The Sinners (1949) Poster

(1949)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
In the kingdom of Heaven,Duvivier reigns!
dbdumonteil27 November 2005
Kingdom of Heaven,what a title for a movie which takes place in a girls' reformatory! It has become difficult to find this Duvivier forgotten gem.It took me years and years of searching before finally laying my hands on a ebay second-hand video tape .Once more,I was stunned:in a career which spans -roughly- the first half of the twentieth century,Duvivier's works almost always appeal and they innovate too:probably influenced by Pabst 's "Tagebuch einer Verlorenen" ,"Au Royaume des cieux" predates such works as " the Magdalene sisters " by half a century!And that's not all:Orson Welles, who was a Duvivier fan ,found his "Othello"'s Desdemona here:Suzanne Cloutier plays an unfortunate girl,in state care,who is unfairly sent to the sinister prison.

Duvivier is the French master of the film noir,only equaled by Henri-Georges Clouzot.Never the Nouvelle Vague produced a single worthwhile film noir .

Duvivier always painted the darker side of the human soul:his world is all wickedness,evil and despair.However in "au Royaume des Cieux" some sunlight does break through.The heroine has a lover (Serge Reggiani) who tries to help her escape from this living hell.A tutor (Monique Melinand) shows some compassion.And the priest does too.But what can they do when a head warden(Suzy Prim) finally sees her dreams come true when the former one -a sensitive good old lady- dies and makes way for her.Suzy Prim portrays a shrew who hates men,probably repressed sexually -a scene between her and Cloutier reaches peaks of hatred and violence- who sadistically treats her girls.And let us not forget the dog's name Goliath (sic).In Duvivier's works justice is often meted out by one of these gentle animals: see also "Voici le Temps des Assassin" and "Chair de Poule"

Remarkable scenes: the hunger strike ,which the infamous Prim tries to break by bringing them a delicious soup (Duvivier's camera masterfully shows the hungry faces ,then the steaming pot);the prisoners turning around the anarchist's dead body (Juliette Greco!);the desolate landscapes the Police car which takes the heroine to the prison crosses;the impending flood which will become a transparent metaphor of the fever which rises behind the reformatory walls.The two estranged lovers ,whose dreams concur beyond a prison's walls.And the last picture which beats Truffaut's "les quatre cent coups" at its own game .

Perhaps an optimistic world ,which is unusual in Duvivier's work,since all these lost girls discover,through their mate's true love that ,they can hope against hope.

The cast and credits :the soundtrack consists of bells ringing louder and louder:MM Duvivier and Jeanson,hats off!
20 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fresh, modern 1949 film
gridoon202429 November 2021
This one is ahead of its time in some ways: it shares a lot of similarities with the Women-In-Prison cycle that came much later (including a lengthy, all-out catfight), while the conversations among many different characters who all speak almost simultaneously may remind you of Robert Altman! There is even a disaster-movie sequence somewhere in there. It's weighed-down a little by the love story between Maria and Pierre, mainly because Pierre is wooden (and too old for Maria). But Julien Duvivier's direction has several innovative bits, and the girls impress with their naturalism; those who played Didie and Margot are the clear standouts. The whole movie has an air of modernity to it ("down with the cops, long live the chicks!"). *** out of 4.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Denounce your comrade to fight evil,you redeem them without knowing it."
morrison-dylan-fan22 July 2016
Warning: Spoilers
With still having memories of uncovering Christian-Jaque's magnificent boarding school film Boys' School,I was pleased to find out from a DVD seller that they had recently tracked down a boarding school/reformatory-set title from Julien Duvivier!,which led to me getting ready to meet the sinners.

The plot:

Taken by police from her boyfriend Pierre Massot, Maria Lambert is ordered to spend the next few years at a girls reformatory.Warmly welcomed by the headmistress,Lambert is taken aback,when the headmistress drops dead on the ground in front of her! Always believing that the headmistress was ruling with a weak grip,teacher Chamblas grabs the now vacant job,and vows to keep all the girls in line. Wanting to show them who is in charge, Chamblas gives them all limited food,and punishes anyone who disobeys her orders. Believing in her heart that Massot is waiting for her,Lambert starts making her escape plan,whilst the other girls start planning their rebellion against Chambles.

View on the film:

Dedicating the title to "Unhappy childhoods",the screenplay by co- writer/(along with Henri Jeanson) brilliantly leaves any sign of "reform" behind in the dialogue,driven by the spiky,off the cuff dialogue from the girls.Along with the sharp dialogue,the writers also express a real attention to detail in giving each of the girls/teachers incredibly distinctive personalities,from hardliner Chamblas cracking heads with compassionate Guérande,to care-free Lambert joining the reforms with down-beat Rachel. Keeping a sense of sincerity at the centre of Massot and Lambert love, Duvivier uses the "reforms" to place Lambert in his Film Noir lair,where Chamblas blocks the girls from seeing any light,and Lambert has to put her hands out for a shard of hope.

Keeping Massot and a priest as the lone main male characters,director Julien Duvivier & cinematographer Victor Arménise undress the psycho-sexual tension standing at the gates,as ultra-stylish whip- pans dive into the repressed sexuality of Chamblas. Surrounding the reform school with a moat, Duvivier links the Film Noir shadows with an extraordinary Gothic (not Gothic Horror!) atmosphere,set alight by Duvivier dazzlingly tracking round the school like a closed-off Gothic castle,whilst the girls run to the water like a coven of witches,and Chamblas gets surrounded by "little devils",whilst the bells ring out on Duvivier's glorious Gothic Noir final shot out of the rotting swamp lands.

Largely looking at Lambert from the outside, Serge Reggiani (who made his debut in Boys School) gives a fantastic performance as Massot,whose long distance from Lambert Reggiani coats in a warm ,longing mood. Stomping round the yard, Suzy Prim gives a gloriously wicked performance as Chamblas,with Prim showing a clear joy in hitting everyone of battle-axe Chamblas's order. Desperate to escape from Chamblas long shadow,the cute Suzanne Cloutier (who surprisingly appears naked) gives an exceptional performance as Lambert,thanks to Cloutier bringing Lambert's aching heart for Massot to vivid life,and also wrapping Lambert with a striking thoughtfulness over helping out all the other girls trapped in reforms,as they enter the kingdom of heaven.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed