"The Goodies" The Goodies and the Beanstalk (TV Episode 1973) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Ah! The Goodie Olde Days......
Rob_Taylor27 December 2004
Well, I just watched this again in a rerun homage to the 70's. I have to say, that, apart from costumes, this has aged rather more gracefully than many other comedies of the era, such as Blazing Saddles.

The humour isn't particularly clever, or witty. It's just fast and furious. As a result, few gags are overdone (are you listening Mr Brooks?) and the pace is quite frenetic at times.

The main thing which distinguishes the humour of the Goodies from virtually any other show or movie, is the insanity of it. Only the Airplane movies came anywhere near it for irrationality and craziness, and even then, they are only a pale shadow compared to what the Goodies were capable of.

The most startling thing about the Goodies were the songs. Most of the shows, including this film episode, had some sort of song, usually accompanied by the most dire of effects and animations. Yet despite the hideous awfulness of it all, it still makes you smile in a way that the capering antics of, say, the Wayans Bros. never will.

To say much about the Beanstalk episode would be to ruin it for those that haven't yet seen it, so I'll stay quiet about specifics. Suffice to say you'll have no trouble spotting the many references to other films thrown in for comic measure.

In short, the Goodies was madcap fun that we will never see again - not because it isn't considered funny anymore - but because nobody can do it anywhere like as effortlessly as the Goodies did.

Enjoy!
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Like The Curate's Egg - Goodie In Parts
PurpleProseOfCairo28 December 2004
I saw this, as our other contributors probably did, during a Channel Five (UK) evening of "seventies" Christmas themed programmes (including a 1983 Morecambe and Wise Show!) I've been waiting for years to see some Goodies - I remember falling about laughing at them in the early seventies (I was born in 1957) - as they seem to have fallen off the radar. This episode perhaps illustrated why (though if some of the dreck from the same period gets a showing on satellite, why not this?). I didn't think it had aged well. The most glaring illustration of this was the Man Friday briefly glimpsed - Afro, bone through nose - it simply wouldn't be acceptable nowadays. Ditto the mild sexism seen from time to time, and the depiction of the Italian It's A Knockout team as Mafiosa who shoot each other when the contest starts.

Aspects of it were very original, and still very funny. Oddie was a silent comedy buff and seemed to try to shoehorn a lot of that sort of material in - again, in these days of X-Boxes and David Brent, there just wouldn't be an audience for it now.

The visual gags during All I Want Is You (animals singing) were brilliant for those CGI-less days, but the freezing cold quarry they obviously filmed the location scenes in was a poor representation of Katmandu! (Hardly their fault, but it brought back memories of Dr Who, where exotic, far-off planets always looked like a quarry in Devon in November!) I will certainly investigate the DVDs as a result of having seen this and read the comments. For all its faults, The Goodies displays a refreshing lack of cynicism.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
"Kids' programme!"
ShadeGrenade28 November 2008
Warning: Spoilers
As far as I - and millions of other British kids - were concerned, 'The Goodies' could do no wrong in 1973. We lapped up each new series ( including repeats ), laughed at the comic strip in 'Cor!', and us lucky ones got the 1974 Annual in our Christmas stocking. Such was the level of interest in 'The Goodies & The Beanstalk' that people were raving about it before it had even been shown.

How, I hear you ask? Simple. B.B.C.-2's trailer was composed of a generous chunk of the climactic bird attack. After seeing the lads dive bombed by golden-egg laden geese to the sound of the 'Dambusters March', there was no way any of us were going to miss the actual show.

It was their first attempt at a Christmas Special, though the previous year they had put out 'The Goodies' Five-Minute Travelling Christmas' as part of 'Christmas Night With The Stars'. Here they got to do a whole show based on the old fairytale 'Snow White & The Seven Dwarfs' ( according to the opening credits ).

Tim, Bill and Graeme have fallen on hard times. After failing as buskers, they decide to sell their only possession - Buttercup the three-wheeled bicycle. Bill is lucky to get a tin of beans for it. Graeme plants one, and lo and behold, a beanstalk shoots into the sky.

Pursuing it across the channel to France, they become contestants on 'Jeux San Frontieres' - the European version of 'Its A Knockout' - , hosted by the late, much-missed Eddie Waring ( often the target of Graeme's impersonations, he was a good sport for doing this. Note the huge cheer he gets when he appears! )

Surviving various obstacles, such as having coconuts thrown at them by Man Friday and swinging on a rope over a tank of piranha fish, they climb the beanstalk. Somewhere in the clouds there lives a giant, and when I tell you he is played by diminutive Alfie Bass I need say no more.

Its impossible to list one outstanding funny moment from this - there are so many. The dancing copper, Graeme switching on a plant to read a book at night, the beanstalk crashing into the B.B.C. Centre where Corbet Woodall ( great guy! ) is reading the news, the spoof ad offering puppies as prizes in a competition, Tim eavesdropping on female nudists ( hope Mrs.Whitehouse never saw this bit ), the lads' singing in a canyon and creating wonderful echoes, Bill trying to encourage hens to lay golden eggs and instead getting a brick, Alfie Bass bellowing 'fee-fi-fo-fum' through a loudhailer, the 'Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?' song number with the lads dressed as the Marx Bros., and of course, the aforementioned finale which also features Alfred Hitchcock and a giant hobnailed boot. All capped by a fabulous cameo from John Cleese as a genie!

Bass had earlier appeared in the 'Camelot' episode that opened Season 4, though as a different character. This is I think the best of his performances. He is a little man pretending to be a giant, and gets some cracking lines: "Have you ever tried cleaning a ten-foot high toilet bowl? Come to think of it, have you ever tried using one?".

I cannot remember what else was on telly on Christmas Eve 1973, but I doubt whether it was outstanding as this. It was the work of three top-flight comedians at their peak.

It went down so well it was repeated several times in the course of the decade, and was the first 'Goodies' episode to come out on video. Channel 5 showed it as part of a Boxing Day '70's comedy theme night ( now why don't they do that anymore? ) in 2004. I do not know what first-timers made of it, but I thought it stood up well. Times may change, but fairy tales thankfully do not.

The Goodies had a couple of Season 4 episodes left to see us into the New Year, but were largely absent from our screens in 1974. When they returned a year later, however, it would be with a bang.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Somewhat Dated But Still Amusing
Theo Robertson8 January 2005
I had given up on ever seeing an episode of THE GOODIES ever being broadcast on British network TV . Apparently much of their humour would today be classed " racist " and I have seen clips where the cast use variations of the N word which would no longer be allowed on British television nowadays so it was something of a shock to see Channel 5 broadcast THE GOODIES AND THE BEANSTALK at Christmas

I was looking forward to watching this again and could recall seeing it as a child . To be honest though much of the humour has somewhat dated with a fairly long early sequence similar to THE BENNY HILL SHOW where there's no dialogue , only a muzak soundtrack as the eponymous goodies try and make some money after falling on hard times . As with all the goodies sketches there's a policeman involved and a scene that will have the PC brigade falling out of their chairs since it might be classed as " homophobic " . There's a sequence later featuring a competition involving puppies " And remember if no one wins the puppies they'll be sold to Indian restaurants " and a sequence featuring a savage done up as Man Friday , but nothing that will cause great offence to someonewith a sense of humour . The only criticism I have about the humour of THE GOODIES AND THE BEANSTALK is that it's maybe a little too cartoonish and surreal for a modern day audience who think THE OFFICE and FRIENDS is the be all and end all of comedy . The goodies might have have been unsophisticated but they still remain amusing

There is one other thing I noticed while watching this that might be classed as criticism and that's the laughter track - It's too intrusive . People complain about the canned laughter in things like I'M ALAN PARTRIDGE , LITTLE Britain but it's just as bad here which goes to show it's not a modern phenomena
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Inconsistent fairytale silliness.
BA_Harrison3 December 2011
Having fallen on hard times, The Goodies decide to sell their beloved bike, but all Bill gets for it at the market is a tin of baked beans. Graeme has a moment of madness and plants the last bean, which grows into a giant beanstalk that leads the guys to the top of Mount Everest, where they discover a giant's castle and a room full of birds that lay golden eggs.

The first part of this 1973 Christmas special, in which the penniless trio struggle to survive, is pure TV gold, featuring perfectly executed scenes of comedy genius that rank as some of the finest funny moments in the history of the BBC. With the use of minimal dialogue, Graeme Garden, Bill Oddie and Tim Brooke-Taylor create classic moments that rival even the greats of silent cinema (the sequence where Graeme prepares for bed on a park bench is sheer brilliance!).

Sadly, once the fantasy element kicks in, the quality quickly goes downhill, first with some weak Benny Hill style farce, and then a poor parody of 70s game-show It's A Knockout. A brief musical interlude in an echoey canyon provides some welcome giggles, but from thereon in, it's relatively mediocre stuff, with poorly edited singing animals and a desperate finale featuring dive bombing, golden egg laying geese that simply tries too damn hard.
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed