The Conspirators (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
40 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Another wartime film from Warner Brothers
blanche-212 January 2008
You know that Warner Brothers - once they have their hands on a hot property, they slice it, dice it, and put it in the Mixmaster. Just look at the three versions of "The Maltese Falcon." Now it's wartime, and that hot property is, of course "Casablanca." In "The Conspirators," part of that magnificent cast is reunited - Paul Henried, Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre - in this story of a Dutch freedom fighter, Vincent Van der Lyn, in neutral Lisbon and having trouble figuring out who wants to help him and who wants to hurt him. The suspects are Greenstreet, the head of a resistance group, Lorre, one of its members, and the exquisite Hedy Lamarr, married to a Nazi official.

The story is harder to follow and ultimately, the film is not as good as "Joan of Paris," another World War II film starring Henried, but it still has great atmosphere and is fairly intriguing. There just isn't enough of Greenstreet or Lorre, one of the great screen teams. Paul Henried, a very useful actor during World War II while the stars were away, does a good job as Van der Lyn. Lamarr is positively outrageously beautiful - no, she's not much of an actress - it's a face made for the closeup, and one can just look at her forever. What she brings is a certain enigmatic quality, probably by default, but who cares.

If this pops up on TCM, you won't be sorry you saw it, but you won't be swept away either.
25 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
wartime spy film.... great cast
ksf-215 January 2019
Others have commented on the (same) awesome cast, many from Casablanca, so I won't spend much time on that. Begins in the netherlands, where Van der Lyn (Henreid) must get from netherlands to portugal quickly to escape. When he arrives, the germans (and others) take notice of him. He meets up with Irene (Hedy Lamarr), who seems friendly enough, but in wartime, one is never sure who they can trust. Van der Lyn hooks up with a rebel group of the underground, and gets caught up in one of their adventures (recover the eagle!) on the way to his own mission. He spends the rest of the film trying to figure out who to trust... and i guess that's the reality for a spy during wartime. It's entertaining enough. Henreid made this right after Casablanca. Directed by Jean Negulesco.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good Looking Entertainment
krocheav7 October 2015
OK, if you want Casablanca then watch Casablanca!. I could never completely understand the fuss people make over that film. Yes, I know it has many very good qualities, but some shaky ones as well (alright, perhaps it's time I looked at it again). As for this particular movies attempt to capitalise on the success of the earlier film (Hollywood has always followed the proved formula method - and even more so now) so it might also be said, if this film had come along before Casablanca, it may just have received all the accolades. I'm assuming 'Conspirators' would have been given the bigger budget (it has a more expensive look about it) and as it seems Casablanca was not anticipated to be the hit it turned out, so Warner's would then have hoped to follow up with another winner.

Arthur Edeson's standout Cinematography is mesmerizing. The knockout classic lighting coupled with the great Direction of Jean Negulesco (others have called him insensitive and pedestrian - how unobservant they show themselves to be! best look again is all I can say to them) The strong Max Seiner music score is quite unique to many of his other works ~ with the masterful Orchestrations of veteran arranger Leonid Raab giving the score a potent sound that's perfect for this story. If anything, the post production alterations would have contributed to the movies hard to follow moments and contrivances, but this was typical with many films from this otherwise spot on studio. That said, let's face it, Hedy and Paul do make the most of their exhausted and very scared characters...theirs were strained times to be living through.

Look at it on it's own entertainment merits, the script may have some unevenness and some characters a little familiar, but overall this is not nearly as bad as some might have us believe. Some will, some won't.......KenR
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
World War II Espionage Melodrama
Jim Tritten23 March 2002
Hedy Lamarr is never more beautiful and it is always a pleasure to see Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre together. The story line is fairly good for the era but the on-screen results disappoint. The movie is justifiably compared with the much much better Casablanca. Paul Henreid is escaping from the Nazis in neutral Lisbon. Hedy, Sydney, and Peter all offer help but there are complications. Conspirators abound -- who is to be trusted? All is revealed an a too predictable ending. See this film as an example of movie making during the war or to round out your viewing of its cast. On the other hand, my wife loved it! Go figure.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
******* Not Bogey
GManfred4 September 2018
Paul Henreid was stalwart and in earnest, but, let's face it. He's not Humphrey Bogart, despite his efforts to be a tough leading man and willingness to face danger unafraid. The rest of the cast is excellent, with several familiar faces in Sidney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre, and Hedy Lamarr is gorgeous. In fact, the story is a good one, as has been reiterated by other contributors. There is some tension and suspense at the end of the film, as they try to uncover the traitor in their midst. But Bogey's not there, with his signature snarling inflections and scowling face. Still, it's entertaining on it's own terms and holds the interest throughout.

7/10 - Website no longer prints my star rating.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Spy Stuff
boblipton16 October 2022
Paul Henreid is man of action, a Dutchman who sabotages military trains in the mountains of his native land. Of course, the Nazis drive him out of the country, to Portugal where he plans to have a good meal and fly to England, until native French woman Hedy Lamar has one of her agents killed. So she sits down at Henreid's table and drags him into the shadowy world of double agents in Lisbon.

Hollywood's shaky concept of European geography and nationality aside, it's a nice, dark little thriller, with a lot of references to CASABLANCA, including the cast (Sidney Greenstreet, Peter Lorre) and plot details. It's uncertain as to the loyalties of the characters; in fact, that's a major plot point at the end. It's definitely a programmer rather than a major vehicle, but there are plenty of details that keep up interest.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Superficial, disjointed WWII intrigue film with good supporting cast
Galygay7 January 2006
A Casablanca clone that never quite gels. Paul Henreid, as Van der Lyn is no Rick Blaine (or even Victor Laszlo for that matter), but is good enough given the support he receives from proved character actors Greenstreet, Lorre, Francen, et al. Henreid hasn't the cynical streak that Bogie's Blaine had. He's too soft, and as a result his portrayal as Dutch freedom fighter "the Flying Dutchman" doesn't quite stick.

Lamarr (as Irene Von Mohr) is presented more as a polished trophy than any integral member of an underground resistance, showing off a different exotic costume and head-cover in every scene. She IS nice to look at, but after the film is over, can anyone remember what she said or did that was so special?

Peter Lorre is in his usual role, exuding a bit of quirky character depth and endearing himself to the viewer in his limited screen time. He gets in the best lines of the movie-- the "cuckoo clock" story.

Greenstreet, though definitely a presence, doesn't do much. He laughs like the "Fat Man" a few times and throws out that famous glare of his a couple more, but the viewer never gets any more than that. Anyway, how can a guy named "Ricardo Quintanilla" come across with a royal English accent???

The climax of the movie is fairly predictable. It reminds me more of the outcome of an average game of Clue. Most of the main characters of the movie are there, yet no one really does anything. This goes on for about ten minutes.

In my opinion, I find Carol Thurston's "Rosa" character much more interesting (and attractive) than Hedy's. At least she's accessible to the average non-freedom fighter. Unfortunately, these are the only two females in the whole film.

David Hoffman plays Vincent Van der Lyn's broken cell-mate in the Lisbon prison. Watch his scenes closely. It is these types of brief character portrayals that give the film some of its most memorable moments.

Overall the atmosphere of this film is quite good, especially in the scenes of the rural fishing village. Still, the viewer never really understands the reasons everything is so darn important. Characters walk around in this great atmosphere and the viewer must assume that they are coming from doing important things, or going off to do important things-- things that could either make or break the resistance movement against the Nazis. Unfortunately, it doesn't quite add up.

My advice is to either hang out at the fishing village, or leave Portugal, set sail a bit south and visit "Casablanca" instead.
13 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I spy
jotix10010 October 2004
Jean Negulesco's "The Conspirators" sounded intriguing when the trailer was shown at TCM. It appeared as though it was well worth a look because of the cast alone. Well, it was a big disappointment!

The story is convoluted, it is hardly plausible what the hero, Vincent, is able to pull, let alone, be allowed to enter Lisbon, at the crucial time when he arrives. The character of Irene remains an enigma throughout the film and finally, there is not enough to make this movie enjoyable.

Paul Henried was a lucky man being in Hollywood while a lot of the American stars were away fighting in WWII. In this film he tries, but there's something about his Vincent that doesn't quite make it. Hedy Lamarr's presence in the movie is pretext to present her in different costumes. Henreid and Lamarr had not enough chemistry to make the film, at least, a nice love story.

Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre are completely wasted and the rest of the players were not interesting enough to keep the viewer's attention at all times. Instead, one feels bored by the proceedings. At least Vincent and Irene, by the magic of the movies, will always have Lisbon!
15 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Casablanca Sequel
gullom-114 January 2007
In order to counter the unbelievably negative previous review I shall first disagree with ALL of the "I spy" review.

Jean Negulesco (Humoresque) directs an all-star cast in "The Conspirators", a truly remarkable film, and a MUST SEE!! This film resembles "Casablanca" in that it has much of its feel--the cast, setting (WWII Portugal), romantic music, this film has it all! Strangely enough, this film bears some similarity to Hedy Lamarr's life in Germany before her escape. She worked extensively against the Nazi's. The fact that she was to be cast in Casablanca instead of Ingrid Bergman goes to show that the chemistry between Paul Henreid was definitely strong. Unfortunately, Lamarr was not able to take the role so it was given to Bergman.

Lamarr's enigma-like qualities is trademark of her style and adds to the film's appeal.

Henreid is in his own element here and the man he was hinted at being in Casablanca comes to life.

Sentimentality evidently fails to appeal to everyone. However, I will conclude with stating how much the messages this film carries appeal to me--the love story filled with strife, as well as fighting against all odds whatever the cost.
52 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Conspire for Nought **1/2
edwagreen2 May 2012
Warning: Spoilers
C+ Warner Brothers Effort with Hedy Lamarr cast as the femme fatale, a mysterious woman with an aura about herself. She meets up with Paul Henried,in neutral Lisbon, during World War 11. Henried has fled from Holland where he has committed acts of sabotage.

The film lacked considerable excitement. You know something is funny when Lamarr was freed from Dachau and married her liberator, the usually evil Victor Francen.

The amazing thing about this film is that both Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre are good guys. That's why they both, with Lorre in particular, are given little to do here.

Naturally, there is leak within the partisan group and Henried, framed for a murder that the Nazis committed, comes up with a plan to uncover the traitor.

The ending is pure Warner Brothers, so similar to that of "Casablanca," of 2 years before. In fact, the film is rather a weak imitation of the Oscar winner. Lamarr was no Ingrid Bergman.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Hedy Lamarr is a beautiful but boring enigma as a woman of mystery...
Doylenf11 January 2008
All the ingredients that made CASABLANCA such a mega-hit are present in THE CONSPIRATORS, but not one of the ingredients is able to put the film over the top as a story of intrigue, espionage and romance.

What's surprising is that the film fails to sustain interest despite a great supporting cast that includes PETER LORRE, SYDNEY GREENSTREET and VICTOR FRANCEN. Also surprising is the fact that it's directed by Jean Negulesco, who did such a brilliant job on the direction of JOHNNY BELINDA. The script is a talky, muddled bit of contrivances and clichés, with Henried as a Dutch freedom fighter in Lisbon clashing with the Nazis and falling under the spell of a beautiful woman who guards her secrets.

HEDY LAMARR is lovely, of course, but her characterization is so paper-thin that all we can really see is her exotic glamor, without much passion or feeling below the make-up. Nor is PAUL HENRIED seen at his best, more remote than usual in what should have been a much stronger role but is dulled by a witless script and a co-star with whom he has very little chemistry.

The convoluted plot doesn't give the supporting actors much to do and it's somewhat of a relief when the story comes to downbeat ending.
22 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Realistic portrayal of anxious life during WWII Europe
jpadamsca11 February 2017
The greatness of this film lies in its ability to make you feel absorbed in the story, characters' lives, and outcomes. Negulesco's masterful direction and the excellent cast's strong delivery leaves you wanting to follow every move and hear every word.

There is also a nice variety of scenes throughout that engage you in the complexities of the characters' thoughts and lives. It adds to the sense of anxiety they felt during the war, even in neutral Portugal. Through Henreid's early anti-German sabotage in the Netherlands, music at Café Império in Lisbon, barroom conversations and back alley meet-ups, everything feels and moves perfectly, adding depth to the story. No scene, word, or movement is ever out of place.

The entire movie was interesting and enjoyable and I watched it several times in 1 week. Isn't one hallmark of a high quality movie the need to watch it several times to pick up all the nuances? Even so, I never felt like it was on repeat.

One final note - the picture is a little dark, so I increased the screen brightness and turned off the lights in the room and that helped. Also, wish it were available in HD, but otherwise highly recommend!
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Tell Quintanilla... They took the Eagle.
sol121829 December 2009
Warning: Spoilers
***SPOILERS*** Somewhat boring and overdone Casablanca-like war drama with the stunningly beautiful, considered to be the most beautiful woman in all the world at the time, Hedy Lamarr as anti-Nazi freedom fighter and former Dachau concentration camp survivor Irene Von Mohr. Don't let Irene's last name fool you she's actually French who's married to German Diplomat Hugo Von Mohr, Victor Franken, who got her out of Dachau at the risk of his own neck.

Getting involved, almost by accident, with fellow anti-Nazi freedom fighter Vincent Van Der Lyn, Paul Henreid, who's known in anti-Nazi freedom fighting circles as the a**-kicking "Flying Dutchman" Irene, in at first not knowing who he is, thinks that he's some kind of Nazi spy working for chief Nazi honcho in natural Lisbon Portugal Dr. Schmitt, Steven Geray. Vincent is on the run from his home in Nazi occupied Holland after almost single-handedly, as we see in the start of the film, wiping out the entire German Army garrison stationed there! Slipping into Portugal Vincent wants to go legit in fighting the Nazis as a member of the free Dutch Air Force instead of being a guerrilla fighter, who's not protected by the Geneva Convention, by getting to England where the Free Dutch Air Force originates from.

The film "The Conspirator's" moves at a snails pace with Vincent getting in and out trouble, and jail, until the last ten minutes or so when the action really starts to pick up. It's then at a swanky Lisbon Casino that it's revealed who's the fink, or traitor, who set poor Vincent up in the murder of fellow anti-Nazi freedom fighter Jennings, Monte Blue, that he was arrested and put behind bars for. Even though the identity of the traitor was not that hard to figure out it was about the most exciting scene in the somewhat very uninteresting, with the exception of Miss. Lamarr, film.

P.S Besides Paul Henreid there's also Casablanca cast members Sidney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre as anti-Nazi freedom fighters Ricardo Quintanilla and Jan Bernazsky to round out the the films Casablanca-like cast. There's also Eduardo Ciannelli as Portuguese Army Colonel Almeida who's out to get Vincent, for violating Portuguese immigration laws, before he slips out of the country on his way to the UK. It was Ciannelli who was to play some 15 years later the lovable Greenwich Village jazz bar and nightclub owner Waldo in the TV series "Johnny Staccato".
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
We shall always have Lisbon
TheLittleSongbird9 March 2020
Really wanted to like 'The Conspirators' much more. It could have been great. It had a talented cast, hard to go wrong with the likes of Peter Lorre and Sydney Greenstreet. An intriguing idea for a story with shades of an all-time favourite 'Casablanca'. A fine director in Jean Negulesco, with good to great films such as 'The Mudlark', 'Humoresque', 'The Mask of Dimitrios' and 'How to Marry a Millionaire' as examples. A great setting, with Lisbon being a beautiful place.

Yet somehow 'The Conspirators' managed to be an underwhelming disappointment. Great potential but the execution was very patchy. None of the cast are at their best, with the greater actors being underused and the leads not being strong enough, and this is for me lesser Negulesco. Not just as a film, with it being one of not many films of his to not rise above the average. But also from a directing standpoint, where one would think that the film was directed by somebody else entirely.

Will start with what is good here as the good things are there. 'The Conspirators' is gorgeously shot with plenty of style and atmosphere, the noir-ish lighting also creating a genuine eeriness. Max Steiner's score is luscious and creates a surprising amount of swelling emotional power not present elsewhere.

Greenstreet and Lorre are underused but they really do make the most of what they have and get a lot out of it. Greenstreet, always good at playing authority figures, especially. Lorre was similarly always great at playing a creep. The ending is exciting and suspenseful, the only scene of the film to be so.

Paul Henreid also does his best, but in order to be convincing as a tough guy he needed a lot more intensity than what he gave. As exquisitely beautiful as Hedy Lamarr is, she is stuck in a role that is worse than one-dimensional and does nothing with it, meaning she doesn't register. She and Henreid fail to generate any chemistry or warmth. Negulesco's direction is disappointingly lethargic, something that is not characteristic of his direction usually.

The script and story also bring 'The Conspirators' down. Hard. The story is formulaic, with its fair share of overused cliches, and when things get increasingly complicated it gets very convoluted, some of it is dull too. The script is too talky and gets very heavy-handed and at times obvious. Even with the convolutions, there is not near enough susprises or tension. Only at the end do any of those things happen.

Summing up, not awful by any stretch but not great either. All have done much better. 5/10
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Just one of those typical '40's WW II movies.
Boba_Fett113819 January 2008
Often problem with these war time made WW II movies was that they were all basically the same. They of course all had a different story but were still all the same in terms of storytelling, overall style and character portrayals. In that regard "The Conspirators" is one of those dozens of typical made war time made movies about WW II.

The movie features a quite messy disjointed story, involving Nazi's, underground fighter's, a romance and one traitor. It also is nothing too spectacular or original.

The movie once more features both Peter Lorre and Sydney Greenstreet. They played in quite a few movies together in the '40's, of which of course the most notable ones were "Casablanca" (also starring Paul Henreid) and "The Maltese Falcon". My only complaint is that their roles are being pushed too much to the background. It focuses too much on Hedy Lamarr and Paul Henreid and their romance, which just isn't the most convincing or interesting element of the movie. Especially Lamarr is dreadful and feels terribly out of place within this movie.

I must admit that the ending is absolutely fantastic though, which involves a game of roulette, with the resistance fighters sitting across a couple of Nazi's, while it is known that one of the resistance fighters is a mole and traitor and must pass a message to the Nazi's within 10 minutes, while they are playing the roulette. It probably sounds very James Bond like to you know but trust me if I say that this is one great and tense build up sequences, that forms a perfect finale for the movie, even though the movie does not end right after it.

The movie as a whole just isn't always the most fast going one and therefore it also doesn't make this movie the most exciting or tense movie within its genre.

Still of course the movie remains a perfectly watchable enough one.

6/10

http://bobafett1138.blogspot.com/
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hedy outshines the plot
bruno-3229 May 2001
Too bad Hedy wasn't available for "Casablanca", L B Mayer refused to loan her to Warner Bros, so they had to settle for the matronly looking Ingrid Bergman. "Conspirators" was not suppose to be another Casablanca, not with Paul Henreid as its male hero. This guy was only good as the 'other' person, not a leading man. Hedy's gorgeous beauty shown in every scene, distracted one from the story. I could still see that 'jewel' shining in the night, at the port, as her 'lover' departed. This being the war years early 40's, the top leading men were serving their country, so they had to settle for the likes of a Paul Henreid as a leading man...ugh.
7 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The best way to woo a hot married wench is to prove that her husband . . .
tadpole-596-91825611 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
. . . is a nefarious triple agent for The Fuhrer, CONSPIRATORS reveals. This pretty much gives you a License to Kill. Most likely the chagrined wife will provide you with a gun plus plenty of ammo, and offer her premises as your Happy Hunting Grounds. Her Open Season will last as long as it takes to make her (briefly) a widow, and when you bag her perfidious Prussian hubby she'll be sure to promptly receive you with open arms and a huge "Thank you!" hug and kiss. In Today's Troubled Times, a Closet Liberal's alluring skirt should serve you just as well.
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Old Classic
whpratt110 January 2008
The cast in this film is filled with great movie greats with excellent talents, but this film is too long and boring and I am glad this type of film is not produced any longer and in the past. Hedy Lamarr, (Irene Von Mohr) was beautiful but always had a depressed look on her face and appeared like a person who had no emotions. Paul Henreid, (Vincent Van Der Lyn) looked like Humphrey Bogart in this picture and for some reason did not fit very well in his role. Sydney Greenstreet, (Ricardo Quintanilla) gave a great supporting performance along with his partner in many pictures, Peter Lorre, (Jan Bermazsky). Victor Francen, (Hugo Van Mohr), "Beast with Five Fingers" played a very mysterious role behind the scenes.
2 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
They'll Always Have Lisbon
bkoganbing30 April 2012
No matter how hard they tried Warner Brothers just could not duplicate the magic that was Casablanca. They tried it was in Background To Danger where George Raft who was considered for Humphrey Bogart's role got the lead. It was a routine action/adventure film set in Turkey.

In The Conspirators this time it was Hedy Lamarr who was originally considered for Ingrid Bergman's part finally made it to Warner Brothers. She is the wife of Victor Francen who is a German embassy official and both are part of an underground group which Sidney Greenstreet heads and Peter Lorre is also a member.

Into all their lives comes Dutch resistance fighter Paul Henreid and the two have big eyes for each other, but there is a traitor in that little underground group who is spoiling things all around political, geographic and personal. A murder is committed and Henreid is the suspect and both the underground and the Portugese police in the persons of Eduardo Ciannelli and Joseph Calleia are on his trail.

The atmosphere of intrigue in World War II Lisbon just as in World War II Casablanca is nicely created by director Jean Negulesco. But the magical chemistry of Bogey and Bergman just isn't there. Like Background To Danger, The Conspirators is just another action/adventure film with an exotic background.
2 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Better than expected
edpickett20039 November 2005
A fine cast throughout. Lorre, Greenstreet, Lamarr, Heinreid. I had even heard of this film before I saw it on Turner Classic Movies. It is certainly not in the class of Casablanca, but it is an excellent WWII thriller. Yes, Lamarr shines in every scene she is in. In fact, she is the main reason to watch this film. She is never more beautiful than in this film, and she certainly is one of the film beauties of all time. But Heinreid is perfect for the lead. It is a bit melodramatic, but we should remember the times when this film was made. The plot is complicated, and this is not a film to "sample" -- the writing is fine, but with few memorable quotes. The black and white photography is excellent. All in all, an excellent film of its type. I recommend it.
30 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"Long live liberty"
boscofl21 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Another chapter in Warner Brothers' World War II propaganda film series, The Conspirators (1944) is a jambalaya of international intrigue, foreboding atmosphere, lackluster writing, and stellar casting. It is frequently derided as a Casablanca knockoff but it more closely emulates director Jean Negulesco's previous work The Mask of Demitrios both in its foggy milieu and abundance of returning cast members. This particular venture emerges more as a triumph of style over substance and is a personal favorite of mine.

Vincent Van Der Lyn (Paul Henreid), aka the Flying Dutchman, is a notorious Dutch resistance fighter passing through neutral Lisbon before making the jump to England. He is taken to underground leader Ricardo Quintanilla (Sydney Greenstreet) by Jan Bernazsky (Peter Lorre) and meets their small band of title characters. Quintanilla wants Vincent to brief agent Jennings (Monte Blue) who is shortly embarking on a dangerous mission behind Nazi lines. Before this happens Jennings is murdered in Vincent's hotel room and the Dutchman is arrested for the crime. Believing himself to have been betrayed by the beautiful Irene (Hedy Lamarr) Vincent stages a daring escape from prison and resolves to get revenge on her. Before successfully completing his mission Vincent must confront Irene, convince his friends he is not a traitor, and destroy the true villain in their midst.

There are many interesting ideas presented in the film but they are hamstrung by a lackluster script credited to Vladimir Pozner and Leo Rosten (additional dialogue by Jack Moffitt). The story bears little resemblance to the source novel written by Frederic Prokosch and features a threadbare, episodic plot with a plethora of characters. Told in flashback by Vincent himself everyone is either following or being followed; spying or being spied on. The melodrama is supposed to be buoyed by an epic love affair between Vincent and Irene that falls flat in every way possible. They meet by accident and Vincent, evidently consumed by passion, spends much of his time impulsively chasing her to the point he bungles his one assignment and finds himself in prison charged with murder. Hard to believe this legendary underground hero would comport himself in such a way. Their romance is further compromised by woeful romantic patter and zero chemistry between the stars. Things finally heat up when he escapes from prison and the third act of the film reinforces the "duty before pleasure" theme that rang more convincingly in Casablanca.

Director Jean Negulesco crafts a visually compelling film with that unmistakable Warner Brothers milieu and, in many ways, trumps the vapid writing. The story moves from the glitz of the Cafe Imperio and Estoril to the seashore fishing village of Cascais, the countryside of Lisbon, the fog shrouded prison, and the clandestine digs of Quintanilla's conspirators. Unfortunately his presentation of the action scenes - Vincent's prison escape and the climactic pursuit of the traitor through the woods - are poorly rendered. The prison escape is particularly ludicrous as Vincent and his cell mate appear to be the only convicts in the place with only one guard on duty in the cell block; it's as bereft of employees as a modern CVS. On the other hand Negulesco crafts several tense dramatic scenes in the third act particularly the kangaroo court of his friends judging Vincent and the activity at the Estoril roulette table when the quisling is flushed out. Supporting all these moments is another wonderful musical score by Max Steiner whose haunting and melancholy orchestrations set the appropriate mood every time.

The unquestioned MVP of the film is the splendid cast that deserved better but manages to transcend most of the shortcomings and propel the narrative. Furnishing the eye candy Hedy Lamarr steps out of the friendly confines of MGM to headline this group as the glamorous Irene. While her acting doesn't set the world on fire she is beautifully photographed and looks luminous in every scene. Despite second billing Paul Henreid essays the lead role as the Flying Dutchman; another resistance legend along the lines of Victor Lazlo in Casablanca. Sadly he doesn't cut such a commanding, inspirational figure here and frankly looks absurd running around in his trench coat blowing up railway stations and Nazis. Henreid does have one great scene where he reveals how he transitioned from schoolteacher to freedom fighter that is arguably the picture's highlight.

The supporting cast is brilliant and chock full of familiar faces from Mask of Dimitrios: Sydney Greenstreet, Peter Lorre, Victor Francen, Eduardo Ciannelli, Steven Geray, and Kurt Katch. Greenstreet is the standout who pontificates in his signature style and sports a rather ostentatious necktie while Lorre is relatively wasted in the undemanding role of Bernazsky. Francen is wonderfully oily as Von Mohr whose allegiance is a major question mark right up until the climax. Making a complete u-turn in his characterization from the mousy Bulic in Mask to the intimidating Nazi Dr. Schmitt and doing a bang up job is Steven Geray who lords over Kurt Katch as his underling Lutzke. Inhabiting the subtly complex role of Police Captain Pereira is Joseph Calleia who must handle both warring factions with diplomacy but is an ally at heart; he delivers an authoritative and crafty performance. Fans of classic cinema will enjoy spotting two significant actors in minor roles: George MacReady in one of his earliest parts as a disgraced Nazi thug and Universal horror icon Edward Van Sloan as Vincent's contact who dispatches him to Lisbon at the start of the film.

The Conspirators was a flop in its day and endured a difficult production history including reported displays of temperament from its stars Paul Henreid and particularly Hedy Lamarr. Personally I adore this film mainly because of the unsurpassed lineup of Warner Brothers character stars who always elevate any project in which they appear. Furthermore there is always something comforting about any of the studio's films evoking a melodramatic, exotic atmosphere emboldened by a wonderful Max Steiner score. While this film might not be for everyone it should do the trick for those who love the Warners ambience as I do.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
following Casablanca
SnoopyStyle12 January 2019
With his homeland under Nazi occupation, Dutch freedom fighter Vincent Van Der Lyn (Paul Henreid) is forced to escape to Lisbon in neutral Portugal. He is surprised by French woman Irene Von Mohr (Hedy Lamarr) who seems to be hiding from the police. She turns out to be the wife of German diplomat Hugo Von Mohr. Vincent finds his way to local resistant leader Ricardo Quintanilla with the help of Polish fighter clock expert Jan Bernazsky (Peter Lorre).

This wartime espionage movie wants to be Casablanca. Henreid is a little too hard and too callous especially towards Lamarr. He's being a cad but a step too far from the combative romance that is needed. They are both trying too hard and not quite connecting. I want badly to love their relationship but there is something artificially constructed about them. Everybody is trying but nobody is succeeding. The noir shootouts have lots of fog. The casino gambling scene could be interesting if I can understand what they're trying to communicate with their bets. It's a fun idea but the execution can be better. If one can compare the dialogue with Casablanca, the difference in writing jumps right out of the screen. This is a broad melodramatic copy of its better.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very Good WWII Spy Movie
ricklomax2 October 2010
I really enjoyed this movie and it is one of my favorites for WWII intrigue. I consider this a sequel to Casablanca, taking off from where The Flying Dutchman left Casablanca and lands in Portugal. I liked enough that I bought the original book (searched and found it online). Definitely worth watching as it is also a good play on romanticism of the era.

During World War 2 underground movements all through Europe helped thwart the Nazi movement. In this movie a portrayal of the underground in 'neutral' Portugal is similar to what went on in Europe. Only one cheesy scene in the move, where a secret security camera is used. But that is a brief scene and does not detract from the film.

Because of this movie Paul Henreid is one of my favorite actors along side Sydney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre. My first viewing was on a Sunday morning when a local TV station aired the movie. Finally I was able to see it again and record from TCM.
18 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Hedy sparkles, Henreid smolders, Lorre skulks, and Greenstreet does a lot of talking in the anti-nazi WWII film that often gets compared to Casablanca.
cgvsluis26 January 2024
Tons of double talk in this Casablanca-esque WWII film starring Paul Henreid, Peter Lorre, Hedy Lamar, and Sydney Greenstreet. Paul Henreid plays Vincent Van Der Lyn, a Dutch school teacher in the Netherlands, who was arrested for teaching ideas counter to the German Nazi philosophy, he escaped confinement and became a disruptive freedom fighter during WWII. This lead to three years of hiding and performing such seditious acts as blowing up train tracks to break up the infrastructure. On the run from the Nazi's, he arrives in the neutral Lisbon as a stop over to reaching England where he hopes to join the Allied forces. One of Vincent's first stops on his Lisbon layover is a restaurant where he orders a meal he has been dreaming of for three years...a thick steak, white bread, butter, etc. Unfortunately at the restaurant he meets the mysterious Irene.

Irene Von Mohr, who is played by the lovely Hedy Lamar, is an enigma who sits down at Vincent's table and asks him to buy her a Sherry after her contact outside in the street is shot and killed. Using Vincent for cover in the restaurant, she uses him until the heat is off and then she gives him the slip out the back door. This begins an interesting relationship full of more double-talk and intrigue. Unfortunately, Vincent ends up in a Portuguese prison for a crime he didn't commit and adding to the depth of the plot line of anti-Nazi intrigue.

Hedy Lamar is gorgeous and the luminous pearls really show off her beauty in her initial scenes. Costume-wise I have to mention the spectacular (and I assume rhinestone) necklace that Hedy wear later in the film with a cluster of sparkly flowers on a black fabric band around her neck...it makes even her eyes sparkle in this black and white film. Paul Henreid, for his part, is equally handsome matching Hedy stride for stride in their budding romantic dance. Greenstreet and Lorre are their usual selves rounding out this cast of phenomenal actors.

If you are a fan of any one of the four leads, or a fan of WWII films, I would strongly recommend giving this a watch. It often gets compared to Casablanca and found wanting, but if you go in with an open mind...you might find the differences enjoyable. I liked the action scenes at the beginning as well as some of the subtler scenes like the young boy at the airport, the food order, fishing and sitting around a fire and while it isn't my favorite film, it is definitely worth seeing at least once.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I agree with Galygay--it just never seems to gel
planktonrules24 April 2008
This is a thoroughly adequate film and not much more. It was intended to try to capitalize on the success of CASABLANCA. Despite Warner Brothers trying to recapture the magic of this earlier film, THE CONSPIRATORS just can't compare--mostly due to a very poor script and some poor performances. Now the parallels to CASABLANCA are there but the film isn't a remake. Instead, it's a slight reworking of the ideas and a few plot points. Many of the stars in the film were actually originally in CASABLANCA (Paul Henreid, Sidney Greenstreet and Peter Lorr).

Henreid plays a Dutch freedom fighter who has escaped to neutral Portugal. His hope is to go from there to Britain, since he is a wanted man in Nazi occupied Europe. However, once in Lisbon, there is a long and complicated web of Nazis and anti-fascist operatives. Uncovering who were actually friends and who were double-agents was the main theme of the film.

As for Henreid and Hedy Lamarr, they are agreeable enough people but just don't have the charisma to make us forget Humphrey Bogart and Ingrid Bergman from CASABLANCA. Henreid isn't really bad--he just isn't Bogie. As for Lamarr, she is the weakest link in the film. Like so many of her films, she is essentially a walking mannequin--wearing lots and lots of expensive costumes (common for her films) but also delivering a rather flat and emotionless performance. Had the part been written more multi-dimensionally, perhaps she would have been a greater asset to the film. Aside from her beauty, she added little to the film--especially since her romance with Henried seemed to come out of nowhere and there was little chemistry between them.

As for the intrigue, it wasn't bad but it also wasn't particularly good. Plus, so many plot holes and inconsistencies made the film very slow going at the end. The finale seemed to drag and much of it just didn't make sense.

Still, this is a decent wartime film--not great, but a decent enough time passer.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed