. His bad guy/monster image kept him from receiving deserved recognition as one of Hollywood's most capable actors. This image is used in an interesting way in "The Invisible Menace" but I won't go into detail and spoil the movie for you. The flashback scene when Karloff is on the island of Haiti fits well into the story but also provides variety in what could have become a boring film since all the action takes place in a confined setting. A talent such as Hitchcock could overcome such a setting as he did in his classic "Lifeboat," but Farrow was not that adept although a skilled director.

All in all a gem for fans of the genre.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Boris Karloff's worst Hollywood vehicle of the 1930s
kevinolzak3 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
1937's "The Invisible Menace" was adapted by Crane Wilbur from Ralph Spencer Zink's unsuccessful Broadway play "Without Warning," and once you've seen it you'll understand why it only ran for 17 performances: it stinks. Having completed "The Walking Dead" for Michael Curtiz and "West of Shanghai" for John Farrow on his 5 picture contract with Warner Brothers, Boris Karloff was tabbed to be the headline player in this middling whodunit set on an offshore military base, asinine comic relief supplied by Eddie Craven as newlywed private Eddie Pratt (repeating his stage role), and typecast dumb blonde Marie Wilson as his ditzy bride. It's a no no for women to be present on the base at any time, but Pratt figures to make allowances for the fact that they were wed in late afternoon, smuggling her inside a duffel bag for a rough and tumble honeymoon spot. In vainly seeking someplace to be alone, the couple stumble upon the strung up corpse of weapons supplier Reilly, beaten and tortured by bayonet, and severe blows on the head, a defeated Col. Hackett (Henry Kolker) calling in a favor from Col. Rogers (Cy Kendall) to take charge of the investigation. Unfortunately, his knowledge of prior contact with Karloff's Jevries, wrongfully convicted of embezzlement in a scheme concocted by Reilly, means that poor Boris ends up a punching bag for the browbeating authorities during the picture's second half, the first dominated by endless interrogations repeating the same facts over and over. A fortuitous stroke of casting finds Karloff reunited with Regis Toomey, six years after the Universal crime drama "Graft," in which Boris was the chief henchman responsible for murder and kidnapping, Toomey the dim witted would be hero reporter who recklessly brings him in; in this feature, Karloff gets to play sympathetic hero (kept off screen for a half hour) while Toomey plays it straight as the surprise killer, anxious to silence Reilly rather than include him in a lucrative gun running racket. Issued on a disastrous double bill with Humphrey Bogart's worst film "Swing Your Lady," it's hardly a surprise that aficionados of Boris Karloff might well regard this as his most disagreeable starring vehicle of the 30s, one that director John Farrow seems to have tossed off rather quickly by August 21, while "West of Shanghai" still awaited release (the nonsensical new title is an absolute cheat). The forthcoming "Devil's Island" and "British Intelligence," weak as they are, must be considered classics after this supremely ludicrous dud from the Brothers Warner.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Mercifully short mishmash
skywaymo22 October 2003
What in the world was Karloff doing in this B-picture quicky years after his triumph as The Frankenstein Monster??? Karloff tries his best but nothing could save this snoozer. The plot summary pretty much gives you the entire plot. Tries to be a sassy sexy comedy, a thriller and a who dunnit all at once. Fails miserable at all 3! The "comedy" is sophomoric. There are no real "thrills". The "mystery" wouldn't fool a 5 year old. Lots of good character actors wasted (Regis Toomey, the perpetual sergeant/policeman, "Dobie Gillis'" father Frank Faylen, and others). For Karloff completists only!
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Great little mystery
dbborroughs2 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Boris Karloff stars in a strange stage based mystery set on a military base that has to do with the death of a weapons researcher. The film is set in motion when a bunch of soldiers on leave pile into a boat and head back to the island base. One of the men is smuggling his new wife over in the hope of a nice quiet wedding night. In the process of finding a quiet place to consummate the marriage they stumble upon a dead body. The base is locked down and a sleuth is flown in.

Weird mix of wedding night comedy (which really doesn't work) and fast paced mystery this is a rather schizophrenic film that would have been so much better had the comedy been left behind. The mystery is a dark and troubling tale with a great deal of violence and suspicion. The mystery is played for all its worth and it makes me wonder what the play the film is based on is like.

The cast is mostly excellent, only Marie Pratt, as the only woman in the cast, is less than good. The real treat here is Boris Karloff as one of the suspects. He gets a real work out as an actor going through a great deal of emotion. It was always clear that he could do more than horror parts to anyone who really watched his performances, and this is a film that proves the point.

Very short, it runs around 55 minutes, this movie moves like the wind and it never gets boring or too comedic. Absolutely worth a look if you run across it.

The mystery is 8 out of 10 The comedy is 3 out of 10 (thankfully its very brief) 6 out of 10 over all
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Routine murder mystery with a misleading title
AlsExGal1 August 2020
Short murder mystery from Warner Brothers and director John Farrow. On a fog-enshrouded American military base, a man is found gruesomely murdered, having apparently been tortured before his death. Gruff military investigator Colonel Rogers (Cy Kendall) tries to find the culprit among the pool of suspects, including quiet Dr. Jevries (Boris Karloff), newlywed soldier Eddie (Eddie Craven) and his bubble-headed bride Sally (Marie Wilson) who has been smuggled onto the island, or any of the other soldiers on or off duty. The cast includes Regis Toomey, Henry Kolker, Frank Faylen, Eddie Acuff, Charles Trowbridge, Phyllis Barry, Harland Tucker, and Carole Landis.

Despite the title and the presence of Karloff, this isn't a supernatural or science fiction tale, just a routine murder mystery, although there is one incongruous scene of a Haitian voodoo ritual. Craven and Wilson stick out like a goofy sore thumb from the proceedings, but I still liked Wilson. Cy Kendall is unusually cast as the law enforcer, as he's typically cast as a gangster or corrupt politician. Just a few years earlier, Toomey was playing the kind of roles played by Craven in this one.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Boris karloff ... in a howwah flick
ksf-24 May 2019
Boris Karloff in another horror flick! co-stars the usual suspects... Regis Toomey, Marie Wilson. Eddie Acuff. its a shortie, at only 55 minutes. U.S. sevicemen on "some island" (?), and one of them has snuck in his new wife. and... someone gets bumped off. as usual, Karloff plays the mysterious, foreboding doctor, so of course, he's the suspect. Did he do it?? someone is trying to bump off more people. then we're in a flashback. a lot going on in this short film from Warner Brothers. it's okay. Director John Farrow had some interesting highlights -- directed Around the World in 80 Days, and won the oscar for Best Screenplay. Father of Mia Farrow! died quite young at 58. Married to Margaret O'Sullivan. was a mover and a shaker.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Bottom of the barrel, let alone the bill.
mark.waltz15 January 2018
Warning: Spoilers
When a daffy newlywed married couple (Eddie Craven and Marie Wilson) find a corpse in a military base warehouse, fingers point automatically to the brooding Boris Karloff who must think quickly to defend himself. This lame programmer, either filmdom's longest short, or shortest feature, seems rushed into production, not giving time to really develop the characters and a plot that is extremely cliched. Combining a supposed sci fi element, this film totally disappoints, and the comedy is ridiculously unfunny. Wilson overdoes the dumb blonde act, and Craven has no screen presence. Karloff does all he can to rise above the mediocrity, and the direction by John Farrow (his second with Karloff in just a year) has no real flow. The painless short running time makes this easier to get through, but I classify this as one of the worst Warner Brothers second feature, one that should have ended up in the public domain with a few others whose copyright they chose not to renew, which like this, are among their worst films.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Gosh! Ain't nothing sacred to you guys?"
Hey_Sweden2 May 2023
That always endearing titan of terror, Boris Karloff, stars in this very minor but still enjoyable murder mystery. A film adaptation of a Broadway play titled "Without Warning", it takes place at an island Army base, where a local character named Reilly (Harland Tucker, "Kid Galahad") is found dead after having been tortured and killed. Karloff plays a character named Jevries, who is supervising construction on the island; he makes a convenient and obvious suspect since it is revealed that there was bad blood between him and Reilly.

Although nothing special, "The Invisible Menace" is still pretty agreeable - and it only runs 55 minutes, so even viewers who aren't won over don't have to stick it out for long. While there is some solid atmosphere here and there, one can tell that this was based on a play, with such a heavy accent on dialogue. Co-stars Eddie Craven ("The Gilded Lily"), who'd originated his role on stage, and Marie Wilson ("My Friend Irma") add copious comedy relief as a dopey private and his ditzy new bride; he's smuggled her onto the island in the hopes of getting some alone time with her.

An excellent supporting cast helps to keep this watchable: Regis Toomey ("The Big Sleep"), Henry Kolker ("Holiday"), Cy Kendall ("Blonde for a Day"), Charles Trowbridge ("They Were Expendable"), Eddie Acuff ("The Petrified Forest"), and Frank Faylen ("The Lost Weekend"). Karloff fans should be aware that, despite his top billing, he's not in the film that much - but, as always, he's masterful at eliciting audience sympathy.

"The Invisible Menace" may be far from top-tier Karloff, but it entertains adequately for just under an hour.

Six out of 10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mismatch Movie Never Meshes Mystery, Comedy, and Terror
LeonLouisRicci25 November 2015
A cobbled together Mismatch of Comedy, Mystery, and a Touch of Terror. An early John Farrow Film whose Career had some Highlights in Film-Noir and other Genres. Boris Karloff is given a Non-Monster Role and He makes the Best of it.

But, for some Odd Reason the Best Parts of the Movie are Glossed Over in quick Flashbacks and give way to Irritating, Dated, Date Comedy and some Unappealing Characters. A few Scenes have an Edge of Violence and a Stylish Darkness, but the Movie cannot Recover from the Weak Elements.

A Movie dismissed by many and is really only Recommended for Completists and the Curious. There are some Things to See here but they Come at a Heavy Price. Enduring the Embarrassment of the Silly Stuff and a Combination of Elements that Never Mesh is Burdensome.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A double dose of Karloff and Lugosi
marquisdeposa6 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
(THIS REVIEW IS FOR THE DVD Invisible Menace/Night of Terror)

This DVD presents Karloff and Lugosi, each in a film that is not part of their usual fare seen in other collections.

THE INVISIBLE MENACE is a Warner Brother's quickie (clocking in at under 60 minutes) that shows that Boris Karloff could do far more than play monsters. Most reviews of this film right it off as a poor example of his talents. I disagree. In it's 54 minute running time it manages to combine murder, red herrings, and an extremely quick paced mystery. The comedic antics of Marie Wilson and Eddie Craven may be a bit trying at times for those looking for pure mystery, but they are far less intrusive than many other mystery films where comedy is injected at random. At least their situation is part of the plot. As to Boris's role being beneath him, I tend to look at as an extension of his abilities to create a character. His gray hair, glasses and quiet manner (except when he is gesturing wildly pleading for justice) are a precursor to his role as Professor Linden in The Linden Tree, which he would play on the New York stage in the late 1940's. Overall it is an enjoyable little film.

The second feature, with the generic title NIGHT OF TERROR, comes as a welcome surprise. I had only seen it listed on Bela Lugosi film bibliographies. It is a variation on the old dark house thriller, with moving panels, tunnels, a gathering of heirs for the reading of the will, etc. This film has the advantage of Lugosi's performance. Reading other reviews of the film led me to believe that he was "wasted" in the part of Degar. Once again I tend to disagree. Bela is in almost every scene of the picture. His mysterious delivery of his dialogue is perfectly in line with the film's eerie atmosphere. As for him being "wasted" he turns out to be the most intelligent person of the lot-including the police and a wise cracking newspaper reporter. Being a B picture, and over the years being subject to scrutiny, the plot discrepancies are pretty evident, but overall it is an entertaining film. As to the peculiar ending, it is no more quirky that Edward Van Sloan's prologue to FRANKENSTEIN or his epilogue to Dracula (cut from most prints of the film)
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fun if you just go with it!
stan_c21 December 2021
If you like Boris Karloff and old movies this one is fun to watch. There are some funny lines. Regis Toomey is in it as well. I remember him from Burke's Law. Give it a try.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
See only for Karloff and the production design
TheLittleSongbird11 May 2013
The Invisible Menace has two things going for it. The dark and foggy production design is striking and very effective. And Boris Karloff gives a great sympathetic performance. Unfortunately, they are the only things about The Invisible Menace(anybody want to explain the significance of this title, because it was irrelevant as far I'm concerned. Of the cast, only Karloff is close to good. Talented character actors like Regis Toomey are wasted, while Marie Wilson is incredibly irritating-of any performance in any of the movies that Karloff starred in, you'd be hard pressed to find one as annoying as Wilson's- and Eddie Craven's mugging is just embarrassing. The fact that the comedy is dated and unfunny doesn't help, and it also seemed misplaced. The same goes with the whole thing about the voodoo, seen in a short flashback, which seemed to have been thrown in at last minute without any relevance to what was already there. The Invisible Menace does try to be a number of elements, I've mentioned already that the comedy didn't work, but we also see the film trying to be a mystery, a melodrama and a thriller. Including comedy too, all four of those elements fail. The mystery element is too obvious and coincidental, the melodrama is overwrought and brings the film to a screeching halt at times and there's nothing thrilling here, merely tedium. The script could have been much tighter, and could have given the actors much more to work from, that is including Karloff. At 55 minutes, you'd think The Invisible Menace would be too short and that it would feel rushed. Actually, the story has trouble sustaining the length, you know there's a problem when the IMDb summary alone sums up the entire plot of the film. To conclude, the production design and Karloff are good, but the rest is a disaster. 2/10 Bethany Cox
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Minor but enjoyable for Karloff fans
Sleepy-1725 October 2003
Murder mystery with a silly title. Better-than-average direction from John Farrow. Marie Wilson is quite funny as a horny newlywed, although the jokes are sticky and worth a few groans. But Karloff as usual is multi-dimensional, spooky and human, a warmer version of the guilty icon that Lon Chaney Sr. perfected.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Only One Sort of Bright Spot
Hitchcoc29 December 2021
Boris Karloff made several of these B movies. This one is about as stupid as it can be. We have a military base where some idiot carries his new wife onto the compound. As they arrive, a man is impaled with a bayonet. The officers run around trying to figure out what happened. Karloff has a history and is under suspicion from something that happened in Haiti. Ludicrous is an understatement.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
standing and talking
SnoopyStyle25 July 2023
Army Private Eddie Pratt (Eddie Craven) smuggles his new bride Sally (Marie Wilson) onto the base. While sneaking around, they encounter a murder victim and get chased by patroling soldiers. Colonel Rogers of Army Intelligence takes over the case. The prime suspect is Jevries (Boris Karloff).

It's a mystery film based on a play. The plot is nothing special. I had hoped to get more Boris Karloff. He's the only truly interesting aspect of the film. He's got the creepy look which makes him the automatic suspect. Mostly, it's a lot of standing and talking with a group of people. It gets rather boring. The title is a little odd. It sounds more like a horror movie.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
KARLOFF PLAYS A DIFFERENT ROLE !
whpratt119 December 2003
This film starts out with Pvt. Eddie Pratt (Eddie Craven),"Down Missouri Way",'46 manages to bring his new bride, Sally(Marie Wilson),"My Friend Irma" TV Series,'52 on to Powder Island Arsenal, a government reservation. He tries to hide her in a vacant building, the military discover a murdered body of an officer. After intense investigations and mysterious attempts are made on the lives of the Army officers in charge, every member on the post falls under suspicion. Colonel Rogers (Cy Kendall),"Call Northside 777",'48 assists in the investigation and recognizes one of the civilians, Jevries(Boris Karloff),"Bedlam"'46, to be an embezzler who was arrested years ago. It is also revealed that the murdered man was his enemy. Found out this picture was based on a 1937 Broadway play,"Without Warning" and actor Eddie Craven repeated his original stage role in this picture. Warner Bros. remade this film five years later as "Murder on the Waterfront". I was amazed to see that Boris Karloff played an entirely different role as a Number One Bogie Man,(Frankenstein) and noticed that his role was a sympathetic one, meek, mild. I believe the audiences felt sorry for him in this picture. As always, Boris gave a great performance. This is a great Classic Film to view.
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Decent
Michael_Elliott12 March 2008
Invisible Menace, The (1938)

** (out of 4)

Slightly entertaining whodoneit about a body being found at a military institution and the investigation that follows. I've seen countless films like this over the years and this one here really isn't any better or worse than the majority out there. The main reason to see this film is due to Boris Karloff but be warned that he's not in the film too much even with the top billing. The supporting cast are decent but the good thing is that the film runs a short 54-minutes. Had the screenplay been a tad bit better the film might have worked better.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
CAMPY B MOVIE FROM WARNER BROS
tcchelsey22 July 2023
Boris Karloff was finishing off his contract with Warner Brothers and starred in this real quickie, under 60 minutes, whodunit to who?

Mia Farrow's father, John Farrow, a distinguished director in his own right (WAKE ISLAND, THE BIG CLOCK) handled this one, and its not bad. Set on a fog shrouded military base island, the eerie fog horn blasting away in the distance. A man is murdered and the military police suspect none other than quiet, unassuming Karloff, who has some skeletons in his own closet. Lots of red herrings to go, and a solid cast of familiar faces.

This was an early role for comedian Marie Wilson, again playing the not too bright blonde who gets caught on base with her soldier husband to be.

What will they think of next? The big guns are really tough on Karloff, and is the real culprit going to get away? Interestingly, it takes a while to figure out this whodunit, in between cross exmainations of Karloff, and the acting is very good.

A side bar to the procedings concerns the real story behind the story. The script was actually toned down quite a bit, based on a graphic novel, which had the victim tied up and killed. Actually, the male victim (in the book) was sexually assaulted by another male and then murdered. Pretty potent stuff for 1938, and answering the question as to why mild mannered Karloff was singled out in the first place, and so quickly, implying he may have been leading a double life. Also it's kind of strange the way the victim is presented, tied to a pole, his clothing seemingly ripped, and leaning sideways? Why didn't the killer just shoot him and get it over with? It just looked strange. Now it all falls into place.

There's also some hilarious questioning as to where everyone was the night of the murder... the common answer being in bed alone? Again, references to the book? Whatever the case, it's entertaining, however, Boris Karloff is the whole show, propping this one up a bit from the usual B mystery factory line.

Karloff's other movie for Warners was WEST OF SHANGHAI (1937), which was the second feature Farrow directed, requiring more makeup for Karloff as a Chinese warlord who smoked a ton of cigarettes! This can be found in a 3 movie box set from WB, also with DEVILS ISLAND (1940), starring Karloff.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hadn't Miss Marple remained an old maid......
dbdumonteil17 May 2009
Imagine Agatha Christie's Miss Marple in her prime.She would have married a private,unbeknown to her new husband's superiors.As they did not have time enough for a well-deserved honeymoon,they decide to do it military style,that is to say inside the camp.Of course they have to hide away from the staff.To make the matters worse,very mysterious (and even criminal ) things happen and 'official-secrets" might not be secret anymore.In spite of Boris Karloff's presence,it is not really a horror movie,but rather a whodunit:it is not difficult to guess who the murderer is and anyway we have a lady detective.She came "without warning" and she will be very insightful.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Exciting Honeymoon...
azathothpwiggins27 July 2023
In THE INVISIBLE MENACE, a soldier smuggles his new bride onto an island base, only to become caught up in a murder mystery. This is a thriller, broken up by big dollops of silly humor.

Of course, the main draw to this film is Boris Karloff as Jevries. This movie was made after Mr. Karloff's astonishing run in Universal Studios' horror classics of the early 1930s, and before his triumphant return in the 1940s, especially in the productions he did with Producer Val Lewton. In MENACE, Mr. Karloff shines darkly in his potential-killer role. You might say that he's "over qualified" for this movie, although it does give him a chance for some more poignant scenes toward the end.

Regis Toomey is also good in his role.

Recommended for fans of Boris Karloff...
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed