Richard Brooks' 1958 adaptation of Fyodor Dostoevsky's iconic novel, "The Brothers Karamazov," has faced criticism for being superficial. Adapting an 800-page masterwork like "The Brothers Karamazov" into a film necessitates making choices, so it's best to evaluate the film on its own terms.
The story is set in 1870 Tsarist Russia and revolves around patriarch Fyodor Karamazov (Lee J. Cobb) and his three sons. The eldest son, Dmitri (Yul Brynner), is a passionate and impulsive army officer known for his gambling and perpetual debt.
The central conflict arises between the father and the oldest son when Dmitri accuses Fyodor of misusing his mother's inheritance, which was meant for him.
The character development for the other two sons, Alexei (played by William Shatner in his first film role) and Ivan (portrayed by Richard Basehart), is relatively less extensive compared to Dmitri's arc. Alexei, a kind-hearted monk, and Ivan, a progressive journalist and staunch atheist, play significant roles in the narrative but receive comparatively less focus.
Alexei, despite his limited development, embodies a compassionate and principled nature as a monk. His presence serves as a moral compass amidst the turmoil within the Karamazov family.
On the other hand, Ivan's character takes on greater prominence as the catalyst for tragic events in the latter half of the second act. As a progressive journalist and an atheist, Ivan challenges traditional beliefs and becomes instrumental in driving the narrative towards its darker turns.
While the film may not provide equal development for all the Karamazov brothers, the presence of Alexei and Ivan enriches the narrative by introducing contrasting perspectives and highlighting the diverse range of ideologies within the family.
The film's focus on Dmitri's relationships with two women, Katya (Claire Bloom) and Grushenka (Maria Shell), drives much of the narrative. Katya becomes infatuated with Dmitri after he helps her father out of a financial bind, but it is unclear why she falls so deeply in love with him. Similarly, Dmitri's attraction to the flighty Grushenka is puzzling, as she frequently changes her mind and even considers rekindling an old flame.
The film provides a moment of comic relief when the esteemed Father Zossima (William Vetter) is called in to mediate the dispute over the inheritance between Dmitri and Fyodor. However, the scene takes an unexpected turn as Fyodor embarrasses the priest by hurling crude insults and invectives at his own son.
The plot gains momentum when Fyodor's servant, Smerdyakov (Albert Salmi),, plots to murder Fyodor and frame Dmitri for the crime. Smerdyakov, driven by jealousy of Fyodor, orchestrates a meeting between Grushenka and her old army flame. Unaware of Smerdyakov's scheme, Dmitri mistakenly assumes that Grushenka has returned to his father's embrace. Filled with anger and frustration, Dmitri confronts his father at the family home.
During their confrontation, Fyodor launches an attack on Dmitri, but despite the provocation, Dmitri resists the urge to retaliate. However, in the chaos of the altercation, an elderly servant inadvertently suffers an injury, and Dmitri, mistakenly believing he has killed the servant, is overwhelmed by shock and guilt.
Later, when the police arrive, Dmitri experiences a mixture of relief and surprise upon learning that the servant has survived. However, his relief is short-lived as he is shocked to find himself arrested for his father's murder.
Smerdyakov, cunning and calculating, has executed a plan to secure the perfect alibi. Prior to the murder, he pretends to have an epileptic seizure in the cellar, establishing a false timeline that shields him from suspicion.
The ensuing events involve confrontations, mistaken assumptions, and a surprising change in conviction by Ivan (Richard Basehart), who suddenly embraces a belief in God.
The trial becomes a foregone conclusion for Dmitri, especially after Katya betrays him during her testimony. The notion that Dmitri pays a bribe to prison guards and escapes Siberian incarceration appears to be a clichéd Hollywood ending.
Ironically, it is Smerdyakov who eventually confesses to the murder, claiming that he committed the act on behalf of Ivan. Smerdyakov was initially influenced by Ivan's initial admiration for a godless world devoid of moral constraints, which left a lasting impression on him. However, Ivan's newfound embrace of God serves as a catalyst for Smerdyakov's admission of guilt.
As Ivan's philosophical beliefs undergo a transformation and he grapples with the implications of his ideas, Smerdyakov's confession becomes a significant turning point in the story. The revelation highlights the unsettling realization that Ivan's earlier musings had inadvertently sparked a chain of events that led to the murder and the subsequent cover-up orchestrated by Smerdyakov.
The irony lies in the fact that Ivan, who initially championed a godless world without moral boundaries, unintentionally becomes entangled in a web of guilt and accountability.
The film adds a sentimental resolution to a subplot, as Dmitri finds redemption by apologizing to a dying child whose father was humiliated by him over a debt.
Yul Brynner and Lee J. Cobb shine in their respective roles, benefiting from well-developed characters. Claire Bloom portrays Katya with regal poise, while Maria Shell's portrayal of Grushenka is hindered by odd facial expressions that aim to capture her character's inconsistent nature.
Albert Salmi delivers a standout performance as the villainous Smerdyakov, which is ironically overshadowed by a real-life tragedy involving Salmi and his wife years later.
As an introduction to the classic novel, the film manages to hold our interest despite the lengthy romantic entanglements. While flawed, "The Brothers Karamazov" is worth at least one viewing.
0 out of 0 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
