Oberstadtgass (1956) Poster

(1956)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The quarter as a family
semiotechlab-658-9544424 October 2010
Kurt Früh's "Oberstadtgass" - in reality the alleys and little streets around St. Peterhofstatt in central downtown Zürich - are a quarter of the Middle Ages. In 1956, most apartments are still non-renovated, have hardly any comfortable infrastructure, so that many poor people live here, while the other houses are inhabited by hand-workers. In the restaurant "Veltliner Keller" - today one of the priciest Zurich restaurants that serves exclusively high-style cuisine - the neighbors gather for a mug beer or cold Fleischkäse with mustard. From the movie it gets clear that only one family can be counted to the better-situated ones (Winterhalter). There is hardly circulation, the narrow streets are from cobblestone, people walk along steep stair-houses up to the roofs where they beat carpets and enjoy a little rest. Everybody knows everybody, the postman Jucker being naturally a central person. The old women gossip. When something extraordinary happens, the whole quarter knows it in no time. It is clear: Nobody is alone here, and even the nosiness of the neighbors testifies that everybody is part in a social network - qua social control. However, there are two exceptions. First the girl whom the postman does not know. This is explicitly said. She tries to commit suicide, but the sledge-hammer noise of the street prevent the old women from blowing up the story into a state occasion. Second, and mainly, there is Mäni Brändli, a half-orphan whose sick mother has to clean aborts in order to make a miserable living. The boy is tormented psychologically and physically by the other children, but he always manages to give them back - and unfortunately is as the only one perceived as being aggressive.

Postman Jucker and his wife had lost her one and only child, a boy, when he was 7 years old. When the sadistic Mr. Winterhalter intends to get Mäni's guardian, Mr. Jucker keeps the boy with him. However, this leads to big problems with his wife who connect overcome the loss of her own child. While this movie is a typical Schaggi-Streuli-movie (cf. "Polizischt Wäckerli"), its value, half a century after it was made, is mainly that it shows the enormous changing that Zurich has undergone in this decades. Where the lower-class people lived in their simple apartments, nowadays the richest of the rich live, all the apartments are fully renovated and brought up to a luxurious "standard". (A family apartment at St. Peterhofstatt costs today, in 2010, over 4'000 Swiss Franks, which is almost 4'000 dollars.) All the old restaurants still exist, but all have also changed into luxury establishments. It goes by itself, that the social cohesion between the families that live there is practically zero: one greets one another, but one would never stand together as they did 50 years ago in order to prove the innocence of the "abort-boy" (Hüüsli-Bueb) Mäni.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Forgettable everyday life drama
Horst_In_Translation3 April 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Let me start this review by saying that the almost 60-year-old film black-and-white "Oberstadtgass" starts really nicely with a pretty good rendition of "In allen Gassen wohnt das Glück". I also read that the movie is known by this title. Unfortunately, this is also the highlight of the film already. The drama that follows later on is fairly uninteresting. It lasts for slightly over 90 minutes and tells us about the struggles of a family with their son and with life in general. I am a German native speaker and I have to say that the Swiss German in here was really difficult to understand many times, so subtitles may have been useful. i doubt, however, that any exist out there. Another minus is that the soundtrack was way over the top. It was so melodramatic and over the top and it felt pretty ridiculous at times. So yeah, I know that Kurt Früh is one of Switzerland's most famous writers and directors, but this movie here does not really inspire me to watch more of this work.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed