The Marshal's Daughter (1953) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Lots of potential with fair script and talented cast, but badly edited and directed
morrisonhimself9 August 2021
One of the great losses in Hollywood was Laurie Anders' making only this one movie.

She was beyond adorable. Another reviewer called her "innocently sexy," which is the perfect description.

She was very capable and with a better director, or at least better directing (William Berke has done better work other times), she could have shown herself a good actress.

She was capable in so much, including ventriloquism, jiu-jitsu, and riding, plus she attempted singing and dancing, which did not come across so well in this film.

But, seriously, just to see her makes watching this movie worthwhile.

Her romantic lead was the generally over-looked Harry Lauter, and it was a welcome change to see him in such a role.

Hoot Gibson is still the great Hoot, even in his relatively advanced age. He still showed he was a real cowboy, and still had that charm.

A mess of other people, including Ken Murray (who has to take the blame for most of what is wrong here), and including some great cowboys and a listenable band, fill out the cast, even if with just cameo and supposedly funny roles.

It's not a world-class movie -- except maybe for Laurie Anders.

Again, I have to repeat, what a sad loss not to have much more of her on film.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A curious film. See the notes at IMDb
JohnHowardReid24 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Copyright 21 May 1953 by Ken Murray Productions. Released through United Artists. No New York opening. U.S. release: 26 June 1953. U.K. release on the lower half of a double bill: February 1954. Australian release: 13 October 1955 (sic). Sydney opening as a support at the Palace. 6,372 feet. 71 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: A marshal (disguised as a medicine man) assisted by his singing-and-dancing daughter, tracks down an outlaw.

NOTES: Hoot Gibson's first feature film since Trigger Law (1944). He made only two more feature film appearances, The Horse Soldiers and Ocean's 11 (both 1960). Counting short subjects, Gibson appeared in at least 211 movies! Johnny Mack Brown's fourth last film. The Bounty Killer, Requiem for a Gunfighter (both 1965) and Apache Uprising (1966) completed his career.

COMMENT: A very curious film with flashbacks within flashbacks and even a sequence from one of Gibson's own rarely-seen silents. True, there are some marvelous action scenes, many composed of glorious if obvious stock footage, but others certainly appear to have been especially staged for this picture. But then again, some of the action footage is terrible stuff, particularly a night ride against an old codger's shack.

And as for the dialogue! All the old familiar clichés ride again. And the acting! Miss Anders displays little talent, either as singer or actress. She evidently hails from the small hive of nonentities engaged in American TV. Still, she does a lot of her own stunt work and is rather fetching to look at.

All in all, the film is worth seeing, but be prepared for a barrel or two of disappointments.

OTHER VIEWS: An indifferently constructed and poorly written western, which loses much of its effect by arousing our interest in one particular bad man, but then saving the kill for a new and uninteresting villain. - Monthly Film Bulletin.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Different kind of western
wlwelch27 August 2022
Am trying to find clear words telling why I liked Ken Murray's 1950s version of an ultra low budget 1940s poverty row western.

First, I liked the cast. Bob Duncan, an enigmatic b-western actor in real life, plays the bad guy, plus he wrote the script. Hoot Gibson had enough left to phone it in. Lauri Anders, another enigmatic figure, is Murray's protégé here instead of Marie Wilson, Murray's primary "Blackout" revue star. Harry Lauter plays his gratuitous role well enough, pretty much like he played all his roles.

Second, Texas Ridder sings some of the soundtrack as background instead of too far out front like it was in that Cooper/Kelly western High Noon. Third, an improbable poker game is inserted only because Murray wanted it, featuring "name" b-western players and Preston Foster, all friends of Ken Murray.

Last but not least, the cast plays it straight. No actor hambones it up, there are zero pretensions, everyone seems to be hitting their marks, and the sometimes erratic editing is not much of a distraction.

This is the third time I've watched it since i found it on the internet years ago. It reminds me a little bit of a Judy Canova movie made around then that is similarly low regarded but that I like. I.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
I guess Hoot REALLY needed the money.
planktonrules24 September 2020
According to IMDB, Hoot Gibson was perpetually in financial straits, as he seemed to spend money as soon as he earned it. As a result, he often took on any project. "The Marshal's Daughter" is clearly 'any project', as Hoot is clearly well past his prime...looking old and puffy instead of heroic. He is, after all, in his 60s...and he clearly looks it. Sadly, he's not even the star of this film...and he's there to clearly support Laurie Anders who plays the title character. As for Anders, she's kind of cute and sings and dances (not so cute)...but she hardly has the chops to be a leading lady in this sort of picture. After all, a western is supposed to be tough...and she just comes off as cute and a bit out of her league.

The plots involves the Marshal and his daughter seeking out the murderer of an orphan's grandfather as well as a local baddie who is trying to take over....and using the 'cattleman's association' to do so.

Seeing and hearing Laurie Anders do ventriloquism in the film, in addition to all her singing and dancing, made my skin crawl. To be fair, she was NOT the first to do this...as Tex Terhune made MANY films along with his ventriloquist dummy...but that ALSO made my skin crawl. But at least in Terhune's case, he starred in films where he was just one of a trio of good guys...and the other two helped balance this. But with Anders, the film is all about her and it seems as if producer Ken Murray is trying to show off her many, many skills...even if they aren't appropriate to the film...which they weren't. So instead of a watchable B-western, it's more a talent show featuring just Anders. Tough to watch...impossible to enjoy.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Rock-bottom "B", poor all around
fredcdobbs58 July 2022
Willliam Berke was a prolific "B" director capable of turning out tight, entertaining, well-made little pictures.

This is not one of them.

Everything about it is sub-par--the writing (laughable), the cinematography (dark and muddy), the editing (done with a dull chainsaw, apparently), the songs (the title song is especially sappy and juvenile) and lead actress Laurie Anders (for whom this as a vehicle) isn't up to it. She's cute, blonde and perky, but that only goes so far, and in this instance it doesn't go far enough.

It's not all her fault, though. Everything about this film is substandard. If Miss Anders was looking for a project to make her a star, she should have kept looking.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
This one's a mess
bkoganbing3 April 2019
Ken Murray comedian and now more famous as the guy who takes all those home movies of Hollywood in its golden era turned producer for The Marshal's Daughter. This film was created to showcase Laurie Anders from Murray's TV show. Anders was cowgirl trick roping artist who goes Victor/Victoria here.

Her day job is with Murray's medicine show. But by night she goes Zorro as a masked fighter for law and order in the old west helping her dad Marshal Hoot Gibson catch the one that got away.

I'm betting Murray cashed in a few favors to get this produced. Some friends did some cameos, Hoot Gibson was certainly way past his prime and wasn't getting movie offers. Tex Ritter sang some songs on the sound track.

The poker game with guests Preston Foster, Jimmy Wakely, Johnny Mack Brown, and Buddy Baer was the only bright spot in one dismal attempt at satire.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the most entertaining westerns ever !
bestark9 March 2008
I have found this movie to be one of the most entertaining westerns I have ever seen. It is funny even when it is not trying to be. An all star cast, last of the B westerns and it is, in a way, a parody of High Noon with the clocks and Tex singing about sorry starry midnight. The poker game is brilliant ! Every western theme is here except for a mining scene. Talk about flash-backs. Try to figure where you are at any time during the movie. The dance scene with Laurie and Frenchie is something I have never seen before or since. The theme song by Tex would be considered politically incorrect now days. The dual identity of Laurie is over the top. How could one not like this jewel ?
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An eclectic mix of parody, comedy and action--uneven but entertaining. A cute, catchy song and an innocently sexy heroine. It's all there.
guanche7 August 2002
Warning: Spoilers
This is the story of the motherless daughter of an undercover marshal (Hoot Gibson) operating a medicine show as a front. At night the girl secretly dons a black outfit, and, as "El Coyote" fights the bad guys. Of course, Daddy has no idea, and once they're vanquished she's quite eager to marry her boyfriend and be a full fledged girl again.

Though it's silly and corny in spots, the movie has good action scenes and some serious violence. This film is not as juvenile as the title might suggest. Both good and bad people die, and the Western atmosphere is not unrealistic. Laurie Anders "the daughter" is extremely attractive, both in looks and manner, (one of my earliest crushes in fact) and most of the other performances are quite good. However, producer Ken Murray's attempts at comedy (in the part of a gambler) fall flat for the most part. Although not overtly satirical, some of the scenes are played with tongue slightly in cheek, usually in an effective manner.

Hardly great cinema but very entertaining, both for young and old, with a good ballad style running theme song sung by Tex Ritter. Well worth your time.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Not that bad but I was deceived
searchanddestroy-15 January 2024
I began in a good way, it brought good expectations, it is not long, only seventy one minutes, but the result is lousy. I guess a director like Joseph H Lewis would have given us something far far better. It remains cute, agreeable, gentle, nearly an oater, not the best effort from director William Berke, who lost his energy on this film. A female lead was rare in those times, so we can admit this is daring. Now, female lead using guns is not rare any more. It remained a rare film since a long time and is now available on You tube. The quality is above average. So, to summarize, I still think that's a good little western for western buffs. But for the others, forget it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed